6 ms·
I know the standard reaction from a lot of HN folk will be to celebrate this progress: it's faster, more efficient, and no one likes to waste time waiting in li
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
I know the standard reaction from a lot of HN folk will be to celebrate this progress: it's faster, more efficient, and no one likes to waste time waiting in line.
Still, though, I think Amazon's automation of the retail experience is helping to create a society where there is even less real social interaction, and I think it's a factor (if even a small one currently) in the increasing tribalism in American society.
Throughout history, "the marketplace" had been one of the major centers of interpersonal interaction, and these days for many people it's possibly to completely avoid ever having to go to the store. I'm not sure that's a great thing.
- threatofrain 9y agoThe marketplace today is hardly the place for meaningful interaction, whether with employees or other shoppers. What it seems like to me is unpaid emotional labor. To have interesting social time, we need less hours at work and more public (non-commercial) spaces to meet. For example, where are children supposed to meet?
- dennisdamenace 9y agoI often learn a lot at the check out lines here in Oregon. People chat, exchange information. Often banal, sometimes valuable. Always nice.
- hn_throw2 9y agoI'm sorry, but it's completely unclear how nice chats do anything to resolve "American tribalism", or, more pertinently, why it's the responsibility of marketplace owners to generate squares of social interaction at all. Even if this slight increase in social interaction did anything ("cash or credit?" -- "Credit, ma'am"), that's as ridiculous as fixing race conditions with sleep() calls (hehe, race conditions).
- 1024core 9y agoWhy use a throwaway account? But to answer your comment: the comment was not about the chit-chat with the cashier, but other people in the line.
- hn_throw3 9y agoI am genuinely afraid of any even modestly political claim being publicly attached to me ("it's not the marketplace owner's responsibility" has a libertarian flavor to it).
- melq 9y agoNice chats don't have to resolve 'American tribalism' to be worthwhile.
- hn_throw3 9y agoSure, they might be worthwhile in isolation, but the context from the GGP was that they're worthwhile enough to worry about Amazon Go (by being a valuable source of interpersonal contact during times of "increasing tribalism").
- degenerate 9y agoI can confidently say that's _not_ the case in most urban areas.
- 1024core 9y agoI dunno. Yesterday at the Farmers Market, I was shopping for produce (salads) and had a conversation with 2 different women. The first offered advice on what to pick, and their health benefits. The second, in turn, was the recipient of my limited knowledge. I live in San Francisco.
- not_kurt_godel 9y agoIf those supposed health benefits aren't real or are misrepresented, which I would guess is likely, then that social interaction was a net negative for society.
- sotojuan 9y agoMost HN users live in urban areas. Here in NYC your average check out line is people on their phones and/or with headphones on. And before you say NYC is an outlier, it was the same when I lived in semi-rural suburban Texas.
- rainbowmverse 9y ago>> Most HN users live in urban areas. I didn't know YC published HN's demographics. Do you have a link?
- isitwhatitis 9y ago>80% of the American population lived in what is called an urban area in the 2010 census [1]. While their definition of urban is looser than you might use, still >60% lived in 'cities'[2]. Unless the wealthier, more connected, more educated readership of Hacker News strongly bucks every trend suggested by their demographics, it's pretty safe to say we mostly live in urban areas. [1]https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-what-does-urban-really-mean/1589/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-w... [2]https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2015/cb15-33.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2015/cb15-33....
- mulmen 9y agoHow do you know HN is made up of only Americans?
- wyager 9y agoThis is a regional cultural thing. I’ve mostly noticed it in ethnically and linguistically homogenous areas. Absolutely not the case in most American urban centers outside of the northern US.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y ago> The marketplace today is hardly the place for meaningful interaction, whether with employees or other shoppers. While I somewhat agree with you, I still think that by taking away the need for millions of people to have lots of little banal interactions, we're also erasing the possibility, on a society-wide scale, of more meaningful interactions that sometimes spring from those trivial little conversations.
- bsbechtel 9y agoSocial time with the freedom to choose how you spend it allows individuals to congregate into their own tribes and pursue interests pertinent to them. Forced social interactions that are the byproduct of other necessary transactions are how we learn from others unlike ourselves.
- MR4D 9y agoYour comment is spot on. Being in line at the DMV is probably the best example I can think of this. I'm usually waiting for a while, and chatting with whomever is next to me. Not unusual to be an interesting conversation with someone I'd have never otherwise spoken to (and probably vice versa).
