4 ms·
In the U.S., a public education is considered a right. Driving is a privilege, not a right, and so the same considerations don't apply. For example, we already
by gamblor956 9y ago
In the U.S., a public education is considered a right. Driving is a privilege, not a right, and so the same considerations don't apply.
For example, we already charge drivers for the privilege of driving: annual license fees, mandated insurance, gasoline taxes, etc. Congestion fees/taxes are simply an extension of the costs associated with the driving privilege.
With respect to schools, we already have a de facto congestion charge, in the form of housing prices near desirable schools. In many states, property taxes near desirable schools are also higher to reflect the greater desirability of the neighborhood.
- dnautics 9y agoBut the "right to an education" doesnt feel like a right in the same way as "the right to free speech" is it "the right to not have your house used as quarters for troops"... What makes that difference?
- jl6 9y agoThis is the difference between “freedom from” and “freedom to” - two very different concepts of freedom which are disserved by sharing a name.
- rsync 9y ago"In the U.S., a public education is considered a right. Driving is a privilege, not a right, and so the same considerations don't apply." I find this conversation very interesting - first, the thought provoking notion from your parent that supporters of congestion pricing invoke a "libertarian but only for this" exception that they wouldn't apply to other goods like schools. Then your (obvious) reply that driving is not a right, but a privilege. I would counter that while driving is certainly a privilege, the roads themselves are a right, or a public good, comparable to schools. So regardless of what hoops you have to jump through to purchase and license your car, once jumped, the roads are analogous to the schools. FWIW, I am personally enthusiastic about congestion pricing and have heard nothing but good things about its deployment in London. I would like very much to have it considered here in San Francisco.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoRoads are by definition not a public good. A public good is non-rivalrous; roads are rivalrous as can clearly be seen if you look outside during rush-hour.
- Terr_ 9y agoEcono-technically a "common good" then. But on a colloquial level, they're still a-good-that-is-made-available-and-for-the-public.
- apendleton 9y ago> the roads themselves are a right, or a public good Transportation is the public good. Roads are one means of providing it, but there are others, like public transit. It's up to the government to determine how best to provide that public good given existing constraints in funds, time, land area for roads and other transportation infrastructure, environmental considerations, etc. They've apparently determined that the distribution of modes is suboptimal, and are creating economic incentives to shift it and better pay for it, but ultimately people will still be able to get places one way or another.
- willyt 9y agoRoads have only been a public good since 1888 in the UK. Before this it was common to pay a toll to be able to use a road. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toll_roads_in_Great_Britain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toll_roads_in_Great_Britain
- moogleii 9y ago> I would counter that while driving is certainly a privilege, the roads themselves are a right, or a public good, comparable to schools. So regardless of what hoops you have to jump through to purchase and license your car, once jumped, the roads are analogous to the schools. FWIW, roads were for people first, not cars.
- 9y ago
- rlanday 9y agoObviously there's no "right" for a kid to get into one of those high demand schools though. Otherwise we're already violating the rights of everyone who doesn't get a spot (and/or their parents, if you believe the primary reason they're so motivated to get their kids into these schools is so they can brag about it to other parents).
- gamblor956 9y agoObviously there's no "right" for a kid to get into one of those high demand schools though. Otherwise we're already violating the rights of everyone who doesn't get a spot That's not obvious, since it depends on the state and even the district. In districts that determine enrollment geographically, a child does have the right to go their local high school if they are within the zone assigned to that school. This has been a contentious issue in districts in CA and NY when they redraw school feeder zones (usually when opening up new schools or closing non-performant schools). [Note that like all rights, it can be limited, if for example the student gets suspended or expelled for disciplinary issues. This is similar in context to the prohibition on firearm ownership by felons.]
- jeffdavis 9y ago"In districts that determine enrollment geographically, a child does have the right to go their local high school if they are within the zone assigned to that school" So, separate but equal then?
- rlanday 9y agoIf what school you go to is entirely determined by where you live, you can already buy your kids' way in by buying a house or renting an apartment in the district. I don't think that's fundamentally any different from buying your way in directly, except that it's probably more expensive, since you're essentially forced to also pay for whatever else makes the neighborhood desirable, instead of being able to pay for only the school admission.