10 ms·
The curious star appeal of Jordan Peterson
- throwaway-hn123 9y agoA loser posting a story about a loser.
- sgdesign 9y ago> In 2016 he made a stand against the Canadian government’s introduction of a law that aimed to make it a crime not to address people by their preferred gender pronouns (regardless of chromosomes). I'm pretty sure that's a gross misrepresentation of that law. From the little I know about it, I think it was more about adding "using the wrong pronoun" as a possible aggravating circumstance to consider when somebody is already being harassed: https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/canadian-lawmakers-pass-bill-extending-transgender-protections-n773421 https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/canadian-lawmakers-p... > The bill adds prohibitions against discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression to the Canadian Human Rights Act, amends the criminal code to extend protections against hate speech and allows judges to take into consideration when sentencing whether a crime was motivated by hatred of the victim’s gender identity or expression.
- jo909 9y agoHis conflict started with the Ontario Human Rights Commission policy which clearly includes gender pronouns. That is often getting mixed up with when he also spoke out against C 16 later, with different arguments. http://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/policy-preventing-discrimination-because-gender-identity-and-gender-expression/3-gender-identity-and-gender-expression http://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/policy-preventing-discrimination-be... I think you are right that just in C 16 there is nothing about compelled speech. My understanding of his position is that it's part of a slippery slope, and the interpretation of discrimination or hate speech could easily extend to using the wrong gender pronouns.
- dogma1138 9y agoC16 refers to the Ontario human rights commission for interpretation and policy which is a huge problem.
- aalleavitch 9y agoAnd then we'll start letting people get married to animals!
- larrykwg 9y agoNo, the widely accepted interpretation of that law is that, if I have a coworker who wants to be called xe/xem/xyr/xyrs/xemself, I have to comply or face punishment, since not be accommodating of this can be construed as harassment. Ideologues want to dismiss everyone who is against this law as transphobic, but this is demonstrably not true, one can be accepting of the human rights of trans people while simultaneously disagreeing with the extend of protections and privileges granted to them. I think what most people ultimately take issue with, is that this law was evidently ideologically motivated and it felt like no logical arguments could ever be discussed.
- upofadown 9y agoThe "it is illegal to use the wrong pronoun" interpretation is only widely accepted by those who have trouble with the definition of the word "discrimination". If I use the wrong pronoun when referring to someone it might rise to the level of harassment if I do it deliberately and repeatedly. It can't be a violation of an anti-discrimination law because it isn't discrimination.
- tomohawk 9y agoI see. So If I insist that my pronoun is "his majesty" and others don't use it, that would be harassment? http://www.thecollegefix.com/post/29230/ http://www.thecollegefix.com/post/29230/ For those of us who think that objective reality is more important than what someone's feelings may or may not be, this imposition of a speech code is clearly harassment.
- aalleavitch 9y agoNo. That wouldn't be harassment. Here is the Canadian legal definition of harassment: https://www.crcvc.ca/docs/crimharass.pdf https://www.crcvc.ca/docs/crimharass.pdf Now, if I repeatedly followed you around, loudly mocking you and your use of "his majesty" and interfering with your life, then yes that would be harassment.
- 9y ago
- tomohawk 9y agoThis video captures some of his thoughts regarding this. It's the first question he answers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1F0A4rohauQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1F0A4rohauQ
- skrebbel 9y agoI'm sad that some enthusiastic well meaning lefties often associate Peterson with the extreme right. If anything, this man is radically centrist. It's just that he debunks extreme right wing arguments in 5 sentences instead of the 2 hour long talks he uses to address what he calls neo-marxism. I think people like him might very well help keep disgruntled young men away from the extreme right, by offering a moderate alternative. We should celebrate that long, balanced arguments get so much mainstream attention, even if we don't agree with them.
- naasking 9y ago> I think people like him might very well help keep disgruntled young men away from the extreme right, by offering a more moderate alternative. That's probably exactly right. People gather around ideologies that have advocates. They don't look at two extremes and say, "hm, they each have valid points, maybe I'm somewhere between these two", they say, "hm, this one thing side X says is something I really like so they must think most like me. Even though I don't particularly agree with a lot of the rest of what they say, and even if I disagree with side Y less overall, I belong in tribe X". Moderation/centrism thus also needs advocates if we want a proper balance.
