3 ms·
How do they want to bring their stuff back to earth? Is there any technology on the horizon that allows us to bring heavy masses to Earth in an affordable way?
by maxxxxx 9y ago
How do they want to bring their stuff back to earth? Is there any technology on the horizon that allows us to bring heavy masses to Earth in an affordable way?
- bohm 9y agoGravity
- maxxxxx 9y agoI guess if it was a big meteorite you can afford some of the material to burn off. Just be ready for a nuclear explosion like impact on the ground.
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y ago> How do they want to bring their stuff back to earth? > Gravity Quite. I not an expert at all, but the question "how do we bring it down" is better put "how do we bring it down safely and so that we can easily recover the material". Throwing rocks down the gravity well is easy, keeping the velocity low at bottom end, or low enough plus aiming accurately at an empty spot, is hard.
- friedman23 9y agoDrop it into a net in the ocean?
- rocqua 9y agoGiven a space elevator, there are some neat tricks that help in de-orbiting and orbiting material at the same time. Essentially, you connect two equal masses with a tether, one you want in a higher orbit and the other you want in a lower orbit. With the tether in place, both masses rotate around their common center of mass. When the masses have 'switched' places, you untether them. I don't recall whether the thethers need to be affixed to the space-elevators to keep them in place.
- Terr_ 9y agoI don't think a full-blown space-elevator is needed for that: Skyhooks [0] don't need their centers to be attached to it, and the lateral velocities involved are probably best kept away from the elevator body. If you have a space elevator scaffolding already, just use descending payloads as counterweights to ascending ones. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure)
- theptip 9y agoI'm curious about whether they will actually bring materials back to Earth. It seems like it would be prohibitively expensive, though perhaps you could construct gliders out of large chunks of titanium and fly them down from orbit cost-effectively, or float small chunks down with balloons. To me the space-mining industry has always seemed better suited to constructing habitats and vehicles outside of gravity wells like Earth and Mars; part of why it's so expensive to have the ISS is that everything needs to be lifted up from Earth, but if the raw building materials and water (for producing oxygen and hydrogen fuel) were mined from asteroids, then there's less need to go back down to earth for your bulk materials. This would make the second and subsequent generations of mining infrastructure much cheaper to build, and once you've got manufacturing going in space, suddenly the mining becomes a lot easier.