4 ms·
There isn't really a functioning long-term futures market for most commodities, though: the vast majority of the contracts are <1 year, and most of the rest are
by _delirium 16y ago
There isn't really a functioning long-term futures market for most commodities, though: the vast majority of the contracts are <1 year, and most of the rest are <2 years. There are a handful of commodities where it's possible to trade 10-year contracts with relatively good liquidity (U.S. natural-gas delivery is one), but they are quite uncommon, and 20-year contracts aren't even traded on the major exchanges. So, I really tend to see the futures markets, at least the way they currently operate, as more a way of betting on or hedging against (depending on your other positions) short-term logistics and demand spike issues, rather than as a long-term pricing mechanism.
- AngryParsley 16y agoI think the lack of long-term futures contracts is evidence that nobody has a clue about the price of commodities in the long-term.
- yequalsx 16y agoBut then futures contracts don't give "an idea of future scarcity". How does your current statement mesh with your previous one? It seems like the conclusion is that no one thinks they know enough about future scarcity to be willing to place bets on it.
- AngryParsley 16y agoWhile the predictions of scarcity are likely correct, the predictions of the consequences of scarcity likely aren't. For example: Once the cost of helium increases, substitutes will be found for many applications. For a buoyant gas, people might use hot air, or hydrogen mixed with some kind of flame retardant. Low temperature research might rely more on computer simulations. MRIs and other devices might use high temperature superconductors bathed in liquid nitrogen. The only problem would be if helium scarcity happened too quickly for people and technologies to adapt. If you thought that was likely, you could invest in companies making or researching helium substitutes and make a killing. It seems like the conclusion is that no one thinks they know enough about future scarcity to be willing to place bets on it. Almost. Nobody knows enough about future scarcity to be willing to place bets on it instead of placing bets on other investments such as index funds. If you enter into a 20 year futures contract, you're saying, "I believe I will make more money from selling this resource in 20 years than I would from investing the value of this contract in index funds for 20 years."
- yequalsx 16y agoThank you for the clarification.
- kragen 16y ago> While the predictions of scarcity are likely correct, the predictions of the consequences of scarcity likely aren't. For example: Once the cost of helium increases, substitutes will be found for many applications. For a buoyant gas, people might use hot air, or hydrogen mixed with some kind of flame retardant. Low temperature research might rely more on computer simulations. MRIs and other devices might use high temperature superconductors bathed in liquid nitrogen. Those are cool speculations. Hydrogen is probably the only option for a buoyant gas. I don't think mixing flame retardants in with hydrogen will work; you either need something lighter than nitrogen (and hydrogen, helium, and neon are the only candidates) or something that can retard flame appreciably in such small quantities that it doesn't counteract the buoyancy, and I don't think any such substances exist. They'd either have to produce a lot of non-inflammable gas, the way sodium bicarbonate does, or absorb a lot of heat like tetraethyl lead, and in either case they have to be pretty heavy. For superconductor and other cryogenic coolants, as they said, liquid helium is already recycled. I like the idea of using high-temperature superconductors. Maybe invest in yttrium mines? (I guess there are lots of high-temperature superconductors today.) Why don't these devices currently use high-temperature superconductors? Are they too expensive? (Edit: http://pubs.acs.org/subscribe/archive/ci/31/i06/html/06chem.html http://pubs.acs.org/subscribe/archive/ci/31/i06/html/06chem.... says that 123, YBCO, and its family are only superconducting within a single crystal, which makes it hard to make large coils out of them.)
- dublinclontarf 16y agoYes there is, you can take delivery of the good and store it or pay someone to store it. And sell at some point in the future.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- kragen 16y agoYou can buy the good (although that's a lot more expensive than buying a call); you can buy shares in a mining or refining operation whose profits will rise if the commodity prices do; you can buy shares in equipment suppliers who sell to the above; you can do any of the above for commodities that substitute for the commodity in question (e.g. rice and corn, if you expect wheat supplies to be short); or you can bet against commodities that complement the commodity in question, either in production or consumption (e.g. mining more indium will probably push zinc and gallium prices down, since the three tend to occur together; cheap energy would probably depress the price of aluminum somewhat; and similarly, cheap energy would probably elevate the price of bauxite.) Disclaimer: I'm broke at the moment; following my financial advice would be a bad idea.
- _delirium 16y agoWell, yeah--- my main point is that the futures market doesn't serve as a functioning long-term pricing mechanism. That's why you have to go to other things outside the futures market if you want to speculate on/hedge against long-term price movements, like buying physical commodities, or stocks, or other such things.