6 ms·
From what I gather, some of this is cultural. His country of origin is just generally blunt and direct about things. That directness is generally associated wi
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
From what I gather, some of this is cultural. His country of origin is just generally blunt and direct about things.
That directness is generally associated with multicultural environments where subtler context-dependent communication simply does not work. Some of the quotes I am seeing here from him are things I think are unnecessarily harsh, but most are not.
Discussions about something he has said or written seem to inevitably comment on his speaking style and divide up between those who praise it and those who vilify it. I feel it is mostly a positive, but discussions could benefit from a little context and broader perspective of that detail.
- Fnoord 9y ago> From what I gather, some of this cultural. His country of origin is just generally blunt and direct about things. I've heard this blunt(/direct/honest) argument quite often (and the same about my country, The Netherlands), but I've also seen Americans in IT who can be very blunt. I attribute it not to country_of_origin, but to the [autism] spectrum.
- jackaroe78 9y agoWhiteabootism
- mar77i 9y agoWhatabautism
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI am not autistic. I have spent a lot of time around the American military and I tend to be direct. Anytime someone suggests that my directness means I must be autistic, they are a) making a faux polite personal attack that calls me a social retard and b) looking for an excuse to ignore and dismiss the substance of my points. I don't consider it to be a good faith form of engagement.
- Fnoord 9y agoNobody called you autistic or a social retard. It is a spectrum as well, some people with autism are far more socially retarded than others. If you want though, you can call me autistic. I take no offence at that, not in the last place because I have a ASD diagnosis. What I said, is that I find autism another [plausible] explanation. Because being honest/direct/blunt is a trait people with ASD suffer from (since they have less of the social awareness which puts the brake on the sharp edges). I find it more plausible than country_of_origin (TBH I find that a -perhaps harmless- form of discrimination/racism), but certainly I did neither imply nor argue that it is the only, sole explanation!
- Clubber 9y agoI'm not autistic but I'm blunt. I do it for a few reasons: 1. It's important, 2. It saves time, 3. It gets to the point, 4. I'm usually aggravated about something, 5. Some people like to dance around conversations, 6. I'm older now, so I don't suffer fools lightly, 7. It usually snaps people to attention instead of some half thought out reply. I used to try to be tactful with everything I would say, but that ended up in a 4 hour discussion / argument with someone who was digging in their heels about something they were wrong about. Huge waste of time and energy. It would blow a whole day. When someone is being blunt with me, I take the time to make sure my response is clear and concise. It certainly has it's advantages. I try to keep the swears to a minimum. I'm not a drill sergeant, but I definitely make my point clearly and forcefully. FWIW, I save the bluntness for important stuff.
- digi_owl 9y ago> FWIW, I save the bluntness for important stuff. As to Torvalds, but we do not get headlines about his mellow emails accepting a patch.
- jerf 9y agoThere's another explanation too, which is that if you pay attention as you age, you find that nicely wrapping up all your engineering points in a polite wrapper can very easily put you into the unenviable position where half your audience doesn't correctly penetrate the circumlocutions to understand what you were trying to say, while the other half goes right on ahead and gets offended anyhow, because what they are offended by is that you are disagreeing with them at all, no matter how much padding you put on that. I'm probably still too verbose (ha... "probably"... I flatter myself), but I went through a phase in my late teens and early twenties where I qualified and wrapped in polite circumlocutions everything I wrote. It makes in incomprehensible, honestly, and it doesn't work anyhow. I still got flamed. (Good ol' Usenet.) There's a time and a place for politeness. That time and place is most times and most places. There's a time and a place for directness, bluntness, and even outright impoliteness; I'd submit "Intel is just going to leave a critical vulnerability in basically every CPU in the world, and throw up an obfuscating cover of flags and workarounds and PR to try to pretend otherwise" is a reasonable time for those things. (Personally, I don't expect miracles. Intel ought to come out and say "Look, this is going to take some years. Here's some workarounds in the meantime, and here's our plan going forward." I think everyone who understands the situation understands that a true fix is very difficult. But if it looks like they're going to try to skate by on some weak workarounds and a heavy dollop of PR, the industry as a whole really needs to pushback, not just Linus.)
- dpark 9y ago> ... I've also seen Americans in IT who can be very blunt. I attribute it ... to the [autism] spectrum. Please stop. It's unhealthy to pretend that undesired behaviors in IT are generally the result of autism. It perpetuates an unhealthy culture by essentially saying that guys (because it's only guys who are excused this way) in IT are not responsible for their behavior. It's also insulting to people with autism to lump their legitimate social difficulties in with people who are simply choosing to be assholes. If a salesperson or marketer or artist or executive is blunt/rude/an asshole, no one assumes it's because they're autistic. It's assumed that this is part of their personality, because they find it more effective to communicate this way (or in some cases, that they're simply bullies). There is no indication I see that Torvalds is autistic. He's certainly not socially awkward. He manages an organization of thousands of contributors very effectively. If he's blunt or rude, it's because he chooses to be.
