4 ms·
The critics may genuinely have had a different view. I loved TLJ. IMO it was a clever, challenging film - much more so than the usual generic superhero movie.
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
The critics may genuinely have had a different view.
I loved TLJ. IMO it was a clever, challenging film - much more so than the usual generic superhero movie.
It had some flaws, but I didn't find it disappointing. But I can completely understand why it might infuriate and disappoint long-time fans.
Which view is correct?
The problem for critics and for creators is that there's no such thing as "the audience.' There are overlapping demographics with different expectations and different abilities to handle challenge and complexity.
If you make something too clever or challenging it slides off the bell curve and "the audience" - the median consumer - hates it. If you give the median consumer what they want and never challenge them, you get bubble gum and potboilers.
I used to know someone who made a nice living writing romantic fiction. It sold very well, because he was clever enough to hit the right tropes and write very consistently to the correct formulas - none of which is easy.
His fiction was well reviewed, but he hated it so much he had to give it up because he couldn't bear to do it any more.
Bottom line is there's a difference between product and art. Product is purely about sales to the middle of the bell curve. Art is about being original, challenging, and creative, and maybe even about having some fun while making it.
If product gets better consumer reviews - and it reliably does - does that make it "better", or not?