3 ms·
If you read the comments you’ll see that there’s no evidence of Yacob’s existence prior to the 1800s and Italian scholars came to the conclusion in the early 20
by barry-cotter 9y ago
If you read the comments you’ll see that there’s no evidence of Yacob’s existence prior to the 1800s and Italian scholars came to the conclusion in the early 20th century the whole thing was a forgery. It might be real but it would be unwise to base any serious efforts on this without at the least carbon dating of an original manuscript.
- wahern 9y agoI suspect you're overstating the conclusion that it was a forgery. I cannot see enough context to determine the source, but FWIW, ... The first argument is that Giusto d'Urbino himself clearly indicated that the manuscripts are not of his own. And I do not see any reason why a European thinker of such caliber produces such a refined philosophical work and at the end ascribes it to some 'Ethiopian Philosopher' that never existed. I could not possibly think of any not to believe Giusto d'Urbino himself who tells us clearly that he bought the manuscripts. ... The second argument is linguistic in nature. Here we should note that Giusto d'Urbino, though he did manage to learn Ge'ez, was in no position to write such a manuscript. Still some accept the fact that Giusto d'Urbino could have dictated his ideas to an Ethiopian scribe who could have captured his ideas in refined Ge'ez. Yes, even the argument does not hold true. You see there is a manuscript--Les Soirees de Carthage de Francois Bourgade. Both Giusto d'Urbino and his Ethiopian Scribe write this manuscript. The first part is written by Giusto d'Urbino himself and the second part by his clerk. A thorough study of these writings by a prominent instructor of Ge'ez literature at Addis Ababa University, Alemayehu Moges, has clearly indicated that, primarily, Giusto d'Urbino's writing in Ge'ez is full of mistakes. The scribe's writing was found to be free of errors but the type of languages used by Giusto d'Urbino scribe and the language of Zara Yacob were completely different. This clearly shows that neither Giusto d'Urbino nor his scribe could have possibly been the author of the manuscript that I strongly insist to be of Zara Yacob. Excerpt of quotation from Teodros Kiros, "Zara Yacob: Rationality of the Human Heart", pp148-149 (https://books.google.com/books?id=z4-HgXftrcYC&lpg=PA148&ots=urDBIoK23z&dq=yacob%20d%E2%80%99Urbino&pg=PA148#v=onepage&q=yacob%20d%E2%80%99Urbino&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=z4-HgXftrcYC&lpg=PA148&ots...)
- wahern 9y agoHere's a book review which seems to summarize the controversy: https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01284505/document https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01284505/document (The review author advocates forgery.)