4 ms·
I learned to cross my eyes way back in the mid nineties during the "3d poster" craze (and man those posters were amazing, zo SO much better than the crap images
by johndoe491 9y ago
I learned to cross my eyes way back in the mid nineties during the "3d poster" craze (and man those posters were amazing, zo SO much better than the crap images found on the web). I remember they sold them in the tube in London, in gorgeous color and the depth was fantastic.
But anyway... do we know that convergence actually helps vision? How so? What is backing this up?
- walterbell 9y agoWe know that poor convergence affects near vision. Presbyopia also affects near vision. Are convergence and presbyopia related? Should you ask the person trying to sell you a pair of expensive progressive lenses? http://www.convergenceinsufficiency.org/ http://www.convergenceinsufficiency.org/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amblyopia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amblyopia http://www.strabismus.org/ http://www.strabismus.org/ The exercises are easy to try and have almost immediate (temporary) positive effect. They work for some people. There isn't an economic incentive to fund studies to determine why they don't work in others, since this could hurt various revenue streams. Standard big pharma vs. wellness dilemma. However, video game software subscriptions for vision therapy may change incentives.
- no_identd 9y agohttp://www.strabismusworld.com/ http://www.strabismusworld.com/ https://www.seevividly.com/ https://www.seevividly.com/ And also, I'd like to point your attention to Aniseikonia, an EXTREMELY underdiagnosed issue: http://www.opticaldiagnostics.com/info/aniseikonia.html http://www.opticaldiagnostics.com/info/aniseikonia.html Neither clinical neuro-ophthalmology, nor orthoptists, nor optometricians, nor opticians, commonly have the equipment to test this, let alone know about it. (I had to literally have a lens kit dusted off in my case. One that nobody besides one entire person in the city knew about besides me.) And the fact that one must consider the current distance and measuring equipment used for vision tests insufficient: http://www.tedmontgomery.com/the_eye/acuity.html http://www.tedmontgomery.com/the_eye/acuity.html To quote: "Traditionally, optical infinity has been accepted to be 20 feet or, approximately, 6 meters. However, at this distance, there is an accommodative demand on the eye of about 1/6 D (one-sixth of a diopter). This amount of accommodative demand can be significant for some people. For very discriminating observers (such as myself), an accommodative fluctuation during an eye examination of more than 1/8 D can result in a variable endpoint in measuring a person’s refractive error (resulting in an imprecise lens prescription), and 1/6 D is even greater than 1/8 D. As a result, it is recommended that the viewing distance (d) in an examination room should be great enough to create no more than a 1/8 D accommodative demand on any patient’s eyes. I maintain, then, that optical infinity, for purposes of examining the refractive error of the human eye, is at least 8 meters or 26¼ feet, rather than merely 6 meters or 20 feet." This combines with the fact that that the human eye experiences "accommodative microfluctuations" which have a range of about 0,5 diopters (aka ±0,25 diopter), and it does so even at true optical infinity. This then makes any assessment done without cycloplegia problematic, but assessment under cycloplegia also has its issues: There exists a dissertation from a German Technical University (Well, "Fachhochschule", look the term up if you have an obsession with detail like I do) that beyond the shadow of a doubt proves that Schack-Hartmann sensor based Wavefront aberrometers can and will do better than humans when measuring the ideal prescription for a human eye. However, this dissertation, even as good as it was (they had a huge sample size and accounted for damn near everything), has several limitations and also points several problems out, and in addition to these, I'll add a few ones I've observed myself and that one can find in the literature (this is from memory and reading a lot of the literature, but keep in mind I can't find the original paper [in German] anymore, and some of this comes from other papers): 1. The default setting of most wavefront aberrometers defaults to 3 eye measurement cycles per eye measurement. However, the study found quite clearly that at this setting, a wavefront aberrometers will very often do worse than an experienced human optometrist or orthoptist, even if they do account for the distance problem I described above, which nearly all of them don't. A 5 measurement cycles however elevate the wavefront 2. Most wavefront aberrometers lack the capability to do a proper measurement of a fully dilated pupil as they expect a maximum pupil dilation of about 5mm, which is ridiculously tiny 3. Wavefront aberrometers cannot compensate for deeply (or at all) cramped cilliary muscles, an extremely common issue 4a. To get a dilated pupil, one must apply a mydriasic (i.e. pupil dilating) agent such as cyclopentolate. 