- threatofrain 9y agoSome people here talk about conversations struck up waiting in the check-out line or at the DMV. I think that is the exception rather than the norm. Just the like bus, or airplane are other forced scenarios, but I think people who strike up a conversation are the exception and not the norm, and I would suspect that they have been down-trending for awhile. What people call "tribalism" I would re-frame as class structuralism. People might segregate themselves by class via Whole Foods vs Walmart, but that doesn't mean people are striking up conversations within-class or between-classes. That doesn't seem very "tribal" versus what American Christians have; rather it seems loosely coherent. And again, I would ask whether a commercial space is really the best place going forward. I am struck by the number of places a young person wouldn't feel like going without a credit card.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- morgante 9y ago> What it seems like to me is unpaid emotional labor. Are cashiers not paid?
- mlevental 9y agodo you think that they're paid to be nice or paid to scan your groceries?
- djsumdog 9y agoI agree. I hate this idea of "removing social interaction." People complain about everyone on their cellphones in the mornings. However if you look at videos from the 1970s and 80s, no one interacts on the trains back then either. They've all got their newspapers and magazines and the nerdy kids have their walkmans. Today it's no longer nerdy to listen to music, everyone has earbuds in and your newspaper and magazines are all easily accessible on tiny little screens which use a lot less paper.
- Kalium 9y agoI understand how you feel that way. It feels like Amazon, and others, are creating a wholly atomized society. Where people exist without having to admit that other people exist. Where people are stripped away from society for profit. But... what if I want that? What if I don't want to be coerced into social interaction, every day, just so I get get my basic physical needs met? What if I want to engage with society and humans on my terms, rather than on yours? Who gets to decide? I welcome this because it gives me another choice. It moves me one step further away from the coerced-social-interaction experient you envision as heavenly and towards a world where I get to make one more of the choices that matters to me.
- srtjstjsj 9y agoYou might be right, or your view might lead to social collapse. Society has been functioning for millenia; it's not clear that can work without people talking to each other. For an HN-pertinent example: If no one wanted to put together a company, would anyone have a job? Can computers really mediate all human interaction? If so, why are social connections so important in building a successful tech company?
- dannyw 9y agoThe difference might be that you could enjoy your conversations and outings with your coworkers, but less so when you’re grabbing groceries at a supermarket.
- int_19h 9y agoConversely, society has been function for millennia, despite all the crazy things that humans have done before - as we change, it adapts. In fact, who is to say that the present typical amount of social interaction is optimal or even generally desirable? It's a function of our society and its tech today, it didn't come up on stone tablets from the heaven.
- Kalium 9y agoYou might be right! It is, indeed, possible that letting people choose to talk to one another instead of coercing them into it may lead to the destruction of society. But, consider. If letting people talk to one another - or not - as they choose rather than as some would-be society-engineer decides leads to social collapse, what will actually be lost? Is so fragile a system really worth preserving? I submit that it may not be. Personally, I don't require that computers mediate all human interaction. I do rather like having a choice, though.
- sotojuan 9y ago> Throughout history, "the marketplace" had been one of the major centers of interpersonal interaction If you shop at Whole Foods, Target, Trader Joe's, Kroger, etc. this has never been true for you, unless by social interaction you mean handing your card to the cashier or asking someone a question. Even in my local, family owned grocery store I don't see this "marketplace" attitude. I doubt it exists anywhere outside of small communities nowadays in the US. Most people work 8 hours a day and hang out at home or in bars/coffee shops; we don't really want to hang out in a marketplace. Note that I don't disagree with your overall point... I just don't think this is a good example.
- icebraining 9y agoI'm not in the US, but yeah, the supermarket experience here is not a social event. In fact, cashiers will get annoyed if you start making small talk. My small local corner store is different, but then again they won't be replaced by an app anytime soon, exactly for that reason.
- saurik 9y agoWhile it might not have been a particularly "deep" interaction, I definitely got to know my favorite checkout person at Whole Foods, knowing what he used to do, keeping each other up to date on new things we were doing, and even following his move from being a checker at Whole Foods to being a manager at another nearby store. I miss the person who used to work at the Staples who always lit up my day when I needed to buy paper.
- themagician 9y agoIn the future you can just buy a crate for $4.99 that could unlock any one of 10 unique alert sounds that will brighten your day when you checkout! And for $9.99/mo you can subscribe to the feed of your favorite restocker and get daily updates about the food their eating and the cute dog they saw on the way home or how great their butt looks in yoga pants! You can even send them creepy messages up to 10 times a month if you have the premium sub (which is only an extra $2.99).
