3 ms·
One of the best things about being independent: You can't tell everybody to fuck off, but you can tell anybody to fuck off. That's clearly great because then yo
by wpietri 9y ago
One of the best things about being independent: You can't tell everybody to fuck off, but you can tell anybody to fuck off. That's clearly great because then you don't end up doing dumb, pointless work because some executive said so.
But the subtly great part is that clients get better results. They know they don't own you, that you have other options. So they have to take your advice seriously. They may not follow it, but they'll at least listen. Which, counterintuitively, means you'll have a lot less desire to actually tell people to fuck off than you would in a regular job.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoLately, that just sounds like the dream.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoIf you're a permanent employer, you usually can't flat out refuse, true. But I still think we have a responsibility as professionals to tell people why their ideas are shit - politely. management: "I want an app that does A to solve business problem B" programmer: "If you want to solve B, you're better off with an app that does C. If you do A you'll run into problems X, Y, and Z. I can do A but i strongly advise against it" Far too many programmers just go ahead and do the first idea and then it inevitably falls apart, because they're too scared to act like professionals and give their own professional recommendations.
- stronglikedan 9y agoProbably because far too many managers will blame the programmer for any failures that result from following the recommendations, no matter how tangential, while simultaneously taking the credit for any successes.
- cosmie 9y agoI think one of the more fundamental issues is the programmers access to that conversation itself. I’ve seen this scenario be far more common when developers try to get business context : Management: “I want an app that does A.” Programmer: “Alrighty. Can you give me more details on why you want that app and what you’re hoping to achieve?” Management: “No. Now how long will it take to get App A out the door? Executive Foo said he wanted app A, so we need to give it to him ASAP.” Programmer feels satisfies they’ve at least tried, and any screwups are managements fault. Scrambles to get App A out the door. Management comes back with feedback Manager: “What is this? This isn’t what we asked for. It doesn’t even remotely address Business Problem B and now Executive Foo is on the warpath after championing this project and looking like a fool!” Management finds a way to convince Executive Foo it was all the overpaid, useless developers that screwed up and reinforces the stereotype of IT being an untrustworthy and frustrating blackhole of a cost center. Management saves face and they pay a consultant to do it. The programmer is left dizzied by the sudden political flak they were just blindsided by.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoHa! I'll take your word for it. Makes me think I would not last long at all in that kind of workplace, as I'd go right over managers head to executive foo with evidence if he pulled that on me.
- cosmie 9y agoI've only worked in a place like that twice. Once (a large company), I didn't last long. In the other (a growing company), the blame-shifting and credit-stealing politics and the people who brought them in didn't last long. In that situation, it's really a lose-lose for the developer. If they go over their manager's head, they've just made a very unfortunate enemy. And as the manager has more rapport and access to the executive, it's likely going to wind up fruitless as the manager finagles doubt into your evidence (by leaning on that existing relationship and handwaving misunderstandings and referencing non-existent verbal conversations into the points of contention that you raised). And if they don't go over the manager's head, they now have an internal reputation for incompetence that'll negatively impact the rest of their time at that employer. So they're screwed either way. At that point it's better to just leave rather than make waves. If you make waves they can come back to drown you later on during your career or job search. If you leave with little ado it stays more compartmentalized to that toxic environment.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoI'm glad I haven't experienced anything quite like that. Your decision to just get out is probably the best one.
- wpietri 9y agoYes! I think the difference between minions and professionals is that professionals have standards. Doctors, for example, won't just do anything patients ask. Too many programmers seem to think they're minions. The job market for programmers is great; I wish more of us used that to stand our ground when asked to do something irresponsible or unethical.
- lisper 9y agoTelling people to fuck off sucks. But being able to tell people to fuck off is awesome. There's an analogous aphorism: it's not working that sucks, it's having to work that sucks.
- 0xWilliam 9y agoExcept we're inherently idle creatures. So while you may be right in some silly marxian sense. 90% of us would do nothing until forced to due to biological needs.
- lisper 9y agoThat might be true of the population in general, but I doubt it's true of the kind of person who hangs out on HN. Even among the population in general, I don't think people enjoy being idle for long. We're curious creatures. We seek out novelty and challenges, and we don't like to feel useless.
- wpietri 9y agoI think you're entirely wrong. There's a great bit in Johnstone's Impro where he has people paint simple pictures, and then shows them the work of others. The people exclaim at how bold, how creative the shown work is compared with theirs. The difference is that the old paintings are by kids, and the new ones are by adults. His point is that kids have a natural creativity that gets trained out of them over time. One can get that back. (In his case, he helps people get it back through improvisational theater classes. They work!) 90% of people have been forced to do things most of their lives. First through an industrial-age education system, then by employers running organizations designed to maximize compliance, not initiative, creativity, or agency. It's no wonder they have lost the joy of creation. Tech for me was the ticket out of work like that. It took me years to work through my resentment. But now for me there's a joy in creation, a joy in service that doesn't match anything I can get with mere consumption-oriented entertainment. My nephew has been in a Montessori program since kindergarten, and he's far from inherently idle. He loves learning. He loves creation. We all do, deep down, if we're half encouraged in it.
- EliRivers 9y ago