4 ms·
Health insurance companies have taken to denying almost every claim that hospitals file. This overtaxes the hospitals claims denial departments and costs hospi
by mywittyname 9y ago
Health insurance companies have taken to denying almost every claim that hospitals file. This overtaxes the hospitals claims denial departments and costs hospitals millions in lost revenue because they don't have the staff to properly review and resubmit every claim (which has to be done by a clinical specialist).
It's like taking your car to a mechanic, and once it's fixed, refusing to pay, claiming car didn't need THAT repair in the first place. Then getting away with it because you have an arbitration agreement in place with the shop. So the shop needs to employ an entire separate department of ASE certified mechanics that are dedicated to documenting that the repairs performed on customer cars were necessary. But the kicker is, YOU GET TO DECIDE IF YOU'RE CONVINCED THE REPAIR WAS NECESSARY.
Hospitals used to have small (1 person per 10k beds) claims denial departments and use outsourcing firms if case loads increased. Now they are acquiring all the outsourcing firms and increasing their staff to like 100 people per 10k beds. It's insane.
I like to retell a particularly awful denial my partner had to deal with, which was a patient had their open heart surgery claim denied by the insurance company because they determined that the patient's condition only warranted observational care (that's right, the insurance company determines what care you need/get). The hospital eventually won that claim, but they routinely lose $100k+ claims and have to eat the cost.
- garmaine 9y agoOn the other hand, when I bring my car to an auto shop they give an estimate of cost before actually doing any work.
- influx 9y agoNot only that but car insurance is for catastrophic events, not for tune ups, and oil changes.
- vkou 9y agoYour car is unlikely to experience life-threatening complications with a nearly unbounded upper cost while it's being fixed. Your body is. A routine surgery can absolutely turn into a hundred-thousand-dollar nightmare. Never mind that a mechanic has a much better understanding of a car, then a doctor does of a human body.
- prklmn 9y agoBut is the high cost of those surgeries a product of the broken system? I say yes.
- vkou 9y agoIn Canada, developing an accidental MRSA infection after a routine surgery will trivially turn a $5000 procedure into a $25,000 package of life-saving treatment and associated hospital stay. When things go bad in medicine, your bill grows really, really, really fast. Also, unlike a mechanic with a car, your doctor can't stop working on you after they blow through their quoted budget and ask if you still want to pay for treating the complications. I mean, they can, but unless you've got a death wish, you're not going to say 'no.'
- fencepost 9y agoAnd in the USA, it'll probably turn a 10-15k procedure into a 125+k scenario.
- hibikir 9y agoAh, but your chances of an MRSA infection aren't the same everywhere. Some hospitals are far better than others at preventing infection, while others are far worse. In a bill per procedure world, like in US medical billing, while I'd not expect anyone to do it badly on purpose, lax procedures that lead to more care are paid by the patient's insurance. In a government owned hospital, or if billing is done up front, it's the hospital's problem. American billing leads to no incentive to saving money, so guess what? US hospitals charge a lot more per procedure and perform somewhat more procedures than everyone else, so ultimately the price is higher. Even if nobody had insurance and shopped around, the US style of billing would lead to very little downward pressure on prices, as it's impossible to have a clue of what you are going to pay. Many businesses, including freelance developers, will not charge per hour, but by job. You jack up the price to end up ahead in the case of typical complications, but there are cases where you lose money, and that's on you being bad at estimates and billing. Billing by procedure in the medical system is just setting the wrong incentives, and a recipe for maximum waste, if not downright fraud.
- majormajor 9y agoThe people I've known who needed expensive care (high-5-figures or 6-figures) were made well aware of the costs in advance, because at that point the facility wants to make sure your insurance will cover it beforehand. But it doesn't do that much for the patients - comparison shopping doctors and facilities is extremely stressful stuff and a lot of people would rather not think about it, even when some outcome info is available. And the exact details are never known up front, so then you're dealing with "it'll probably cost X more to do it at Y but there's probably a Z percent higher chance of a good outcome..." no-right-answer type serious business decisions. Emergency care is a different matter, I imagine, insurance-coverage-wise, but pre-approval seems to be fairly widespread for planned stuff these days.
- garmaine 9y agoExcept that medical providers don't honor the estimate in the same way an autoshop typically does and is required to do in many jurisdictions. They treat it as just that -- an estimate. You still get charged for whatever procedures are performed, which can change from the estimate when situations change or they deem something to be medically necessary in the moment.
- mywittyname 9y agoTrue story: my partner's department can't just sort denies by highest cost because they literally do not know how much the procedure actually costs and nobody in billing/finance can tell them either. She came home one day feeling pretty good about overturning a $180k denial. She checked back a few weeks later, and found the paid in full amount to be in the neighborhood of $10k after "negotiated discounts." The system is fucked. Had the denial gone through, that person would have been on the hook for the full 180k. (Or, to be more accurate, the hospital would have negotiated for $10k from the patient and written the remaining 170k off of their taxes)