- goldenkey 9y agoI don't bother the opposite sex while shopping. But when it comes to just normal convo about good foods that me and another shopper are both buying, it's usually a short-lived "Isn't that ice cream awesome?! Hi five!." Nothing profound but I can see the positivity from even a small event of mutual love for the small things in life. :-) I will admit though - Whole Foods and Trader Joes' employees are some of the nicest and down to earth people I've ever met. They definitely add to the experience of shopping. But it appears that Amazon still has those type of people that will roam the store - just not cashiers. And they are probably a lot more grumpy and treated like crap, 'cuz Amazon.
- srtjstjsj 9y agoIt's funny to call them "down to earth", when they (especially TJ's) are performing a DisneyWorld-like entertainment role enforced by corporate leadership.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tuna-piano 9y agoI think you're right, and I haven't seen the answer from our society yet. If you can sit at home and get things delivered (which is easier and addicting), you do miss out on different experiences (some good, some bad). You can imagine a world where many of our storefronts could empty out. If you work from home, get Amazon deliveries, go to school online, etc... what will you do and what storefronts do you need? Are bars, restaurants and barbers enough? One of my favorite anecdotes that makes me think... has our whole society evolved incorrectly? "In 18th-century America, colonial society and Native American society sat side by side. The former was buddingly commercial; the latter was communal and tribal. As time went by, the settlers from Europe noticed something: No Indians were defecting to join colonial society, but many whites were defecting to live in the Native American one."[1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/09/opinion/the-great-affluence-fallacy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/09/opinion/the-great-affluen...
- freehunter 9y agoThe example is obvious if you actually step outside your door. Anyone can get anything delivered at any time of day or year, so other than going to work, there is no need right now for anyone to leave their house, ever. But funny enough, if you go into any downtown area, any park, any waterfront, any restaurant, they're busy. Abnormally busy, based on the fact that, again, none of them have any need to be there. Turns out that when you relieve people of the burdens of things they have to do (like grocery shopping, which is oftentimes tedious and boring), they now have more time and energy to do things they want to do. Instead of forced interactions at the grocery store, they'll go to a park and talk to people they actually want to talk to. Instead of spending an entire day going to Costco and shoving their way through the crowds, they visit a boutique store and stop for coffee at a local cafe. Some of the comments in this thread are quite curious. Bemoaning the death of tedious chores and banal small-talk like these are things the general public actually enjoys doing rather than merely tolerates out of necessity.
- tuna-piano 9y agoGood point! Cities are doing great worldwide, and few seem like they lack people doing stuff. But of course you don't see the people who are at home or in the suburbs (shudder). Loneliness and solitude seem to be growing as well. Maybe worst in Japan, but the problem also exists worldwide. http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/11/asia/japanese-millennials-hikikomori-social-recluse/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/11/asia/japanese-millennials-hiki...
- freehunter 9y agoI think the standard HN reaction isn't to celebrate this, but rather to bemoan how technology takes us further from some non-existent utopian ideal where rose-tinted glasses replace reality. Like how "real social interaction" only exists at a supermarket checkout lane. So your comment checks that box perfectly. Whining about the death of tradition is basically the "free" square in Hacker News Bingo.
- Kiro 9y agoThe revolution here isn't self-checkout. In my country most stores already have that, which means all social interaction is eliminated already. So your argument is less about Amazon Go and more about self-checkout. The revolution is that you don't need to scan any items yourself or do anything at all. Just pick your items and go out.
- devoply 9y agoThe revolution is more about Amazon getting into grocery shopping. What they are hoping to do with this concept is to create an automated store that can be supplied via there warehouses. So that with minimum effort they can run grocery storefronts all over the United States and take over that business as well.
- pacaro 9y agoThe revolution is in how you spend your time. On an ordinary day when you know what you want for lunch, it can take under a minute to pop in and get it, under 10 seconds if you’re in a hurry.
- ballenarosada 9y agonone of these things are a "revolution"
- pacaro 9y agoYeah, revolution is definitely hyperbole, but from experience it does change the way you think about “popping into a store” because it really can take so little time. This can be both good and bad; you can pick up lunch in a hurry without that frustrating 5 minutes waiting to pay, but on the other hand you can also pick up a chocolate chip cookie between meetings far far too easily.
