6 ms·
Designing Social Systems Without Causing Depression and War
- golemotron 9y agoThe article doesn't dare touch on the idea that online communities may actually be detrimental to good social interaction. We evolved for face-to-face. In-person relationships are rich, rewarding and not as prone to miscommunication.
- ngcc_hk 9y agoIt is unnatural and inhuman ... hence any social system that root out this is bad. Accept what we are and deal with it squarely. Escape is not a solution.
- betimsl 9y agoMaybe this is one way/method to deal with it? Squarely?
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoI am convinced of the future existence of MOOPs - massive online open psychology - where we aggregate the daily actions of millions (arguing with children, discussions with the boss, food choices etc) and look for patterns and better choices for each of us at the upcoming moment (Siri, what is the best way to tell my wife her bum does look big in that, ... based on 500,000 similar conversations, the best 1% responses were when the phrase "xxx" was used) This is feeling similar - that we need or want our virtual environment to help us - in practise sessions as he seems to say, or in advice It seems we want science, but at the level of our personal, everyday, choices. we want to trust our computing environments have our best interests at heart. and that kind of means no commercial interests can be involved.
- bmomb 9y agoI think a world in this scenario is pretty much a dystopia. If every person chooses for the better response and action given the a situation how can a individual be unique? If all husbands reply to a bum in the exactly same way why do you really need a husband? Failing is a big part of being human, sometimes that can cause harm but failing and learning is one of ours core functions. I rather be good than be you? (Sorry if i made my post a bit 'agressive', its not my intent, english is not my main language and i still have to learn how to write properly)
- crypt1d 9y agoI don't think that every husband would be replying the same to the 'bum problem'. I'd expect the response to be tailored based on some specific traits of both husband and wife and based on experience in similar types of marriages/relationships. I do agree with you that I'd rather make my own mistakes, than try to be a perfect partner by using an app. The idea is definitely interesting, but scary at the same time. It sounds like something out of The Black Mirror show :) P.S. your English is great, nothing to worry about!
- gregknicholson 9y ago> I'd expect the response to be tailored based on some specific traits of both husband and wife and based on experience in similar types of marriages/relationships. I'm wary of trying to reverse-engineer human behaviour, especially as it applies to personal relationships. Besides, who decides what's the “best” course of action here? Who decides what the goal is — length of relationship? Happiness? (How do you measure that? Pleasure endorphins? Well then the correct response is you should stop talking to your partner, and do some exercise and drugs!) In practice, the person who decides is the person in Google's office at 17:00 on a Friday. (This is why driverless cars are hellishly scary, by the way. Any car that can be controlled by computer should have to use only publicly-auditable software — i.e. everything must be open-source and all builds must be fully reproducible. At least then you can theoretically be certain you know who your car will decide to save in an emergency, and why. How long before `git blame` is invoked in court in a murder case?)
- gregknicholson 9y agoI think it boils down to 2 options: 1. Persuade people to choose to be kind. 2. Manipulate people so that they act in a kind way (or avoid acting in an unkind way), without necessarily wanting to be kind. Option 1 means you need a good way to remove unkind people from your own experience (“free listening”). This is typically not popular with commercial social network services, because this lets you ignore adverts too. Option 2 reduces this need, but leads to the problem of who is “allowed” to do the manipulation, and who decides this? When communicating in person, most people have years of learned behaviour (learned from millennia of social norms) nudging them towards acting kindly (or at least not actively unkind), because in person there are immediate, unavoidable social consequences. These consequences are absent when communicating remotely, such as via the internet. I'll let you decide for yourself whether this counts as option 1 or option 2.
- indigochill 9y agoI don't understand your criticism of option 1. As a Facebook user, I can remove anyone I want from my feed either by "unfriending" them or simply unsubscribing from their feed. Ads are not people so Facebook doesn't provide a facility for unsubscribing from them (and I assume they do some kind of curation on them since they generally seem of decent enough quality for internet ads). Of course, I use an ad blocker to ignore them anyway, but that's beside my lack of understanding of your criticism. To your criticism of option two, I think this is the fundamental flaw in the goal of engineered social systems. There are groups which have radically different ideas about what is "kind". Extreme religious fanatics would say it's unkind to let someone "live in sin", so extreme measures are considered kind for the spiritual well-being of the individual and the community. Secular western thought is more interested in material well-being, so it would say kindness is the promotion of the material well-being of others, generally without passing judgment on how they choose to live (except insofar as it violates others' material well-being). So the decision of who decides what's kind can lead to completely different interpretations of what kindness is and how the social system behaves.
