9 ms·
Why Understanding Space Is So Hard (2016)
- philipov 9y ago> although Einstein’s theory demolished Newton’s absolute space, it gave us something else in its place—a four-dimensional structure known as spacetime—and this, Greene argues, is absolute. And yet, it is now thought that spacetime itself can not be absolute, and must emerge from more fundamental structures, such as combinatorial geometries: https://youtu.be/qTx98PUW6lE?t=13m7s https://youtu.be/qTx98PUW6lE?t=13m7s
- andrepd 9y agoI wouldn't go so far as to say that "it is now thought". More like some people that are researching this problem are proposing some solutions. We are far from a definite answer.
- philipov 9y agoSorry, I thought the video made that clear. What is now thought is not an answer, but a perspective on the question. That the way to resolve the paradoxes between quantum mechanics and general relativity is not to find a quantum mechanical theory of gravity, but that both quantum mechanics and spacetime must emerge together from something more fundamental. In this sense, it is now thought that spacetime is not absolute. This sentiment appears widespread in the physics community, but as to precisely what this more fundamental theory should be, that answer has not yet been found.
- js8 9y agoIt is hard. There are cellular automata, which are result of discrete local functions evolving in fixed space. But what if we had something like "foam automata", discrete local functions that could alter the space they operate on? For example, if we represented the underlying space as graph, could we have functions that evolve as to change (reconnect) the edges and add/remove vertices of said graph? Aside from 1D case, I was unable to figure out a set of rules that wouldn't quickly devolve into something that's either locally too dense or too sparse or disconnected. And making it follow some laws of conservation seems even harder. Maybe some smarter readers of HN will figure it out, I would certainly be delighted.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. What you're describing isn't too far from Causal Dynamical Triangulation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causal_dynamical_triangulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causal_dynamical_triangulation
- pharrington 9y agoThe downvotes may be from people wanting to help the uninformed/hobbyists avoid wasting time trying to do something that's unrealistic - http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/3/9/e1701758 http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/3/9/e1701758. (I upvoted because the unrigorous idea of some sort of "foam automata" is cool, even if a formal, universal version of it is impossible.)
- js8 9y ago> Not sure why you're being downvoted. Thanks, I was also confused, but according to some weird social customs enforced on HN, I cannot sincerely ask that question. On the other hand, I am not sure about the upvotes either. I actually didn't mean to develop some new physics theory, I just wanted to play a mathematical game (like Game of Life, for example), which would alter its own space/geometry. And this seemed as a good place to mention it, and get some feedback if somebody was aware of something similar. Because I found it quite nontrivial (to make it work "decently", in a vague sense), despite my lack of ambitions to explain physics. CDT looks interesting, but it's not quite what I had in mind.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jabgrabdthrow 9y agoHere's something similar: https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0011076 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0011076 I found that article from here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pregeometry_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pregeometry_(physics)
- mr_luc 9y ago
- mabbo 9y agoI know that, given the greatest minds in history have worked so hard on the problem, I'm missing something. What is it? When I think about the problem on an individual atom level, the rising up the bucket doesn't seem hard to explain at all. Friction from the bucket to the outer molecules makes the water molecules want to move in the same direction (slowing the bucket sightly, I'd imagine). Once those ones start moving, they too will pull along the nearby molecules via friction. Then momentum will cause them to move towards the outer edge of the bucket, pushing each other and pushing some up the walls of the bucket. I'm not being facetious here- what's the problem? Have we tried the same experiment with extremely low-friction buckets?
- samirillian 9y agobased on the article, i think the problem of momentum (which you invoke) is the crux of the question.
- tafurnace 9y agoYou aren't the only one. I thought the same thing while reading this and felt the mechanics behind the atoms' movement was easy to understand and explain in what the article seems to suggest is difficult to explain. Perhaps either the bucket example was a bad one, not explained correctly as to what was difficult to understand, or Newton didn't understand certain aspects of the physics of atoms at the time. I'm not a physics or history expert, but it seems like a failure of the article to make the problem clear, not you.
- T-A 9y agoThe problem is: how does the bucket know that it's rotating, and not the rest of the universe that's rotating around it? Maybe this will help: http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/HistTopics/Newton_bucket.html http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/HistTopics/Newton...
- trevyn 9y ago>Tie two rocks together with a rope, he suggested, and go into deep space far from the gravitation of the Earth or the sun...Rotate the rope about its centre and it will become taut as the rocks pull outwards. The rocks will create an outward force pulling the rope tight. If one does this in an empty universe then what can it mean for the system to be rotating. There is nothing to measure rotation with respect to. Newton deduced from this thought experiment that there had to be something to measure rotation with respect to, and that something had to be space itself. Eh? You measure the rotation against the thing that performed the “rotate the rope” step in the experiment. Thought experiments that contain the step “now magically remove X from the observable universe” should be treated with caution! :-) If you change it to just “There exists a universe empty except for a rotating set of rocks connected by a rope”, rotation needs no meaning as it’s one of the axioms. Also, there is no observer in that universe, so you’re making a pretty dangerous assumption about the ability to observe a universe without being a part of it.
