4 ms·
There's potential issues with earthquakes and terrorism, both of which are less likely to affect planes, since they travel 10k from the ground. (Terrorism still
by icebraining 9y ago
There's potential issues with earthquakes and terrorism, both of which are less likely to affect planes, since they travel 10k from the ground. (Terrorism still obviously affects airplanes, but with Hyperloop you not only have to secure the stations, but the whole track too).
- Robotbeat 9y agoHyperloop wouldn't work as an effective weapon like an airliner can, though.
- ubernostrum 9y agoAirliner-as-weapon was the "innovation" of the 9/11 attacks. That's one of the big reasons why the attacks worked, and why they'd never ever work again: previous hijackings were about using the plane + passengers as hostages, in order to achieve some other goal. So airline staff had a "script" of not risking lives to resist a hijack attempt, because hijackers typically didn't want to kill anyone, since killing people on the plane would reduce the number of hostages available to use later as leverage. The plan was to let them get the plane on the ground, then wait for the Delta Force guys to show up and deal with the situation. When that changed in the 9/11 attacks, you suddenly saw people on planes actively resist hijacking even when it risked lives (in fact, that started happening on 9/11, with the United 93 passengers once they found out what had been done with the other hijacked planes). Meanwhile, people remain afraid of mass-casualty incidents, and so they've remained an effective tactic (there have been several subway/train attacks in the post-9/11 era) even if nobody managed to crash the trains into buildings.
- vidarh 9y agoThere has been plenty of hijackings since 9/11, and only in a few instances have passengers tried to resist. Maybe things would be different in the US, but I suspect even that would be highly contingent on how the hijackers would act (e.g. whether they'd have the presence of mind to make a big point of stating an intent that'd involve keeping everyone alive). EDIT: It's worth noting that hijackers have overall been far more likely to get killed during a hijacking than passenger - as a passenger, unless you have very specific reasons to believe they're intending to crash the plane, it seems like a much safer bet to keep your head down and wait.
- mr_toad 9y agoIf those are the biggest risks then sign me up. I take bigger risks crossing the road every day.
- colejohnson66 9y ago> with Hyperloop you not only have to secure the stations, but the whole track too I hear this argument a lot, and it personally doesn’t make sense to me. Trains tracks in the middle of nowhere have functioned for two centuries.
- Someone 9y agoAnd trains have been attacked for at least 150 years or so (westerns, Lawrence of Arabia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cairo–Haifa_train_bombings_1948 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cairo–Haifa_train_bombings_194...), just like stage coaches got attacked for centuries before. On the other hand, technological progress means planes nowadays also can be attacked while in air, using rockets (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17) or (not quite yet, I think), drones. Planes have an advantage for the defense that it is easier for them to randomly change routes.