4 ms·
That’s a myth What's a myth, that torture doesn't work? Imma need a citation on that one, because I've got stacks of 'em to the contrary.
by mikestew 9y ago
That’s a myth
What's a myth, that torture doesn't work? Imma need a citation on that one, because I've got stacks of 'em to the contrary.
- mcbits 9y agoMost people will hand over their wallet, phone, car keys, passwords, and spill their darkest secrets if you just point a toy gun at them and raise your voice. Some won't, but saying "torture doesn't work" as a blanket statement implies that they all have infinite pain tolerance.
- drdrey 9y agoPeople will also confess to anything and say whatever they think you want to hear under torture.
- mcbits 9y agoSure, it doesn't always work. Some people will also withstand torture and take their secrets to the grave. But "torture doesn't always work" is a far cry from "torture doesn't work." A more believable amoral/utilitarian argument against torture is that there will always be a more effective method than torture available. That's probably also wrong, but at least it's not so obviously wrong on its face. The problem with the argument is that if a would-be torturer finds evidence that torture is the most effective method in some circumstance, they will feel vindicated in using it. I think a better argument is "regardless of effectiveness, anyone crossing this line is a dangerous and despicable person, and shall be prosecuted."
- Gatsky 9y agoMost people are carrying a wallet, phone, car keys. How many people that get tortured actually know anything?