- circlefavshape 9y agoI think you're conflating "kind" with "moral" here. I've never heard of a religious person justifying censure of a sinner based on kindness
- uoaei 9y agoGood and ethical behavior should be incentivized, both on short and long timescales. It is obviously not enough to punish the wrongdoers, because our laws don't prevent everyone from killing, discriminating, or exploiting their fellow people. Currently so much rides on mere survival that the only effective objective function we have to consider our actions is that of money. Either the capitalist system needs to be diversified to encourage multi-objective optimization wrt quality of life across all lifeforms, or it needs to be dismantled and another form of cooperation that directly incentivizes helping your fellow human/animal survive should be installed. Think about it like this: rather than writing some complicated optimization algorithm that sometimes climbs hills and sometimes descends them according to some arbitrary judgment scheme, we redesign the objective function so that all ethical behavior lies along stable manifolds. We can effectively hack human psychology by exploiting its predispositions to incentivize ultimately good behavior. This "good behavior" doesn't even necessarily need to be complex or controversial: something as simple as the Golden Rule would likely be sufficient. E: to add that I recently attended a contemporary art exhibition where one of the exhibits was the introduction of a new cryptocurrency called Kineticoin[1], which supposedly awards artistic contributions to society. How exactly to distribute this value is up for debate, but it is a sorely needed one, IMO. [1] https://kineticoin.weebly.com/ https://kineticoin.weebly.com/
- qazpot 9y agoI have a few questions for you Who gets to decide what is "Good" and "Ethical" behavior ? What exactly would be the "incentive" "Good" and "Ethical" behavior. ? You say that capitalism can be dismantled in favor of another form cooperation that directly incentivizes helping your fellow human survive. Is this not in direct contradiction the base animal instinct of self survival. The incentive would have to be huge in order to override this base instinct. You suggest Golden Rule as sufficient way to define "good behavior". But Golden Rule itself has shortcomings and criticism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule#Criticism). Do you have any sufficient argument against these criticism.
- liberte82 9y ago
- JepZ 9y agoActually, I find it interesting how HN incentivizes good behavior with their karma system. Yes, HN discussions are most of the time not about social values, but nevertheless I found that it changed me a bit, so that I think more about how to write my comments. So what I like about the system, is that (for experienced users) down voting is allowed and that a down voted comment is getting less attention (less karma damage, less reader damage) and that is getting faded out (so while reading comments you can quickly skip the bad comments). That way, you don't have to be afraid of writing a bad comment accidentally, because the system takes care of it, but when you write one you can see that that less people are reading it compared to a good one. I just wish down voting would require writing an answer. Nothing is more frustrating than a down voted comment when you do not know why people didn't like it. Over the past years, I found that other readers like comments which tell them something new and insightful about the topic. Links for further reading and as references for opinions are also appreciated.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoTo be contrary, I find HN/Reddit point systems to be related to the degradation of discussion. It's a popularity contest. Good comments do not always get upvoted (in fact, they may be downvoted because people don't want to hear it). But salacious and ill-informed stuff gets upvoted a lot. You very quickly get hive minded behavior: similar beliefs get upvoted, contrary ones get hidden, so soon enough you've got an echo chamber, powered by worthless Internet points. It's a very basic hack on our psychology - we like points, but maybe it's not alltogether good. It works ok on HN because it's a decent community with moderation intended to keep the discussion good. But Twitter and most subreddits are horrible abuses of this and I'm not sure people would spend so much time arguing on the Internet if they simply weren't rewarded so directly for doing so.
- JepZ 9y agoWell, you are right about the hive mind and the popularity contest and I don't know how to solve those things easily. But what I like about the system is that it reduces negativity (to some extend). So many internet discussions are full of nonconstructive, negative criticism that I am happy that the Karma system tries to hide such comments. But obviously it has its own problems :-/
- cirgue 9y agoThis article and this comment thread are prime examples of why the tech industry needs social science and humanities. There are literally centuries of human though and decades of experimentation that addresses this problem, and the constant throughout history is that it is is both hard and complicated.
- qazpot 9y agoYes the proposed solution in the article as well as some solutions proposed here in the comments ignore decades of theory and knowledge developed in social sciences, philosophy and other subjects by thousands of thinkers. I guess when you only have a hammer everything looks like a nail.
- kiliantics 9y agoSeriously. It's almost as if there was a concerted effort in the last century to stamp out any kinds of thought that opposed or threatened the dominant capitalist ideology of the global hegemonic powers...
- ferongr 9y agoSocial sciences and humanities do not adress any problems or give objective, actionable advice or guidance.
- sophistry 9y agoCan you give an example of a case where you've expected to find a solution in humanities and social sciences and been disappointed?
- craftyguy 9y agoFor a solution to be a solution, it has to work, right? I would argue that there are a great number of proposals in humanities and social sciences, but the fact that we are still plagued by war & depression means that the proposals either didn't work or cannot be implemented for whatever reason(s).
- indubitable 9y agoI don't think it can be taken as an assumption that "social systems" in the digital space can exist as a net social positive. The most fundamental problem in all groups is that 'well received' messages are far different than 'good' messages. And the feedback and filtering mechanisms in all current digital social systems strongly incentivize the former over the latter. And I don't think there's any particularly good way to solve this. Even in real life large purposeless gatherings of mostly bored people rarely leads to desirable things.