- d13 9y ago"Something makes the water rise up against the side of the bucket" We really have no idea?? Wow, it shows how little we really know about anything.
- tim333 9y agoNo idea is a bit strong - we understand quite a lot about it. But not everything by a long shot.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoWe believe we understand a lot about it, but we're not - yet? - absolutely certain. That is, once we get to the end, then and only then will we be certain of what it took to get there. Yes, no idea isn't accurate. We've got ideas. We just can't say the ideas are correct.
- empath75 9y agoThere are layers of explanations needed. The typical explanation is inertia, but there is the question of what causes inertia and what causes whatever causes inertia and so on. There are always going to be new questions.
- goldenkey 9y agoThis article is pretty much a copy of a much more detailed Scientific American piece posted 3 months ago. I highly recommend it, a great read. The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15487928 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15487928 Regarding the topic on hand -- Is it possible for the net statistical acceleration of the charged virtual particles of the quantum vacuum to be used as an absolute reference frame in order to gauge absolute velocity/intertial mass? Does anyone know if this idea or similar has ever been tested experimentally?
- tim333 9y ago>Is it possible for the net statistical acceleration of the charged virtual particles of the quantum vacuum to be used as an absolute reference frame in order to gauge absolute velocity/intertial mass? I very much doubt you could use that as an absolute reference frame. It would contradict the ideas of relativity and no one has observed such a thing as far as I know.
- goldenkey 9y agoThe partial differential equations of relativity consider spacetime and matter/energy to be infinitely divisible. Particles are neither supported nor rejected. Blackholes seem to indicate that relativity performs well in matching reality despite lacking any notion of particles. But who knows..relativity could be at odds when it comes to the vacuum. The reason if any, to think there might be something interesting here-- All objects as they move through the vacuum, leave a disturbance, a "wake" of sorts, in all quantum fields. These disturbances can appear as real particles to some observers, while being virtual particles for others. It may be possible then, for relativity to be satisfied considering this observer-dependent visibility. In fact, perhaps a binary statistical measure on the number of real particles may be the key to getting the absolute measurements.
- state_less 9y agoThese are fun questions to ask. If you take away everything in the thought experiment except a single hydrogen ion, what can it rotate about? What does rotation mean in a universe without anything except a single atom? What does inertia mean without respect to something else? Can such a particle have a velocity?
- whatshisface 9y agoIf all you have is a single hydrogen ion (proton? I assume you mean H+), then you will always be able to choose a coordinate system where it is neither moving nor rotating. You can also do this if there is a universe outside. Alternatively, you can choose a coordinate system where the particle is rotating, accelerating, or moving however you like. Your choice will be determined by the goals you have. (Without the laws of motion, there is no reason to prefer even intertial frames over nonintertial ones.)
- state_less 9y agoYep, I was thinking about a proton. I probably should have been more explicit. Is the particle moving or is the coordinate system? It seems, like you say, to be arbitrary. Without something else in the universe, the particle could have any rotation, velocity, inertia, etc... depending on which coordinate system you choose. The coordinate system seems to be layered on, from a universe where the idea of space and time were more useful.
- vorg 9y agoThere must be something else in the Universe to observe the single proton for it to have rotation, etc, according to quantum physics. Extend this idea to the centrifugal force on the water in the bucket in a Universe with nothing else in it, and the centrifugal force is similarly both there and not there, in a quantum superposition until observed. The value of Planck's constant is thus a function of the large-scale distribution of energy in the Universe, rather than a fixed property of spacetime itself.
- platz 9y ago1. The Higgs field goes one better: By offering resistance to anything that passes through it, it may explain why objects have inertia in the first place. Why doesn't the higgs field slow down objects moving in space? 2. If gravity is simply the curvature of spacetime itself, the higgs field gives particles mass, and mass curves spacetime, what is the relationship between the curvature of spacetime and the higgs field exactly, is it special somehow? (It seems somehow the way the higgs "offers resistance" is related to the curvature of spacetime)
- psadauskas 9y agoAs far as I understand it, the Higgs field isn’t resistance to motion but rather resistance to acceleration.
