4 ms·
Why would someone who says that lie have your vote? Unless you're under investigation or living somewhere like Iraq, the government is not spying on you through
by lern_too_spel 9y ago
Why would someone who says that lie have your vote? Unless you're under investigation or living somewhere like Iraq, the government is not spying on you through giant corporations, as both the law and Snowden's leaks show.
- whatshisface 9y agoThrough a sufficiently creative definition of spying, nobody has been spied on in human history. Otherwise, we're forced to contend with the fact that we are being caught in the same dragnets that were advertised to catch the next Osama. (Not advertised to us, of course - we had no serious chance to vote on it.)
- lern_too_spel 9y agoWhich dragnets? Be specific. The phone metadata dragnet doesn't exist anymore, and the way it was used according to Snowden's documents when it did exist could hardly be called spying on OP.
- whatshisface 9y agoHere's a detailed writeup. It had been claimed that the phone tracking was reduced, the rest clearly remains: https://www.aclu.org/issues/national-security/privacy-and-surveillance/nsa-surveillance https://www.aclu.org/issues/national-security/privacy-and-su... I understand that some disagree with the other (and past) positions of the ACLU and may be disinclined to trust its website. Fortunately this issue isn't a particularly party-based one. Here's another good source, although it also says a lot about the history of the leaks: https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying If there is any accurate secondary source that is clearly conservative, It'd be welcome for me to see it in a reply. There's no particular reason why we'd have to porkbarel this issue - presumably there would be no party affinity at all. Edit: I know that there is lots of text behind those links, but the issue is an expansive one. I sincerely invite you to read them!
- lern_too_spel 9y agoThe rest? What rest, specifically? Which program includes spying on OP and lying about it? I have read Snowden's publicly released documents, so I know that there is no rest that satisfies OP's claim. I sincerely invite you to read the links you posted and look for it, instead of presuming they say something they don't. Edit: Specifically, the EFF claims that the NSA is copying all the data that goes into Room 641A. This despite that they know that the device in that room is a filtering device (Narus deep packet inspection) and that Snowden's documents specifically show that the NSA filters the traffic for targets' communications. There remain no documents that support the EFF's claim. The ACLU document you linked does not claim anything about spying on OP. Edit 2 (whatshisface: too many conspiracy theorists downvoting facts for me to reply): Here is the document released in 2013: https://www.aclu.org/foia-document/government-letter-fisc-re-clarification-nsas-upstream-collection-pursuant-section-702 https://www.aclu.org/foia-document/government-letter-fisc-re.... Quoting the relevant section, "As previously described to the Court, in conducting upstream collection using electronic communication accounts/addresses/identifiers (hereinafter 'selectors') pursuant to Section 702, NSA acquires Internet communications that are to or from a tasked selector, or which contain a reference to a tasked selector." It continues, "NSA prevents the intentional acquisition of Internet communications that contain a reference to a targeted selector where the sender and all intended recipients are known at the time of acquisition to be located in the United States." Nope, no spying on OP here. Do you have any documents that say otherwise, or are you going to keep sticking your fingers in your ears and pretend that evidence exists without actually presenting it? Edit 3 (nyolfen): Isn't it funny how no documents exist that corroborate Binney's wacky claims, even after the Snowden leaks? Isn't it funny how Binney continues to make nonsensical claims like the NSA having 5 zettabytes of storage, which is orders of magnitude more than Google, Amazon, and Microsoft combined? Isn't it funny how Binney always claims to be a genius but talks like an idiot? See discussion above about your unsourced cable splitter collecting everything claim. Also, you've hilariously misread what EvilOlive was. It doesn't bounce traffic off a foreign router. It was an implementation of a rule change that allowed collection of traffic from targeted individuals as long as one end was foreign, where previously both ends had to be foreign. https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/27/nsa-online-metadata-collection https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2013/... > what standard of evidence besides nsa admitting as much would you accept? Any document at all showing mass spying on Americans. I won't hold my breath. If there was nothing in Snowden's millions of documents, why why should I believe it exists?
- besselheim 9y agoIt makes sense to collect everything possible, then discard what you don't need later, because when conducting an investigation you don't know in advance which data are of interest. If your communications are intercepted, stored, but then never looked at, and eventually deleted - this is functionally equivalent to having never been collected at all.
- tgragnato 9y agoWe have already had proofs of the LEAs inability to keep TS information safe, expect a worse level of protection for routinely intercepted phone calls, emails, ... It's very very difficult (some people say impossible) to assure 100 percent that people's data have been safely stored and transmitted for their whole retention lifetime.
- besselheim 9y agoThat's an argument for ensuring that such data is properly secured, not an argument against collecting it in the first place.
- tgragnato 9y agoIf you ask me, keep one or the other. The inability to maintain the operational reliability of a datastore (including backups), does not inspire confidence. Assuming this is an incident and not a coverup.
- whatshisface 9y agoThere's one big difference: if your data was never collected, then a breach (internal or external) doesn't endanger it. If it was "collected but never looked at," then it's subject to the integral of every mistake, malicious action or rule change from now until they loose it. One of the major things that Snowden revealed was that random nobodies had huge access to sigint material.
- besselheim 9y ago