- misterbowfinger 9y agoInteresting, I saw this as the opposite. Without the existence of centralized checkouts, retailers can craft totally different experiences for shoppers. It's in their best interests to keep shoppers in stores for longer. A great example is wine tastings at Whole Foods locations - it's clearly a social event within a grocery store. I'd say there's going to be even _more_ opportunities for social interactions at grocery stores like Amazon Go. To your point, though, the "marketplace" you're talking about is the ambiguity between the consumer and the worker, aka Marx's point about the commodity fetish. That's something that's existed since the late 1800's, though. I don't think that's going away anytime soon. Although I can see something similar to a farmer's market run in the same format as Amazon Go. I haven't thought through all the edge cases yet, but it feels like a solvable problem.
- ricardobeat 9y agoHere in Amsterdam I can step into the supermarket, pick and scan items with my phone, put them on a bag, pay with contactless and leave without any human contact. I’ve been doing this multiple times a week for the past 4 years, so nothing new. I think you’re dramatising what is a natural step as shopping evolves with technology. If you value social interaction you can always spend more time with friends you appreciate, go to public spaces, head to the bar. The supermarket has hardly ever been a source of good times anyway.
- bko 9y agoYeah, marketplace is great for "interpersonal interaction", except for tourists or people unfamiliar with the societal norms of the market. In that case, they're often getting ripped off or slowing down the process for everyone. Not as relevant for supermarkets but I think the overall trend of seamless and transparent transactions make (almost) everyone's lives better off.
- zackmorris 9y agoI think the word is "provincial". Thanks for making that connection for me, that our lack of personal interaction is leading to the extremely polarized views we're witnessing. I almost feel like whoever finds a way to connect us all in real life without staring at a screen is going to make a billion dollars (and save the world or whatever).
- wdr1 9y ago> where there is even less real social interaction Good? I'm an introvert. I don't value random, superficial interactions with people I'll never talk to again. In fact, they cause me anxiety & I dislike them. I do value the time with a select group of people. And by reducing the time I spend in the supermarket it allows more of the human interaction I do value. My social group has a wide assortment of views, from Muslim to Catholic to Athiest, to #TrumpTrain2020 to #NotMyPresident. I've never witnessed nor heard of people having meaningful discussion with the checkout clerk. I've never seen nor heard of someone, after that brief interaction, saying "You know, you're right. I'll reconsider my position on the person of the opposing political party." The statement marketplaces may have been true when we in the barter system, but it certainly hasn't been president in modern society for sometime. And I say that as someone who grew up in a town of 2,000 in the 70s and has lived in a large urban area for the last 20.
- snowwindwaves 9y agoMy mom shopped at the same grocery store for 30 years. Some of the cashiers lived in our neighborhood, and we would see them every time we went grocery shopping and sometimes around the neighborhood. The cashiers knew me by name from when I was a baby grocery shopping with my mom. I suppose it depends on what you call a meaningful discussion, but seeing the cashiers was like catching up with a friend. This was in Ottawa so not a small town, and I'm in my late thirties now.
- exolymph 9y agoYour mom's experience is not typical.
- 1024core 9y ago> a society where there is even less real social interaction, Every time I shop at my favorite store, I encounter InstaCart employees more than regular shoppers.
- jchw 9y agoTechnology is not an issue related to this problem. Bigger corporations in general make this inevitable. How meaningful of an interaction do you have with the tired cashier at Walmart or any other big retailer? Even at Trader Joes, the few minutes of interaction are rarely meaningful, even if I try to make them so, and that is the absolute best example. Small talk is not that engaging. Even more so, technology for not having to interact with cashiers ever already exists: the self-checkout system. If I walk into a chain store like Meijer, people will be piled up at the self-checkout even if there is a completely free human cashier waiting for customers! But even so, people are not checking out to socialize. Even what they do say isn't so substantial. Things move too fast, there's too many customers and too little time. How often do you remember the name of your cashier? How often are they still working there a year later? Amazon's store actually represents a potential departure because as they say, they introduce humans in ways they think will improve the customer experience. Quote: >“We’ve just put associates on different kinds of tasks where we think it adds to the customer experience,” Ms. Puerini said. So there are people. And those people, with their hopefully less hectic roles, are almost certain to interact with customers in ways that will be more meaningful than the overworked cashier with a line of 10 carts and a full bladder. And perhaps, if the job doesn't suck (unlike many of Amazon's jobs, unfortunately,) they might actually stick around to become a normal you can interact with. Of course, that's completely just conjecture. I actually believe Amazon's store will be around the same as any other in terms of the social value you get out of it, which is to say minimal at best. If people actually had meaningful value to get out of visiting marketplaces in modern times, they'd look forward to it instead of looking for how to eliminate it.
