3 ms·
Why is violence as punishment morally wrong but very harsh mental conditions not? For that matter why is violence as punishment morally worse than involuntary
by gpm 9y ago
Why is violence as punishment morally wrong but very harsh mental conditions not?
For that matter why is violence as punishment morally worse than involuntary confinement as punishment. If Joe does either to you we all agree it's morally wrong, but for some reason we consider justice system sanctioned confinement fine, but not violence. Why?
(I'm assuming you understand violence to include "strapped to a chair and waterboarded" and "fed drugs that trigger pain receptors" - I'm not sure everyone considers the word violence to include those things)
Edit: I know it's against guidelines here to say this - but can we consider not downvoting pfarnsworth to hell - whatever you think of his opinions he is providing good discussion.
- megaman22 9y agoHonestly, for a lot of infractions, I'd take the early-modern dozen lashes with a cat-o-nines over the laborious, expensive and perilous processes that the modern legal system can put one through.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoI think as a society, physical violence is now considered "medieval" or primitive. