7 ms·
Math Lessons for Locavores
- desigooner 16y agoAnother NYT Article on this theme talking about "food miles" http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/06/opinion/06mcwilliams.html http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/06/opinion/06mcwilliams.html Here's Will Wilkinson on why eating Local may not better http://marketplace.publicradio.org/display/web/2008/08/27/eat_local/ http://marketplace.publicradio.org/display/web/2008/08/27/ea...
- tptacek 16y agoCouple things here: * First, it's not true that the overriding concern of "locavorism" is energy conservation. Other concerns include food quality, the survival of small farms, highlighting the bad practices of huge corporate farms, and animal welfare. * 80-90% of the "value" of these ideas you can capture by eating only what's in season (ie, no fresh tomatos in February) and sourcing protein from small farms. Both of these things: you want to do anyways. * "Locavorism" doesn't support the notion that we should grow oranges in Wisconsin so they can be local. No, the Alice Waters types think people in Wisconsin shouldn't be eating many oranges at all. It's true that Locavorism is on the cusp of becoming more a yuppie religion than a valid principle. It's certaintly true that industrial farming is more energy efficient. Maybe it's right that the word "Locavore", which is stupid, be tainted by association with this trend. But let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater. Small family-owned farms carefully raising high-quality cows, pigs, and lambs are a very good thing. Restaurants that can tell you name of the farmer who raised the lamb on their menu are a very good thing. Seasonal cuisine is a very good thing. These ideas don't have to be "locavorism"; maybe they can just be common sense.
- evgen 16y agoWhile "food miles" may not be the overriding concern of most locovores, it certainly seems to be the favored argument they use most often to justify various actions and decisions; of the various concerns you listed energy conservation is the one that is easiest to try to quantify. Since this particular point is one that will, by definition, almost always be won by the locovore side they tend to drag it out more often than they should (especially because it is a point they subsequently lose on when the bigger picture is examined.) Personally, I think locovorism is way past the point of no return in terms being nothing more than a means for yuppies to distinguish themselves from the hoi polloi. Once you could get organic veggies at Wal-Mart they needed St. Pollan to give them a new rallying point. I live in the bay area and from the vantage-point of this mild climate it is very easy to enjoy local seasonal food with almost no inconvenience to my lifestyle. I grew up on the midwest on one of those small farms you praise (back before shipping arugala around the world for my local salad bar was common or even possible) and I can tell you with certainty that seasonal cuisine in that climate really sucks.
- patio11 16y agoOnce you could get organic veggies at Wal-Mart they needed St. Pollan to give them a new rallying point. Highlighted for emphasis. Virtually every trend in marketing food to the middle class is "Don't eat that. Poor people eat that. You don't want to eat like a poor person, do you?" The big picture reasoning for that is here: http://www.ers.usda.gov/AmberWaves/September08/Findings/Charts/Findings2_fig02.gif http://www.ers.usda.gov/AmberWaves/September08/Findings/Char... The dollar cost of the inputs to what might be called "traditional food" is cratering, due almost entirely to technological improvements. A 2010 tomato resembles a 1970 tomato, but costs much less. If you ate like someone in the 1970s ate, you would spend much less of your total income on food than they did. That would be a very negative outcome for some players in the food industry. Hence, trying to tell you that your 2010 tomato is not really the same tomato as that 1970 tomato your mother used to make pasta sauce with. It is a magic poisoned GMO tomato. Your mother, if she was still making you pasta sauces, would certainly be using good natural organic local tomatoes. Since your mother doesn't still make you pasta sauces, you can pick up a morally appropriate pasta sauce at Trader Joes for a mere five times the price of the same ingredients with a different label at WalMart. (The change in who cooks and how much is the story behind the story of American food consumption in the last two generations.)
- tptacek 16y ago"GMO" is a red herring. When it comes to produce, the problem isn't that it's mass-produced and it isn't that it's mutated with secret Monsanto DNA. The problem is that huge companies have conditioned the market to believe that tomatoes are something you get in the bin 15 steps forward and 5 steps sideways from the entrance to the supermarket, in the big bin labeled "vine-ripened tomatoes", when in fact tomatoes don't work that way, and anything you put in a bin labeled like that must, by necessity because of the way supply chains work, be a fake wax replica of a tomato even when good tomatoes are available. The problem is not that poor people eat tomatoes. The Fresh Markets supermarket 3 blocks north of me serves a solidly lower-lower class market (I live next to Austin, one of the poorest neighborhoods in Chicago, a "food desert") has better produce than Whole Foods does. Poor people, particularly Hispanic poor people, do veg really well. The problem is that the Del Monte's of the world are replacing real tomatoes with fake tomatoes. That is bad. It's not a class warfare issue.
- maukdaddy 16y agoI can't upvote Mr. Ptacek enough here. I am a member of a meat CSA that's local because I can go to the farm and see how the animals are raised. I buy veggies from the market here in Chicago because I can go to the farms and see how they're growing the produce. While lowering the energy factor is a bonus, it certainly isn't the reason I eat mostly local food. I eat local because I want to know how animals are treated, ensure that animals aren't bloated with corn feed, and to ensure that I'm not eating chemically (ammonia) laced meat. It's also important to put money back into your local community. If I spend $50 at a chain grocery store, very, very little of that is going into the local economy. If I spend $50 on meat from a local farm, all $50 is going to the local economy. PS How's the 1/2 pig?
- tptacek 16y agoIt looks very impressive but I haven't started cooking with it yet; I will report on it shortly. Erin and I are planning on cooking through Ruhlman's _Charcuterie_ and reporting the results. I can't recommend Slagel Family Farms highly enough; they were just awesome to deal with.