- koiz 9y agoRetail is not a place where you will find a "real social interaction".
- lsc 9y ago>Throughout history, "the marketplace" had been one of the major centers of interpersonal interaction If you mean "the coffee shop" (there's a long history there) or "the pub" (a longer history, in the western tradition there) sure, I agree. I'm not saying randos approach me all the time when I'm in those sorts of places, but it happens. It doesn't happen at the grocery store hardly at all. It happens a lot more often in the ride sharing services than even the pub; Yesterday I took my Saturday afternoon ride to Fry's for sandwiches, (The Fry's Sunnyvale Cafe is passable. Not bad. Not as good as the dedicated food places on Murphy, say, but it is super nostalgic for me, so it's something of a weekend tradition.) and while nobody talked to me in the Fry's cafe (I mean, aside from the procurement of food. I have met other interesting people there in the past.) the driver actually apologized to me because he spent most of the ride there speaking with another rider in a foreign language, which was mostly interesting in that he seemed to think that I had some expectation of being included in conversation as he drove. But yeah, I talk to the drivers often, a lot more than talking to strangers in retail spaces. I guess what I'm saying is that social spaces need space for idling. Sitting in the back of the car does this, as does serving food or drink. Buying groceries, I think, does not.
- lsc 9y agoand I think there's something different culturally about waiting in line for prepared food I'm going to eat there and waiting in line in the grocery store; I much more frequently am approached by random people in line at Sam's than at Safeway, even though I spend a lot more time in the latter.
- philwelch 9y agoMost American tribalism is already geographic enough that forcing people to interact in shops won’t do anything to fix it.
- nlawalker 9y agoEvery modern good, service and machine is helping to create a society with less real social interaction, and has been for decades. We're only feeling it now because we're reaching the horizon of not having to directly interact with another human being, ever, while still being able to take advantage of many other aspects of modern life. The real lamentation is that the lack of interaction is perhaps less of a "choice" and more of a necessity for many people. Casual socialization is becoming a privilege reserved for the people who can afford to indulge. Everyone else is too busy getting by, and will choose the path of least interaction because they can't afford the inefficiency. Economic pressure over generations may make introverts of us all.
- gumby 9y agoHow about freeing you to have the social interactions of your choice?
- phil248 9y agoThere's always farmer's markets. And hardware stores, butcher shops, clothing stores, cafes, bars, and boutiques of all varieties. In fact, I can't think of any staff I interact with less than a cashier at a convenience/grocery/big-box store. Except maybe toll workers, a job that is already becoming automated. The place I interact with people the most is at a farmer's market by a large margin
- int_19h 9y agoOr maybe we're just returning back to normal. Consider: historically, in hunter-gatherer societies for example, everyone knows everyone, and that's their social circle. You don't really interact with random strangers, except in very few, usually very formalized ways (or warfare). Compare this to our existing society: most of the people that you're expected - in fact, required (at work etc) - to interact with, are strangers. Most of our communication protocols deal with various aspects of that. With this kind tech, we retreat back to our comfy bubbles of familiar people that we've known for a long time, and away from the strangers.
- curun1r 9y agoI think it comes down to respect and social status. In the times that the marketplace was a place of meaningful interaction, the vendors were merchants or tradesmen selling their products and those were relatively respected stations in life. They weren't nobility, but they weren't at the lowest strata either. Today, retail is a near-zero-skill job that's manned by people who are either young or uneducated. When I worked retail between high school and college, I remember there being a glaring mix of people like me who were transitioning through it and lifers who'd been there for a decade or more. And you could see it in the interactions with customers. When dealing with the younger employees, customers often adopted an avuncular style that's used when dealing with people of the same class but different generation. But when I'd see people talk to the lifers, the interactions were more mechanical and less personal. It was almost as if customers felt that there wasn't any shared context and so a conversation that went beyond the immediate transaction was pointless. I contrast this with my experiences going to farmer's markets. There, vendors are viewed much more as equals. They're largely respected and often own their own business. It's much more common to see people having conversations that feel like they're between equals than it is to see those conversations at a traditional supermarket.
- tootie 9y agoMaybe, maybe not. Less cashiers can mean more floor staff. Even at a place like Target, I need help now and then and the few floor staff are running around like crazy. And they already have self-checkout scanners.
- robrenaud 9y agoCitation needed on the tribalism. 55 years ago the white tribe and the black tribe had separate schools. The percentage of Americans identifying as Christian is going down about a percent a year.