5 ms·
> Get people out of computer apps and onto phone or web apps. That's a funny line to take in a comment thread about the rising threat of compromised mobile dev
by toyg 9y ago
> Get people out of computer apps and onto phone or web apps.
That's a funny line to take in a comment thread about the rising threat of compromised mobile devices. From the article: "Mobile is the future of spying, because phones are full of so much data about a person’s day-to-day life." Also "it doesn’t require a sophisticated or expensive exploit.. Instead, all Dark Caracal needed was application permissions that users themselves granted when they downloaded the apps."
So actually, by pushing people to mobile, you're pushing them exactly where bad actors want them to go.
Yes, it's fairly difficult to pwn an iPhone, but we know that state actors can actually do it when they really want to (we know from Snowden that they stockpile exploits), and there is nothing you can do to actually increase your defenses - you cannot install firewalls, antiviruses or any other threat-detection software. Android (as demonstrated here) is trivial to compromise. On top of that, mobile apps and OSes simply cannot be airgapped. They rely on the cloud, which is another humongous surface attack.
A well-configured opensource-running personal computer where the user does not have the root password is as secure as an iPhone, if not more.
- tptacek 9y agoWhat does the root password have to do with anything? Linux-on-the-desktop-types have been dropping this line for years. What does a user want to protect on their computer? Ask a Unix sysadmin and you'll get answers like "the integrity of /sbin, /lib, and /etc". Ask a human and you'll get an answer like "my email and personal information". The humans are right: that's what the targeted attackers are after (as you'll see if you read this report, where the programs that get installed don't even try to privilege escalate).
- toyg 9y agoThe root password has to do with installing apps. These apps go through a process designed to allow non-root users to install privileged apps - the privilege escalation is there, it’s simply allowed by design. And that’s Wrong. It’s almost as wrong as the standard Windows mode of running as a local administrator. I’m not sure what the solution is, but it’s fallacious to say mobile security is so much better than desktops, because it’s not. Desktops can be secured by an “adult” sysadmin, in the mobile world this role is left entirely to Apple and Google - and as it has been proven over and over again, they fail at it, probably because they are too big. A local admin has to review a handful of apps, Google and Apple have to do it with bazillions apps and they will inevitably slip.
- tptacek 9y agoYou don't need root privileges to install an application on a general-purpose operating system (or to install plugins and extensions to applications). Root credentials are a red herring --- except, ironically, on iOS.
- toyg 9y agoDesktop OSes can be locked down pretty extensively, and that’s where the root password (a concept that includes sudo, policies, UAC etc) comes into play. You can have all sorts of locks that won’t open unless the admin says so. That is the point. On mobile you get only what Apple and Google give you, and there is very little you can do about it.