- fmihaila 9y ago(Apologies for the long post. I can’t point off the top of my head to a textbook reference, but [1] may be enough for a start.) This is not an unsolved problem. The key is to understand how inertial motion and inertial forces are explained in Newtonian mechanics vs. general relativity. Let’s take two friends, Charlie and Isidor. Charlie is sipping coffee while reading a book sitting on a chair in his home, while Isidor is reading the same book while floating freely on the International Space Station. At first glance, it may seem that Charlie is experiencing inertial motion (with velocity 0, since he is at rest) and Isidor is in accelerated motion around the earth at a very high speed, since he is moving in a circular orbit. (Recall that in Newtonian mechanics, circular motion is always accelerated motion since the velocity vector varies with time, even though only in its direction.) However, this is backwards. In fact, Charlie feels the constant force of the chair pushing on his bum and lower back, which is why he keeps changing his position when it gets uncomfortable, while Isidor is weightless, experiencing no forces acting on his body whatsoever. Also, absent any collision or explicit application of rocket thrust, the ISS and Isidor inside will maintain their current trajectory forever, while maintaining Charlie’s ‘at-rest’ position requires the constant application of force on his body, which is why when the chair eventually breaks (Charlie is a heavy dude), Charlie moves quickly towards the ground, spilling his coffee. This observation is at the core of general relativity. Einstein remarked that, if we surround Charlie with a tent, he cannot possibly tell whether he is sitting on the beach or whether his chair is actually on the floor of a rocket accelerating constantly at 9.81 m/s^2 towards Alpha Centauri. At the same time, if the ISS had no windows, there is no experiment Isidor can conduct that would tell him whether the ship is orbiting the earth or is hurtling unaccelerated in a straight line in deep space. IOW, Charlie is in fact the one experiencing accelerated motion, while Isidor is in inertial motion. So what, then, is inertial motion? In general relativity, a body is in inertial motion if its trajectory in spacetime follows a local spacetime geodesic. Earth’s gravity distorts space time around it to a shape in which the trajectory of the ISS at that altitude and velocity is actually a straight line according to the local metric imposed by the Earth’s gravitational field. Conversely, if we plot Charlie’s at-rest position on the beach through the same spacetime according to the same metric, it corresponds to a trajectory that deviates from the geodesic right up until the moment when the chair breaks, when for a very brief duration, his motion will actually follow the local geodesic. What does this have to do with the water in the bucket? Once the water molecules rotate in sync with the bucket, their trajectories all deviate from the local geodesic lines. We can see that by imagining the bucket wall instantly disappearing; the water molecules would cease following the previously enforced circular trajectories, and they would start traveling in inertial motion away from the bucket, freely falling towards the ground (i.e., inertial motion in the Earth’s gravitational field). The sum of the forces required to maintain the water molecules on circular trajectories happen to lead to a curved water surface. The water molecules at rest in the non-rotating bucket are still in non-inertial motion similar to Charlie’s, but the forces acting on them to maintain those particular trajectories simply lead to a flat surface. The point is that every time we want a body to deviate from its free, inertial trajectory in its local spacetime, we must apply a force. The water curvature is a direct result of all the forces which are necessary to steer the water molecules away from the local spacetime geodesics. [1] https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/3988 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/3988
- mikhailfranco 9y agoNice time-less relational formulation of Newtonian gravity: http://fqxi.org/data/essay-contest-files/Barbour_The_Nature_of_Time.pdf http://fqxi.org/data/essay-contest-files/Barbour_The_Nature_...
- 8bitsrule 9y agoNice. Things moving around in the Eternal Now (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_presentism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_presentism). What is duration if not a fiction of memory?
- dang 9y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10979418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10979418
- z3t4 9y agoIf nothing would exist, who would be there to tell ?
- kapv89 9y agoFew years back, I was brushing up on some topology I studied in college. One thing lead to another and I came up with the idea that there are 5 dimensions of the absolute nature of our natural universe. Wrote it down as a medium post last year: https://medium.com/@kapv89/logically-there-is-a-5th-dimension-fcc51cca9e94 https://medium.com/@kapv89/logically-there-is-a-5th-dimensio...
- eximius 9y agoI mean, your post posits a logical possibility but merely posing the possibility does not make it likely (like your post seems to imply). Also, a dimension has some degree of continuity or, at least, regular discrete nature that I'm not sure your idea for the 5th dimension really fits naturally. Surely, we can relate to positions in your concept of a dimension, but does a relation require a dimension? I'm not sure. Maybe it does. Maybe my above thoughts are all locked in the concept of a euclidean geometry. My topology studies were always in the context of function spaces, so it was a bit too abstract to think about it this way.
- woodandsteel 9y agoAs a non-expert, it seems to me the question is whether space is fundamental, or whether it is produced by something else more fundamental, and if so, what.
- colordrops 9y agoI don't understand why the bucket example implies absolute space. When looked at from a reductionist perspective, each atom is still travelling inertially with respect to other atoms, but they are constantly changing direction based on mutual forces applied to each other. The fact that from a macroscopic perspective they appear to be "spinning" doesn't mean that "spinning" is actually a fundamental and inherent form of motion relative to some static background.
- ithkuil 9y agoBut they are not changing position nor velocities with respect to each other while rotating, they are changing positions and velocities against other frames of references.
- colordrops 9y agoThey are though. Structures are not rigid, but more elastic. They only appear rigid and monolithic from a macroscopic perspective. One atom moves relative to another , and then exerts electromagnetic force on another which then moves a bit itself, and when all are seen together they appear to be a single unit that is spinning, but that is an illusion.