- bitwize 9y agoYeah, he's a celeb on the derp-right because he goes hard on postmodernism and third/fourth wave feminism. That doesn't mean he agrees with the derp-right or the PUA contingent that have latched onto him. I think he gets postmodernism wrong and frankly, so do a lot of postmodernists. I see postmodernism as "Defense Against the Dark Arts". The postmodernist's tool kit -- the silly word games, denial of reality, and so forth -- are all borrowed from the right, and from capitalist society (in particular advertising and PR). And they play silly word games, talk in circles, and deny reality because they're preparing their students for a world in which the enemy have made that the norm for discourse. So when the postmodernist says "there is no reality" what they're really saying is the reality you know, and the rules for perceiving and inferring that reality, have been compromised. When Foucault says there's really no such thing as science, what he means is that science itself has been compromised, and you can't use science against the enemy because the enemy already controls it and will turn around and use it against you. But I like Peterson's style -- bombastic without being antagonistic, and highly principled -- and about the psychology bits he has some really interesting things to say.
- scribu 9y agoI prefer the chronicle.com article that appeared on the HN frontpage yesterday (and was swiftly burried, I suspect). It offered a broader context. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16188789 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16188789
- Dowwie 9y agoTo give someone a better idea who Jordan Peterson is and his experience with those in mass media: https://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2018/01/watch-cathy-newmans-catastrophic-interview-with-jordan-peterson/ https://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2018/01/watch-cathy-newmans-ca... I knew of Peterson but never read his work nor heard him speak. This interview could be an important piece for university level discussion. I think it summarizes problems among the media and intellectuals like Peterson.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoWatch: Cathy Newman’s catastrophic interview with Jordan Peterson I don't really know who he is other than seeing his name popup on Youtube regularly however I do note that his supporters always use that sort of language, often watch X destroy Y in an interview. There seem to be minorities at the extremes shouting past each other whilst the rest of us get on with our lives and wonder what all the fuss is about.
- Dowwie 9y agoThe Spectator does seem to be in his corner. These articles are from the same source. I didn't know who Peterson was but like you had also heard about him. I watched that interview and have a better idea. This interview could be an important piece for university level discussion. I think it summarizes problems among the media and intellectuals like Peterson.
- josephg 9y agoI think "watch X destroy Y" is just youtube's version of clickbait. I suspect you'll find videos like that tailored to most groups on youtube. I sometimes use them as trailers for longer talks that I might enjoy - although I always feel a little guilty for encouraging this sort of thing. In this case I found their interview to be excellent viewing. She was harsh and honest with him, and hurled most of the standard criticism at Peterson that people talk about. And while doing that she gave him the time and opportunity to respond. And he stayed calm, considered, articulate and entertaining throughout. I don't agree with everything either of them said, but I enjoyed watching that interview immensely - its exactly the sort of thing I want to see more of on youtube and in the public sphere. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54
- petercooper 9y agoTo me, it's a shame (and a sign of where media and culture are, right now) that the drama around pronouns and feminism are what people are jumping at with him. His teachings on the ideas of self identity, motivation, and the redefinition of religion as a system of archetypes and hierarchy are far more interesting and grounded in fact.
- collyw 9y agomore fact than people making up new genders?
- gizmo 9y agoMaybe it's because he jump-started his popularity by picking on transgender kids, using the flimsiest possible pretext. It shouldn't come as a surprise he has nothing of value to say about (identity) politics, because on that topic he doesn't have any expertise. He's just another guy with poorly conceived opinions. On the other hand he has been a clinical psychologist for 20 years and so (surprise!) he has accumulated some valuable insights along the way.
- apocalypstyx 9y agoHaving been raised in fundamentalist Christianity, Peterson always sets off preliminary warning bells for me: The enemy is all around you. Access to secret "true" knowledge. The world is corrupt. A plan that if you follow correctly will lead to good things. An enemy that alternates between specific and generalistic states. Everything has to be framed through a set of ideological points at all times, which are reiterated in the otherwise minorist points of life. That is not to say that he definitively is something of that kith or kin to that, necessarily. Just that I see several public figures these days that come out of one branch of science, platforming their knowledge of one field to the world of knowledge at large, and espousing thinking --- right down to phraseology, at times --- I have heard too often from sources these same individuals would claim to violently disagree with. Taking on Peterson's own postulations related to the co-evolution of the biological and memetic aspects of humanity (which in general I would agree with): I think the push to a what would otherwise be called a 'religious sensibility' can be --- and often is --- clothed in scientific language.
- raguuu 9y agoI have similar background and negative experiences, but I don't get the alarm bells but rather makes me appreciate some things I was being reached when young and also sad that the my fundamentalists parents weren't more like him. I'm am atheist as it gets but the Bible studies by him are fascinating. I remember the Bible stories very well but never thought about them in that light.
