3 ms·
I'm not a particle physicists by any means, but doesn't any theory of gravity have to deal with 'real' infinities at high energies from the physics we already k
by pixl97 9y ago
I'm not a particle physicists by any means, but doesn't any theory of gravity have to deal with 'real' infinities at high energies from the physics we already know?
We have some idea that black holes are a type of singularity (something that could possibly called an infinity). With E=MC2 we have an idea that if you apply enough energy to a particle it can become massive enough that it becomes a singularity itself.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoA singularity popping out of the math is almost always an indication that something else is going on. According to general relativity, at the center of a black hole there might be some kind of "singularity" - but in reality what that means is GR is probably inadequate, when used alone, to describe the center of a BH. "Singularity" really means "your math broke and you need to fix it" by bringing in another theory that can fill in the gaps - or, rather, extending the current theory in a way that eliminates the division by zero.
- pmiller2 9y agoNo, not really. A singularity in a quantized theory would simply be a place where gravity is strong enough that you can't move more than a Plank distance away from it.
- RuggeroAltair 9y agoThe issue is not only about mass. Any mass could form a black hole, the main point is about mass density, and that's not trivial to obtain. That aside, real infinities is a vague concept. What's important is that any theory of gravity has to deal with the fact that the current understanding of classical gravity and quantum field theory make (when you combine them) a theory that has problems at the Planck scale. Those are problems that any theory of quantum gravity or every theory of everything have to deal with. But it doesn't mean that those potential theories would have any infinities. Such a theory, though, has been very elusive. With the exception of string theory, which is the leading theory in terms of its success, most theories tend to have fundamental problems. String theory research is certainly not complete, but it's in my opinion currently the best shot we have. Online, and in academia, you can find lots of very opinionated discussions about it, which include aspects of testability, predictivity, etc. which means that some people really dislike string theory and prefer other approaches.