4b. To get a relaxed cilliary muscle, one must apply a cycloplegic (i.e. cilliary mucscle paralyzing) agent such as cyclopentolate. 5. Most wavefront aberrometer measurements occur in the office of an optician, who legally may not dispense cycloplegic & mydriasic eye drops (such as cyclopentolate). 6. This is a good thing, because cyclopentolate is an muscarinic antagonist. Normally relatively harmless, when given to people with various atypical neurological features such as for example some of (but not all of) those exhibited by some of (but not all of those) those diagnosed with schizophrenia, it can lead to acute psychosis. 7. The above seems doubly unfortunate because schizophrenia seems to have an - extremely little researched - link to the previously mentioned Aniseikonia: http://www.schizo-binoc.de/ http://www.schizo-binoc.de/ [Personally, I think some of the hypotheses on the neurological mechanisms of this link as offered by Hildegard Korn seem whack, but if you look at purely her quite empirical - albeit possibly anecdotal - data, you'll see that the pattern she describes along with the formal errors in commonly used diagnostical procedures she outlines quite flawlessly do add up to something and could probably get easily explained, in terms of neurological mechanisms behind the observed biophysics, by a more respectable theory on the neurological mechanisms behind it.) And then there's the whole patent lockdown between all the big glasses manufacturers, but I cba to continue typing this out. I truly despise the optical and ophthalmological industry. They still haven't heard Sue Barry's message although she's shouting it with all the force she can muster.
- walterbell 9y agoOne note is that opticianry and optometry are not separated in Germany. While this may lead to conflict of interest, it can also lead to a better eye exam. We can now manufacture lenses to 0.01D but still perform exams in 0.25D increments. Everyone should have their eyes examined by two independent doctors, preferably in diverse cities, just to see the range of subjectivity involved in each prescription. Why can't SeeVividly vision therapy be made available directly to consumers? Is the reason technical or business, to avoid conflict with eye doctors? The computer industry may be on a collision course with the optical industry, due to augmented reality and smart glasses. We all know what happened when pocket computers collided with mobile telecom/carriers. The illusions provided by AR depend upon the brain's visual cortex and neuro-plasticity. Smart glasses may use 3D printing / nanoscale manufacturing to create transparent "lenses"/"displays" which embed cameras and microphones. Thank you for the Sue Barry pointer: http://www.stereosue.com/ http://www.stereosue.com/
- no_identd 9y ago>While this may lead to conflict of interest, it can also lead to a better eye exam. I have very good familiarity with the situation in Germany. It's barely any better there due to the same limitations I've already outlined. Granted, you find more opticians with 1/8 diopter trial frame lenses there, but it's still a rarity and opticians lack orthoptic training, something NOT supplementable by normal optometric training (which already goes beyond optician training), even if the IVBS would like you to think otherwise. >Why can't SeeVividly vision therapy be made available directly to consumers? Is the reason technical or business, to avoid conflict with eye doctors? Liability.
- mistermann 9y agoI've recently developed intermittent vertical diplopia (double vision) - it will happen out of the blue and last for a few minutes (closing eyes and relaxing seems to clear it up). I've been trying to wear my reading glasses more often and also when on the computer and it seems to have largely cleared up, but it still happens now and then. Do you think it's safe to consider it problem solved or should I be looking into it more? Went for an eye exam and she said everything was fine.
- pfranz 9y ago> There isn't an economic incentive to fund studies to determine why they don't work in others, since this could hurt various revenue streams. I could be incredibly naive, but it sounds like a public health issue. Depending on how widespread it is, I can see any country organizing a study or pilot program. The country wouldn't have economic competition from big pharma and would see having a healthy and skilled population as an economic advantage.
