4 ms·
I appreciate the effort in writing this readable paper, but I do find the analogies in the first few sections to be quite strained. Here's an example: > Alice
by kccqzy 9y ago
I appreciate the effort in writing this readable paper, but I do find the analogies in the first few sections to be quite strained.
Here's an example:
> Alice decides it is time to blockchain her supply chain. She rents some cloud storage to hold the ledger, and installs internet-enabled temperature sensors in each frozen yogurt container. She is concerned that sensors are not always reliable (and that Bob may have tampered with some), so she wires the sensors to conduct a Byzantine fault-tolerant consensus protocol, which uses several rounds of voting to ensure that temperature readings cannot be distorted by a small number of of faulty or corrupted sensors.
Now, since all frozen yogurt containers pass from Carol to Bob to Alice, doesn't Bob at some point in time have access to all the frozen yogurt containers and their temperature sensors? Then Bob can easily corrupt all of them, rendering this scheme useless. He can, for example, replace all of the sensors by malicious sensors that report wrong temperatures when they are in Bob's truck.
Is there something I'm missing?
- wsxcde 9y agoThe assumption is that there are only "a small number of faulty or corrupted sensors."
- cdetrio 9y agoIts easy to go through a couple containers and find/replace a few sensors. But it would be a lot of work for Bob to go through every single yogurt container and corrupt all the sensors.
- dragandj 9y agoHmmm. But, how does a distributed blockchain help anyway?
- Donzo 9y agoAll of the censors vote on if they have been tampered with. They will leave a record of their votes on the blockchain as Bob tampers with them in real time.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vertex-four 9y agoSo Bob tampers with them all to record “everything’s fine” all the time. What now?
- Donzo 9y agoFinally! He can melt all the ice-cream and destroy his customer. No, Bob's misconduct would potentially be provable in court based on the trustless data ledgers in the blockchain. Really, this example just shows one way how developers could use blockchain technology to develop applications that utilize trustless data. Imagine this same technology applied to the transfer of human organs, rather than easily replaceable ice cream. Challenge yourself to think of other scenarios in business where trustless data might make a difference. Maybe you'll have a valuable idea in this wide open space.
- vertex-four 9y agoIf you have trust in a court, you don't need a trustless system, by definition.
- Donzo 9y agoSlippery slope: I can trust the court if I don't have to trust the data. I can't trust the court if I have to subjectively prove my arguments.
- vertex-four 9y agoBut you can't trust the data if the systems providing - creating - that data are tampered with, by definition!