6 ms·
Interesting, and sorry to hear about your bout with homelessness. I spent some time homeless as a teenager and it was awful. I can't imagine going through tha
by freedomben 9y ago
Interesting, and sorry to hear about your bout with homelessness. I spent some time homeless as a teenager and it was awful. I can't imagine going through that with kids.
I've wondered quite a bit about the basic income idea. One of the issues that has me stumped is what to do when AI and automation are taking lots of jobs that people currently do (like truck driving, which is going to disappear fast). I'm not sure providing only health care and not basic necessities will be enough.
Maybe at first people can retrain into other career fields, but the AI revolution will come swiftly and leave much wreckage in its path. I tend to think this will eventually be a very good thing, but it will wreak havoc and cause a lot of short term pain like the industrial revolution did in the 19th century.
Definitely interesting stuff to think about. Thanks for sharing.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoMachines previously were threatening to take jobs away. It ultimately led to many improvements for commoners, such as the 40 hour work week. We call it The Industrial Revolution. But no need to learn from history. We can just pretend that restructuring work isn't possible and act like what we are currently facing is utterly unique and the world hasn't seen anything like it before. (Not a swipe at you. I am just angry and frustrated about the entire world acting like only UBI can save us from the robot-job-pocalypse.)
- freedomben 9y agoTotally fair :-) I have also wondered if that wouldn't be the case. As machines take over, we may see new jobs created that never existed before, just (as you rightly pointed out) happened in the industrial revolution. I really hope this is the case actually. My certainty diminishes somewhat when listening to people like Ray Kurzweil talk about his Law of Accelerating returns (exponential growth)[1]. I wonder if things might be different this time around (change is too fast, too extreme/disruptive) due to things like the exponential growth curve. Of course we humans always like to think "this time is different" so who knows. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/ray-kurzweil-law-of-accelerating-returns-2015-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/ray-kurzweil-law-of-accelerat...
- cglace 9y agoIt definitely wasn't a seamless transition. I'm sure we will come out the other side but more than a few eggs will probably be broken along the way.
- JDiculous 9y agoYou're trivializing the turmoil of the Industrial Revolution. The 40 hour work week was only won after centuries of bloody labor revolts. https://futurism.com/what-the-industrial-revolution-really-tells-us-about-the-future-of-automation-and-work/ https://futurism.com/what-the-industrial-revolution-really-t... This time is fundamentally different because AI automates the human mind. Human input may always be needed, but fewer and fewer jobs are required to support the needs of the population. New quality jobs are not being created at a sufficient enough pace to be offset the loses.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI'm not trivializing anything. I spent 5.7 years homeless. I got off the street 4.5 months ago. We have a ridiculous number of homeless in the US. Meanwhile, rich tech giants talk of giving UBI to everyone as their solution to so many jobs going away. The jobs that are going away pay about $20k-$50k. UBI is expected to be $10k or maybe $18k. Articles that talk about this then write warm little vignettes about how lovely it will be to have that supplemental income on top of your low paid job, utterly ignoring the actual scenario posited that this money is in place of a job in a climate where there is little or no hope of getting another job. If you think the Industrial Revolution was bloody, you don't want to see what happens with millions of people getting just enough money to sleep in a tent and keep eating while the cops harass them and the system gives them no hope of getting back to a middle class lifestyle. They won't be actually starving. But they will be mad as hell and have nothing but time on their hands to plot a revolution and train for it.
- thriftwy 9y agoWith UBI, you have two important new options: - You can move away from expensive locale to a cheapest one. - You can find supplemental income: do something with your hands, provide services, etc. You have all day to do that. It shouldn't be that your time is worthless and nobody is willing to pay anything for it. - You can pool with other people to form a community, save on bulk. Three actually.
- 9y ago