3 ms·
Some years ago I got into a dispute with an interviewer about some C++ construct. He claimed it wouldn't work. I claimed it would. I asked him to put it through
by maxxxxx 9y ago
Some years ago I got into a dispute with an interviewer about some C++ construct. He claimed it wouldn't work. I claimed it would. I asked him to put it through the compiler but he refused.
Same in your situation. Why didn't they try it out before making a judgement?
- kazinator 9y agoAt some point you have to have confidence in what you know (right or wrong). You can't be trying every darn thing. Wait does JS really have curly braces? Not sure now, I haven't read the spec from cover to cover three times; better go try it. Okay, super exaggerated example (but I like those; they get the point across). Also, empirical approaches can appear to confirm intuitions that are wrong; like printf("%d %d\n", i++, i++) producing the wrongly expected answer.
- maxxxxx 9y ago"At some point you have to have confidence in what you know (right or wrong). You can't be trying every darn thing." I view it as test. When an interviewee or a new guy at work tells me something that I don't know or think is wrong I always give him the benefit of the doubt and verify it together with him. If he is right I know we have somebody who brings something to the table. If he is wrong that's clearly a negative that counts against him. If that happens a few times I will stop listening to that person.
- dwaltrip 9y agoEmpirical approaches and underlying theory are both valuable and should be used together. Abstract theory is useless by itself. Hell, simply writing a program to accomplish some specific goal is an empirical exercise that further enriches existing understanding. Of course, as you note, empirical guess-and-check knowledge with no theoretical understanding is also a problem.
- abetusk 9y agoI've been in this position a few times, one way or another. It's a bad position to be in. If you're wrong, you're labeled as unknowledgeable. If you're right, you're labeled as "not a culture fit". I've found that no matter how humble you try and be, the interviewer is isn't very gracious when they're right and isn't humble enough when they're wrong.