3 ms·
I don't get it. How many urban areas with housing crunches have people living on property with enough room to build another house on? This seems like it's 100X
by tootie 9y ago
I don't get it. How many urban areas with housing crunches have people living on property with enough room to build another house on? This seems like it's 100X less efficient than apartment buildings which every densely packed city is already full of.
- dwater 9y agoMost East Coast American cities have neighborhoods that were built 100 years ago as suburbs because it was impractical to walk to downtown that are now considered inner city. Other areas of the country do as well, but I'm only speaking to my own experience in the Mid-Atlantic. These neighborhoods are higher density than modern suburbs but much lower density than downtowns. People like the character of these neighborhoods because they seem to offer a good mix of being centrally located but still quiet and pleasant. The people who live in them try to keep that character through zoning and NIMBYism. This is a compromise to preserving what the residents like while allowing slow increases in density. A reasonable next step would be to allow duplexes and triplexes up to a certain density like 2 per block or something. That way the neighborhood could develop over time without causing the outrage that tends to accompany a developer getting a variance to throw up a modern boxy 4+ story apartment/condo building in an otherwise 1-3 story neighborhood.
- 88 9y agoIn the UK lots of homeowners make marginal increases in density with loft conversions, extensions, garages converted into bedrooms, 'beds in sheds', etc. The areas where this happens the most (typically low density suburban housing) really need razing to the ground and replacing with much higher density apartment buildings. To my mind, homeowners investing more money in these properties is only decreasing the likelihood of that ever happening.
- danans 9y agoThe underlying principle is incremental upzoning. By rezoning neighborhoods to just the next incremental higher density level (Single family homes to duplexes, triplexes, SFH+ADU), you allow for housing supply growth in a way that doesn't rapidly change the neighborhood character, and incentivizes households to participate in the growth, rather than just large developers. It also can result in a more stable appreciation of land values than going from SFH zoning to large apartment zoning. See: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/12/12/the-power-of-growing-incrementally-series https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/12/12/the-power-of-...
- philwelch 9y agoIt's a political compromise. Seattle has a huge housing crunch, and not coincidentally, half the city is zoned for single family housing. Upzoning single-family housing all the way to apartments is politically difficult, but ADU's (we call them "mother-in-law apartments" in Seattle) are an easier sell.
- apendleton 9y agoADUs aren't necessarily just separate structures. English basements/garden apartments with separate entrances also count (and are also banned in many jurisdictions), and for many cities, rowhouses/townhouses with ADU potential make up a large share of the housing stock. DC and Boston are prominent examples.