- maukdaddy 16y agoI need to try some of their products. My monthly CSA is Cedar Valley Sustainable Farm and I supplement from Mint Creek (amazing lamb) and some others from around the area.
- snth 16y agoAre local economies somehow more worthwhile than distant economies? I don't quite understand that argument.
- tptacek 16y agoThey are if you want to build a life in your local community. But that aside: a small, high-quality farm in Nebraska is just as worthy of support as a small, high-quality farm in Wisconsin. The problem is, a small, high-quality farm anywhere is more worthy of support than Cargill. Patronizing local farms instead of supermarkets means less of your money goes to Cargill. That's a good thing.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- hugh3 16y agoBut let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater. Small family-owned farms carefully raising high-quality cows, pigs, and lambs are a very good thing. Sure! So can large farms owned by huge companies raising high-quality cows, pigs and lambs. And small family-owned farms raising crappy animals are a bad thing. I'm not sure why we should be focusing on the size and ownership of the farm at all.
- tptacek 16y agoWhat huge company produces high-quality pork? Quality protein doesn't scale.
- jknupp 16y agoI'm no locavore, but for an article with the word "math" in the title, the following breakdown seems a bit silly: Overall, transportation accounts for about 14 percent of the total energy consumed by the American food system. Other favorite targets of sustainability advocates include the fertilizers and chemicals used in modern farming. But their share of the food system’s energy use is even lower, about 8 percent. The real energy hog, it turns out, is not industrial agriculture at all, but you and me. Home preparation and storage account for 32 percent of all energy use in our food system, the largest component by far. Well, fine, but ceteris paribus you've just shown that transportation and fertilization do, in fact, make up a not insignifcant percentage of food production cost. Why would you add in the cost of home storage and preparation, which (presumably) will be the same for everyone?
- sp332 16y agoThey're not the same for everyone. If you do your dishes in the sink more often, eat your veggies raw more often, open your refrigerator more often, your energy use might be lower than if you started optimizing for transportation costs instead.
- aplusbi 16y agoA better point would be that home storage costs are the same for local foods as they are for shipped foods.
- sprout 16y agoActually possibly worse, since shipped foods are engineered to last longer without spoiling, and they go through a lot more quality control than what you pick up at the market, so the ones that spoil quickly often don't even make it to you.
- fhars 16y agoActually, if you do your dishes in the sink, your water consumption will be four to ten times and your energy consumption up to four times higher than in a modern dishwasher, see table 2 on page 9 of http://linusov.info/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/eedal_03_manualdishwashing.pdf http://linusov.info/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/eedal_03_manu...
- kragen 16y agoAt present we grow enough grains alone to satisfy the caloric needs of about 20 billion people. Agriculturally, we are living in a post-scarcity world, unless the population triples again, and we have been for forty years. What we need in agriculture today is not more efficiency, but more resilience and more justice in the distribution of the results. It is inexcusable that today, forty years since the end of food scarcity, poor people starve to death every day while steers are fatted on corn and soybeans for the rich. Through efficiency, we've achieved a post-scarcity world. Now we need to achieve a post-poverty world. Efficiency is not going to get us there. Locavorism might promote greater resiliency; but does it? Does the long-distance and international food trade ameliorate or exacerbate the privation of crop failures? Do small, local farms produce less fertilizer runoff per acre than big agribusiness operations? (Historically, in first place, with the most agrochemicals applied per acre, has been the suburban lawn.) Is locavorism an effective hedge against new pests devastating monoculture crops? Does it effectively break down hierarchies of richer and poorer regions by reducing long-distance exploitation, or does it reinforce them by keeping the money of the rich close to home? I don't know. But when you're sitting in a fancy restaurant, pondering whether the lamb on the menu, priced the same as 100 kilos of soybeans, comes from Niman Ranch down the road or from a giant ranch in New Zealand — don't delude yourself into thinking that that's a serious food policy issue.
- tptacek 16y agoLet's see if we can't get locavorism to address nuclear nonproliferation, while we're at it. Jeepers. Whether we should be eating more or less meat, whether meat should be priced massively higher or not, why can't we agree that most other things being equal, we should eat better meat when possible? Cargill meat is inflicting all the same imbalances on the world food market, and loading our food with antibiotics while still increasing foodborne illness, and reducing the overall quality of our meals. Niman Ranch, for what it's worth, is a consortium of independent small farms spread all over the place.
- kragen 16y agoAs far as I can tell, there's no connection between the structure of the food supply chain and nuclear proliferation. On the other hand, locavorism consists of advocacy of a particular structure for the food supply chain, which necessarily has profound implications for all attributes of the food supply chain, including resiliency, affordability, and environmental impact. It isn't obvious to me which way those implications run, but I am claiming that those are the important aspects to investigate, not energy-efficiency or flavor. I agree that big meat producers like Cargill (and, apparently, Niman Ranch) harm resiliency and the environment. I think that your questions, like how much fecal contamination is in your meat, and how it tastes, are rounding errors when compared to questions like how much farmland had to be saturated with ammonium nitrate to feed it, how much methane it emitted, and how much downstream spinach was contaminated with Salmonella — from a public policy perspective, that is. As long as a substantial number of people in the world who are starving to death, many more people are eating meals of very low overall quality and suffering serious illness as a result. This is the important issue. You're right about Niman Ranch. Thanks for the tip. They had me fooled; I thought Niman Ranch was a ranch in Marin County, California. I didn't realize they were a nationwide marketer of grain-fed feedlot-finished beef (it explains this in the FAQ on their web site) and that Bill Niman now refuses to eat Niman Ranch products!