- apocalypstyx 9y agoIt's not the Biblical references / usages that bothers me, and that's in and of itself is not what I mean. I engage with it theology myself and often respect theological thinkers in regards to their arguments. This is always the problem when I try to bring this up: trying to convey that it is a religiosity creeping in, but a fundamental desire that exists as the foundational impetus of what we call religiosity, but which can find expression through other avenues in ways that are not immediately recognized as such.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 0x445442 9y agoI don't know how it happens but Peterson seems to always be engaged by the most logically challenged and intellectually dishonest individuals society has to offer. The recent channel 4 interview is the prime example of this. Now maybe it was all for show but the interviewer was utterly incapable of stringing even a few ideas together and at one point in the interview her mind visibly began to short circuit attempting to do so.
- raguuu 9y agoIt would be fun to see a debate with someone very different than him but actually someone who has arguments and date to back it up not just blind ideology.
- alexpetralia 9y agoI'd recommend Sam Harris' podcasts with Jordan in that case.
- 0x445442 9y agoYeah, a much higher level of discussion between two individuals exploring ideas.
- err4nt 9y agoI think a lot of why people like him is he speaks so CLEARLY, whether you agree with him or not you thoroughly understand his position, and he usually has some thought-provoking reasons for everything he says or does. I think people are starved for somebody who can be persuasive and calm, not relying on hyperbole or name-calling to make their points, and he shows everybody a way they can do that.
- Fezzius 9y agoHave you ever listened to him for one hour? He never answers a direct question, it's always wordsalad(no wonder people don't understand him) , he has a few interesting concepts which he repeats constantly His claim to fame is misunderstanding a discrimination law about transgenders. Which is all you need to know about him.
- ghoststories 9y ago"His claim to fame is misunderstanding a discrimination law about transgenders." If that was true, why did his university send him a warning letter that essentially confirms his concerns? He consulted a lawyer on the matter, he confirmed them as well. Laws are subject to interpretation, bad laws are subject to bad interpretations. He considers bill C-16 a bad law. There no "one correct understanding" of a law, otherwise we wouldn't need lawyers and legal cases would be trivial matters. The fact that you refer to bill C-16 simply as "a discrimination law about transgenders" shows that you poorly interpreted it yourself. "Which is all you need to know about him." I interpret that as a display of pure and utter ignorance - was that your intention?
- dingoonline 9y ago> If that was true, why did his university send him a warning letter that essentially confirms his concerns? He consulted a lawyer on the matter, he confirmed them as well. The Canadian Bar Association which represents over 37,000 lawyers, judges, notaries, law associates, law professors and students across Canada says this is a good thing and not the freedom of speech slippery slope that its been made out to be. https://www.cba.org/CMSPages/GetFile.aspx?guid=be34d5a4-8850-40a0-beea-432eeb762d7f https://www.cba.org/CMSPages/GetFile.aspx?guid=be34d5a4-8850...
- Synaesthesia 9y agoI personally love Noam Chomsky, but he’s not easy to watch speak (very motonous sounding) and his books are also mostly fact-laden. I think he’s toned down his heavy academic style a bit in his newer publications. Still his knowledge and wisdom are second to none IMO
- gizmo 9y agoThis is somewhat offtopic, but Chomsky speaks that way to stop his detractors from talking about his style. If he's too loud, too animated, too flashy, people will focus on him as a person as opposed to his ideas. His solution is to be as bland as possible, in the hope this forces people to engage with the substance and nothing else.
- Synaesthesia 9y agoYes he also dislikes appeal to emotion, or emotive talking, as it can be abused or be misleading.
- bitoneill 9y agoMy first exposure to Peterson were through his YouTube talks on depression. It's a family disease in his case since he, his father and daughter all suffered from severe depression. His YouTube video with his daughter about how they were able to get help with medication was very interesting. I am very glad he seems to have recovered and has gone on to make an impact in other areas.
- markdog12 9y agoChannel 4 interview with Peterson that's popular atm: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54
- skrebbel 9y agoThanks. I watched it, and I love it. I really like how the interviewer did, she presented the feminist view pretty well, while keeping her cool. Sure, she used her position as the one controlling the agenda well, quickly switching topics when pressed into a corner, but that's her job.
- markdog12 9y agoNot sure if sarcastic... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JkcXRC4HZqc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JkcXRC4HZqc