6 ms·
Wow, this explains so well why I despise Eurogames. Instead of eliminating opponents, everybody plays until the end after some arbitrary score limit is reached
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
Wow, this explains so well why I despise Eurogames. Instead of eliminating opponents, everybody plays until the end after some arbitrary score limit is reached (or turn limit or whatever).
I play Dominion or Catan and I'm working away and suddenly somebody says "game over! I won!" and I'm thinking, well that was a waste of time. I'm resentful and frustrated - what did I do all that for if it ends at such a meaningless point?
- thriftwy 9y agoBut it's realistic. These days you don't get to eliminate your opponents. What you do is endless rat race on tiny margins. Plug: "Epic Spell Wars of the Battle Wizards" are pretty awesome if you insist on elimination.
- arno_v 9y agoYeah,Epic Spell Wars is awesome!
- LearnerHerzog 9y agoLooks fun— that artwork reminds me of the show "SuperJail" https://goo.gl/Sc12Qb https://goo.gl/Sc12Qb
- detaro 9y agoAt least with Dominion, I'd say that predicting when the game is ending and adjusting your play is an important part of the game. And unless it's really one-sided (which sucks, and maybe there is an argument that Dominion lends itself to develop one-sided games without recovery) or whoever you are playing against is keeping mental count of everyone's point (which wouldn't be impossible, but I've never met someone actually bothering to do it) they won't be able to say "I won" before everyone has counted out their points.
- vkou 9y agoGiven that points tend to come from provinces/dutchies/etc, it's pretty easy to keep mental counts. When you've bought half the provinces in a three player game, and are not behind on dutchies, it's often safe to predict that you won the game, before any card counting.
- jonreem 9y agoWhen I play I always count victory points - how do you know what to do if you don’t know how many points people have or how close the game is to ending? Adjusting your play during the course of the game as the game gets closer to ending is a crucial part of the game. If you’re surprised when the game ends you weren’t paying enough attention!
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoExactly. I was paying attention to people at the table, to activity, to eating and drinking and socializing. You know, what you do while 'playing a game'.
- tnzn 9y agoHow is that meaningless ? Do you also consider races meaningless ? Do you consider most sports meaningless ? You probably don't like it because that's not how you learned to enjoy games, not because it's inherently worse than Ameritrash
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoSports don't stop the race randomly because somebody has found 'victory points' under their chair. Payers' efforts are rewarded with clearly recognized progress (down the field/on the scoreboard). There are time limits and buzzers and some sense of tension. Not just grind along and then, randomly, 'its over, and you lost'.
- sirclueless 9y agoIt sounds like you just haven't properly learned to account for the strategy of the game, or are not correctly tracking win conditions and using them to inform decisions. If you just blithely play out a self-centered strategy and are somehow surprised when Charlie claims the Longest Road card and declares himself the winner, then sure it might feel disappointing to lose. Instead try to be aware that for the last two turns Amanda has been 2 ore away from completing her last city and winning, but someone would need to roll exactly a 9 to do it on her own, while Bob has already completed all his cities but is unable to build more roads and Caroline is staying one Knight ahead of his army size through the help of Amanda giving her resources for the greater good. Maybe your win-con is going to have to be to steal Amanda's longest-road card and build another settlement which is gonna be a long shot but maybe given Amanda's desperation for ore and everyone-but-you's unwillingness to trade with Bob, you can do it. Maybe you can beat the odds and come from behind, maybe you can't, but either way an abrupt "it's over you lost" can never happen -- only someone executing their win-con better than you did, with the table unable to stop them.
- tnzn 9y agoIt just seems you play german board games as if you were a tenisman who doesn't count points and is surprised when we tell him the set is finished.
- k__ 9y agoI think a good game lets everyone play till the end AND gives them the opportunity to win at any time. Otherwise you lose too early OR have to look at the rest of the crowd winnig...
- IntronExon 9y agoMonopoly is like that, and your point dovetails with the tendency of that game to end abruptly when someone quits in a rage. Who wants to spend dozens of rounds slowly, yet inevitably losing?
- arkh 9y agoHere is the trick: gang up on the current winner. Playing with at least 3 or 4 players most games become more about diplomacy and getting other players to do what you want than getting good roll / cards. A good trick is to get hit hard at the start of the game (when you win a lot it is not hard to be a target) then once someone start getting ahead focus everyone on them while retelling how everyone fucked you over early-on. When you get in a position to win start speaking less to not attract any attention, don't use flashy combos. Then win. If you play a lot, learn how one game can help you for next one: if don't break your promises or help someone when they need it; you may get some help next game. Or people will be a lot more willing to trust you, until breaking this trust can give you a win.
- Yen 9y agoI'd like to specifically advise caution with the "gang up on the current winner" strategy. One the one hand, yes, it can make games more fairly balanced. It works well when a) all players are roughly on the same skill level, and can independently agree on who the current winner is, b) players are all playing to win, and c) players are willing to recognize that it's still just a game, and not take losing personally. It can fail hard, though, and make a gaming experience more miserable. "retelling how everyone fucked you over early-on" reinforces the negative parts of the game play experience, and eventually you get people arguing over who's been screwed over worse. You get players who've had a strong showing arguing that "I'm not really the leader", and feeling singled out and attacked when they inevitably get ganged-up upon. Except then it's not merely their perception - the other players have discussed ganging up on them! My immediate family is almost entirely board game enthusiasts, but arguments of that variety have almost driven apart that board-game-playing shared interest. Games such as Settlers of Catan are effectively banned, since they're really hard to prevent from devolving into "who got screwed over more" arguments.