- Fnoord 9y ago> It's unhealthy to pretend that undesired behaviors in IT are generally the result of autism. Not what I did; no need to start bifurcating. What I asserted (or, what I meant) is that people on the spectrum are more common in IT. I never said that everyone in IT is autistic. I never argued Torvalds has autism. > It perpetuates an unhealthy culture by essentially saying that guys (because it's only guys who are excused this way) No idea where you got either of these red herrings from. That's certainly not what I asserted. I do want to note though that women with autism largely go un(der)diagnosed. > It's also insulting to people with autism Hi, I have autism, as I acknowledged in another post throughout this thread. There's a rule on HN that you shouldn't assume the worst explanation from a post. Well, you just did, cause why would I willingly try to insult everyone with autism if I have it myself? How that make any sense whatsoever? I don't see at all why my post can be considered offensive unless you resort to things like bifurcations... > It's also insulting to people with autism to lump their legitimate social difficulties in with people who are simply choosing to be assholes. People with autism need to function in a non-autistic society. The current therapy I am getting is focussed on that. Using autism as an excuse isn't acceptable; its considered counter-productive. > There is no indication I see that Torvalds is autistic. He's certainly not socially awkward. He manages an organization of thousands of contributors very effectively. I don't find him very strong, socially. Read his body language while he's giving a talk. He's shy, at the very least. Just because someone can express themselves easily via e-mail doesn't mean they're not socially awkward. Also, what I quoted is not mutually exclusive. More importantly, there is no such thing as a binary autism flag; it is a spectrum. What Torvalds suffers from is that he expresses his anger with unnecessary cursewords in order to give his arguments strength (a fallacy). To name another example: I've never seen RMS do that, but I have seen TdR do that. I find neither of them particularly strong socially, either.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thriftwy 9y agoI'm not sure. Finns (and swedes) are considered introverted, with shoegazing issues. That kind of directness looks like a personality trait (acquired maybe) and not default.
- wingerlang 9y agoI don't think introverted is the right word. Our culture just doesn't do a lot of stranger-chit-chatting.
- ptman 9y agoThe apple does not fall far from the tree.
- tome 9y agoI'm not sure you replied to the correct post since it didn't really seem to be about Linus's style. Anyway, this argument comes up again and again. Regardless of the style in his country and language or origin he is writing in English, in public, for an international audience. One expects a different sort of tone.
- tauntz 9y ago> One expects a different sort of tone. I don't think I can agree with that statement :) I'm part of the target audience and that tone is _exactly_ what I'd expect instead of polite talk that dances around calling out BS for what it is.
- tome 9y agoThe merits or demerits of that tone are another issue. I'm responding to the claim that Linus uses that style because it's the style of the country he comes from. I don't think that argument holds much water.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThat isn't remotely what you initially said.
- tome 9y agoYour argument was > From what I gather, some of this is cultural. His country of origin is just generally blunt and direct about things. and my response was > Regardless of the style in his country and language or origin he is writing in English, in public, for an international audience. Which parts of what I said seem inconsistent to you?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSaying that you expect a different tone because he is currently writing in English, in public, for an international audience is not the same as saying that his culture of origin in no way influences his communication style. That's like saying because my mother is now an American citizen, she should obviously no longer have a German accent. You may personally feel she has some obligation to do her best to lose the accent, but regardless of the standards you would like to see imposed on other people, most people remain influenced for life by things they grew up with.
- Yaggo 9y ago> From what I gather, some of this is cultural. His country of origin is just generally blunt and direct about things. Maybe he just is what he is. The differences between individuals are greater than differences between cultures. I'm from Finland and I can assure you that Linus' style of communication is not a norm here.
- slii 9y agoAs a fellow Finn, I agree that our country is probably much more blunt and direct than the impression I get how the US works. That's also the way I like it, and I think you have gone way too far in the US in this politeness thing. However, Finland is culturally quite homogeneous, so I think the reason behind the bluntness is not what you suggest it may be. For a Finn, I think Linus is on the blunt side, but he's not an extreme case. In fact, I'd argue he's not an extreme case even among non-Finns; it's just that most people only hear about his rants. Also, I find that Linus is somewhat quick to judge things, and often his reactions are based on a misunderstanding of the facts.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThank you. Low context communication is associated with multicultural environments, but not exclusive to it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-context_and_low-context_cultures https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-context_and_low-context...
- mmrezaie 9y agoWell many years ago his rational (which I agree) was that you should not be vague on the mailing list or people will be confused and Linux Kernel is serious. For all those who do not like this attitude, I point you to the responses coming from Intel/AMD these days. In AMD's response to specture v2, I still cannot understand the text if they say their CPUs are exposed or not. If it wasn't because of the comments in here I would have guessed that they may not.
- Gravityloss 9y agoThere could be a family flavor too. His father doesn't exactly make things sound pretty either.