4 ms·
Cleanfeed looks like a superior solution for this sort of thing: http://cleanfeed.net/ http://cleanfeed.net/ I haven’t used it, but came across it in https://n
by chrismorgan 9y ago
Cleanfeed looks like a superior solution for this sort of thing: http://cleanfeed.net/ http://cleanfeed.net/
I haven’t used it, but came across it in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15890816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15890816. I haven’t used Discord either.
I’m interested in actually informed opinions on the matter!
- CharlesW 9y agoThis sort of "assisted multi-ender" solution is a good alternative to a pure VoIP call, and elsewhere in the thread I posted links to more of this kind of remote recording solution. The main problem with them is that they put more of an onus on the interviewee, which often isn't an option with high-value guests.
- eropple 9y agoThat, and they don't do video, and they don't do live. Podcasts are progressively moving to both of those (live as a Patreon incentive, for example, or Twitch/YouTube) and tools like these are limited. There are limits to what external tools can do for video; at some point you either need to be a video mixer (and this you are not doing in a web browser, unless you want people like me to ask "hey, how do I configure interpolation on my HDMI intakes?" and you go "uhhhhhh" because you have no APIs for that), or you need to plug into a video mixer. I mentioned upthread, but the best option for these cases that I can see is ripping each video and audio feed out of a VoIP solution and sending them to a video mixer via NDI. I'd pay decent money for that.
- zbuf 9y agoHi, thanks for mentioning us (here and elsewhere) Cleanfeed isn't actually a multi-ender, it was originally developed for live radio interviews. So it aims to give the best quality live and in that regard it's different to, eg. Zencastr which does the recording each side and syncs up the better quality audio later. Each method comes with its own pros and cons; my own experience is also that anything after the interview is not always practical.
- eropple 9y ago'zbuf spams that around a lot, but frankly the audio from it is not appreciably different from Discord and the inability to use it in a DAW makes it, to me, an unserious tool.
- bastawhiz 9y agoCleanfeed only seems to run on Chrome, no?
- CharlesW 9y agoYes. One issue with Cleanfeed and similar solutions is their very narrow and specific browser requirements due to WebRTC dependencies. Now that recent versions of Firefox and Safari support WebRTC, this should change soon.
- fulafel 9y agoFirefox got WebRTC support in 2013, about the same time as Chrome. See eg. https://hacks.mozilla.org/2013/02/hello-chrome-its-firefox-calling/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2013/02/hello-chrome-its-firefox-c... (though this blog's event was with beta releses of the browsers, stable releases got enabled-by-default WebRTC later in the summer for both browsers)
- joelrunyon 9y agoZencastr is good for this too - but I'm looking for a video-based one of these. Does anyone know something that does that