4 ms·
> We have a ton of aging and insufficient local/regional > infra that badly needs upgrades and expansion. That was _precisely_ the point of HSR--to slow grow
by wahern 9y ago
> We have a ton of aging and insufficient local/regional
> infra that badly needs upgrades and expansion.
That was _precisely_ the point of HSR--to slow growth in automobile traffic so there'd be less need to upgrade and expand the highway infrastructure. Airports and highways are immensely expensive.
There were extensively analyzed projections that showed investing in HSR was more sensible than doubling-down on the automobile. We can quibble over the calculus all day long, but that sort of quibbling is why we can never get sh*t done.
I live in the Richmond District of SF. We have one of the busiest bus lines in the country, and that's just one line out of 4+ parallel lines 2 blocks apart. Everybody here wants a subway, but the city is building BRT because of cost and as a compromise with local business owners (who don't want _anything_). Nobody wants BRT, but it's a done deal, and it irks me the amount of energy people put into killing BRT ostensibly in pursuit of a subway. It's idiotic. All it does is make BRT more costly without making a subway any more likely. If you want government to be more efficient, we need to come together as a community and learn how to compromise and _support_ infrastructure development. This stuff is costly because the opposition is a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- kelnos 9y ago> That was _precisely_ the point of HSR--to slow growth in automobile traffic so there'd be less need to upgrade and expand the highway infrastructure. That sounds weird to me. HSR serves a different set of people and solves different problems than local/regional transit does. As a simple example, I wouldn't see HSR reducing traffic on 101 or 280 between SJ and SF all that much. There are certainly some people who commute between SF (or very close by) and SJ (or very close by), but there are still plenty of people for whom driving to/from SF or SJ to catch the HSR to go to the other destination wouldn't make sense. The major benefits of HSR are people traveling between NorCal, Central Valley, and SoCal. The most common type of commute pain is only minimally helped by HSR. > [a bunch of stuff about BRT in SF] That would seem to support my point: that we need better local transit options, including a subway, and we need to find a way to get what we actually want and need, not what interest groups like local business owners want. I see this as completely unrelated to whether or not we need HSR, though.