- quink 9y agoAssuming that you really consider the destination to be the goal rather than the journey, Splendor and Patchwork are two highly rated cheap games that while they don't eliminate players early have no hidden information and transparent scoring as you go, with quality iOS apps if you want to try that first. I think the downvotes you're getting are unjustified, yours is a valid opinion to have. Player elimination games can be excellent, but IMO mostly only if they're short. Love Letter is a great example. King of Tokyo/New York and Loopin' Louie are two others I have. Player elimination is a pretty good mechanic for short games, so I'm reading your comment as more of a perfectly legitimate complaint about long games with hidden information rather than a lack of player elimination.
- StephanTLavavej 9y agoSplendor has a small bit of hidden info - when you blind reserve a card, you get to look at it, but it stays secret from other players. However, blind reserves are very rare, so you’re basically accurate.
- Karrot_Kream 9y agoDifferent people play games differently. On the converse, I find a game with elimination to encourage petty behavior and find the overall experience of longer games with big elimination mechanics to be arbitrary. I'm glad that Eurogames give me a chance to play without all of us attempting to specifically undermine the other.
- techsupporter 9y agoI agree with you to some extent, at least if the game does it poorly. "Points reached, game over" is the only quibble I have with the two-player version of Agricola, "All Creatures Big and Small." The end game condition is reached far too quickly for my tastes so I wind up asking the other player if he or she would like to have a "house rule" of more points.
- labster 9y agoUpvoted because everyone is entitled to their own preferences in games. It's wonderful that the world is full of such different people. Also, I'm not definitely inviting you to my gaming group.
- adamredwoods 9y agoHe's probably a grognard.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoI host a gaming club. We're in test for 5 games. They vary from simple card games to collectible sets to party games to complex deck-building board games. They all have one thing in common: they're social. You play with other people, rather than in the same room as other people. I've watched some family members play Catan every holiday for years. They sit in virtual silence for 2-4 hours, all looking grim, hardly speaking. When its over, they seem relieved and exhausted. Its depressing. Our club games have people talking constantly, laughing, chanting, enjoying themselves to the limit. They're fun. And that seems to me to be a critical threshold to deserve inclusion in the category 'game'.
- newen 9y agoIt depends on the group that you're playing with. Catan with my family is fun because we chat the whole time, try to get each other in trouble, etc. Quiet time is pretty rare in Catan for us. Actually the one game that really tells you the character of a group is Codenames. In certain groups, the entire game is super serious and quiet with lots of time spent on thinking, while in other groups the game is fun and filled with discussion and jokes and so on.
- dagw 9y agoI get your point, but allow me to offer a counterpoint. A game I can play (and win) without concentration or any real mental effort is a dull game. Sure playing the games can be a lot of fun with the right people but then they're fun despite the game and not because of the game. The game itself is just a catalyst for social interaction (which I guess in itself is a perfectly valid scale to judge a game on). However I believe that if it's a great game I should also be able to enjoy playing it in virtual silence against complete strangers. Ironically I consider Catan a game that is mainly fun because of the social interaction the results from it. And that seems to me to be a critical threshold to deserve inclusion in the category 'game'. Is chess a game?
- pwinnski 9y agoIt is fascinating to me that something you hate about Eurogames is what I love most about them. Vive la différence!
- Pxtl 9y agoBecause you aren't thinking about the game right. Victory is elimination. Watch the other players like a hawk, keep an eye on everybody's score, and orchestrate a pile-on when somebody gets a visible lead. Try playing some of these group games like Carcassonne or Splendor in a 1v1 format. 1v1 strips away the chaos and makes every victory a corresponding defeat, and teaches you the mechanics in their barest form. Then you come back to a big 4-player table with a newfound grokking of the game.
- yesenadam 9y agoCouldn't you equally say that about games where everybody plays until the end after some arbitrary time limit is reached? Like uh football (of all kinds), basketball etc etc etc - most games/sports.
- mcv 9y agoIf you don't see the end of the game coming, you're not paying attention. In any case, the sudden end is better than the drawn-out torture that is Monopoly.
- lmm 9y agoA "build your own thing" game always needs a point at which you draw a line under it and count up and decide who won. The better games will find a way to at least vaguely integrate it with the theme - e.g. in Keyflower you play through Spring/Summer/Autumn/Winter, in Barbarossa you play until someone captures Moscow. Still, even for a straight "first to 10 points" or "play 5 rounds", to my mind the positives outweigh the negatives. If you play until all but one player is knocked out then a) most players are gonna lose in a very personal, direct way b) players who've lost have to find something else to do while the game finishes c) there's no way to predict or plan how long the game's going to go on for. A lot of competitions involve a fairly arbitrary limit - why run for 100m rather than 110 or 90? Why play football for 90 minutes rather than 80 or 100? Why do 18 holes of golf rather than 17 or 19? Why drive 3 laps in Mario Kart rather than 2 or 4? Sometimes all you can do is find a point at which to draw a line under it.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoSure its nice for everybody to be in it until the end. I guess I object to a race that ends when somebody steps on a crack seemingly randomly, and the one with the most bling on their vest then wins. Its the part about 'you have to come up with something to end it'. The theme breaks down then. Makes the game seem unfinished, like they couldn't think of some reasonable way to wind it up so they just gave up. Pandemic ends when you contain the plague, or it kills everybody. You talk and socialize and cajole until the end, with everybody. There's a well-made game.