3 ms·
> Leask agreed, saying an immediate declaration of invalidity would pose a "potential danger to the public or threaten the rule of law." What the fuck. I mean,
by mschuster91 9y ago
> Leask agreed, saying an immediate declaration of invalidity would pose a "potential danger to the public or threaten the rule of law."
What the fuck. I mean, thanks to Judge Leask for invalidating this practice - but that part is utter nonsense and causes up to a year of further suffering for affected people. They're not going to walk around in society so what is being threatened here?!
- peeters 9y agoAdministrative segregation is a legislated tool used for various problems within institutions, such as violence within the penitentiary. It's a flawed and now thankfully unconstitutional tool, but it is the established tool nonetheless. Simply removing that tool without giving Parliament time to legislate an alternative would leave them in a somewhat chaotic position. That's not to say that in the meantime, it's the status quo. Corrections Canada has essentially been put on notice, so any use of solitary going forward is going to be under more scrutiny, and hopefully some aspects of the decision (like not having the right to counsel during segregation hearings) will be corrected sooner than that.
- throwaway2048 9y agoits normal in Canada for the supreme court to rule a law unconstitutional, and give the government a deadline to fix it.