3 ms·
> People obviously prefer SOVs to standing on trains. Why not give people what they want if we can develop technology to do it? SOVs just take up so much space
by jcranmer 9y ago
> People obviously prefer SOVs to standing on trains. Why not give people what they want if we can develop technology to do it?
SOVs just take up so much space, about 20× that of normal standing density. In cities were even the mass transit is oversubscribed, there is no possible way to fit in SOV. Even burrowing in tunnels doesn't work--you'd still have to somehow squeeze the access ramps in. Cities that try to be SOV-centric instead of transit-centric end up having really large sprawl and lose the benefits of being close to anything.
To give you a sharp visual statement of the difference in space. When trains disgorged their passengers at Union Station in Toronto, people would often stream across the surrounding streets without particularly regard for crosswalks. When traffic was waiting at the light on Simcoe St, there was more people walking between the cars than there was sitting in the cars waiting for the light to change.
- vidarh 9y agoIn places like London, a major problem with the underground system is that even space to surface vents for aircon etc. is restricted enough for it to be a problem. Fitting access ramps would be a massive problem. The lack of space for aircon vents has gotten to the point where the clay surrounding the underground tunnels are permanently 5+ degrees warmer than it was when the system was built, because not enough heat is pumped back out, and it soaks up less and less of the waste heat. Most of central London is basically sitting on top of a giant clay heatsink. Building down also doesn't add all that much when trains run frequently enough that junctions/intersections are not viable without delays or sacrificing speed. As well as when depth changes need to be very gradual... The irony is that building more tunnels is by far easiest in cities too small to need the capacity - if you have long intervals between trains, for example, junctions become a far more manageable problem, leaving far more trajectories free to use.