- walterbell 9y agoThe global numbers for myopia are rising in children, https://www.brienholdenvision.org/myopia-prevalence.html https://www.brienholdenvision.org/myopia-prevalence.html, "The hot spots of myopia right now are in East Asia where countries such as South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, China and Japan have a prevalence of myopia of 80 to 90% but even the USA has reported a staggering prevalence of 42%, almost doubling in three decades." A few behavioral optometrists have spoken up or published books on these topics, but they are a tiny minority, e.g. https://vision-therapy-pa.com https://vision-therapy-pa.com
- xenadu02 9y agoI can't find the link but I seem to remember a study found that exposure to sunlight (at least the level found on an overcast day) was required for ~4 hours per day to prevent myopia. This link had been suspected previously but they found a mechanism of action. The eyeball itself would release regulatory chemicals at night after the daytime exposure that inhibited growth of the eyeball. Since myopia is most often caused by the eye being slightly too large this seems like a plausible explanation. It certainly makes more sense than the previous theory about spending too much time indoors - that somehow you would spend too much time focusing closely since distances indoors are limited.
- oolongtea 9y agoThe article you're referring to might be this one: http://bjo.bmj.com/content/early/2017/06/12/bjophthalmol-2017-310292 http://bjo.bmj.com/content/early/2017/06/12/bjophthalmol-201... (Alas, it's not Open Access) I also remember reading an earlier news article in Nature on this exact topic: https://www.nature.com/news/the-myopia-boom-1.17120 https://www.nature.com/news/the-myopia-boom-1.17120
- fjsolwmv 9y agoReading glasses are for lens focusing, not for convergence. Prism glasses are for convergence issues, but are rarelt prescribed. No conspiracy theory needed.
- no_identd 9y agoNo conspiracy theory was claimed. Here's one of the newer summaries of research on prisms for convergence issues, unfortunately in German, but the abstracts' in English: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00347-014-3037-9 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00347-014-3037-9 Which states quite clearly that horizontal prisms shouldn't get prescribed, only vertical prisms, and weaker ones than previously thought, which brings us right back to the fact that we need more competent developmental, behavioral functional optometry & orthopty. Furthermore, you probably want to read this article by Rodenstock: http://assets.markallengroup.com/article-images/image-library/147/uploads/importedimages/20rodenstock.pdf http://assets.markallengroup.com/article-images/image-librar... It's unfortunately marketing material, however, it's also the only English resource I know that outlines the problems of: * Listing's law in its original version only applying to distance vision * 'effective near astigmatism' * tilting of the intraocular lens inside one document so you don't have to go crawling all over the literature to find them like I had to. Now think of how failing to properly correcting that influences accommodative strabismus via the accommodation-convergence reflex in anisometropic patients... Especially if the glasses ain't iseikonic and thus induce unwanted and unbalanced base in/base out prism. Of course, Rodenstock has a patent on some of these corrections. While Hoya has a patent on freeform double surface lenses which makes everything way more complicated to optimize when you ain't Hoya, Zeiss has a patent on knocking out convergence using an infrared light source to measure pupil position, and on various multiphoton raytracing technologies for calculating corrections such as the one Rodenstock describes (leading to Rodenstock using a complicated workaround), and so on, dozens of patents locking everyone out of making an /optimal/ pair of glasses. Yes this makes all vendors about equally good, but only by making all of them, relatively speaking, mediocre. Each in their own special way. And don't get me started up on contact lenses and how they relate to the difference between axial anisometropia, refractive anisometropia, and their hybrid. My point here, and in my other comments (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16195742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16195742 & https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16195570 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16195570): There exists no conspiracy. There only exists cock-up, and lots of it. Hanlon's razor etc.
- appleflaxen 9y ago> Should you ask the person trying to sell you a pair of expensive progressive lenses? probably not, but should you ask the person trying to sell you an app with mediocre reviews of efficacy (the placebo effect should cause ratings to be higher than a "true" rating).
- walterbell 9y agoThere is existing research on vision therapy and behavioral optometry, e.g. here's a 2002 review paper that covers preceding decades, http://www.familyvisioncare.org/2016/research/02_THE_SCIENTIFIC_BASIS_FOR.PDF http://www.familyvisioncare.org/2016/research/02_THE_SCIENTI... If new business models (including software) for vision therapy emerge, the revenue can fund marketing of existing studies or even new studies. The presence of this (marketing?) article in the NY Times at least raises awareness of the concept, so that people can consult the research or ask a professional about non-lens options.
- EGreg 9y agoAny recommendations for 3d magazines? I want to buy on amazon if you have a link.
- walterbell 9y agoSearch for "stereogram".