4 ms·
The idea that a state is entitled to some cut of a purchase just because the purchaser lives in the state is absurd to me. If I can walk across state lines and
by kelnos 9y ago
The idea that a state is entitled to some cut of a purchase just because the purchaser lives in the state is absurd to me. If I can walk across state lines and buy something in a brick-and-mortar store and be charged that state's sales tax, why should I be taxed according to my own state's sales tax if I instead buy something online that's physically located in another state? Or, to make it less "techy", if I order something over the phone or by mail order, why should my state feel they deserve a cut of that?
I think it makes more sense for all purchases to be taxed at the rate where the seller resides, regardless of where the buyer is. So if I live in CA and buy something from a seller in NJ, I pay NJ tax, to NJ, even if the seller has no presence in CA. This has what I consider to be the nice effect of making this detail a part of the reason why you might want to move your operations to a particular state. State governments can offer businesses incentives to move/stay in-state if they do have a higher sales tax rate: they can offer other tax breaks to a company that will allow them to reduce prices so they can remain competitive, or states can just lower sales taxes to be more competitive. I'm not 100% sold on that latter bit, since I like the idea of taxing consumption (encourages saving and/or investment), but I like some of its other properties. This does get more complicated when a business has a presence in multiple states, but I'm sure someone can figure that out[0].
I don't find your argument about sellers moving out of the country to be persuasive. That sort of thing can be fixed with shipping taxes and/or import duties. If states or the US aren't implementing those sorts of things, that's the thing that should be fixed.
[0] Note that I'm looking at all this from the perspective of a "user" of the system. I don't know or care how complicated it is to implement by businesses or the states (as long as the complexity is limited such that compliance doesn't add undue costs); what I do care about is what seems fair and reasonable to purchasers who are subject to the taxes.
> but what often happens is when revenue start to decline then the politicians either have to cut services or more likely what they do is raise rates for other taxes.
I don't see that as an issue. Raising rates for other taxes is a perfectly reasonable action to take to keep state revenue stable and predictable. This is already a problem with sales taxes: recessions and booms affect sales taxes in ways that require states to adjust budget already.
- conanbatt 9y agoStates would get into a race to the bottom in for this effect, which is not what the states wants to do with its own tax collection. That would basically be pulling the amazon tax bargaining with every single state for every single sales tax. I'm all for it, but that system is likely to not survive.
- jnordwick 9y agoCorporate income taxes by state would seem to deny a race to the bottom. Very few (6?) have no corporate income tax and not all business are located in those states. While states like business there, they also like taxes. Not allowing them to tax out of state sales would seem to be a good brake on their greed.
- wmf 9y agoThe point of sales/use tax is that the tax on your consumption pays for the government services that you use.
- kodablah 9y agoIs it on consumption or production + transfer? If I continually consume something that I've always had, I'm not paying recurring sales tax. But if I produce something new and sell it, I am, making the GP's point more sound.
- wmf 9y agoIn economics, "consumption" basically means "buying things".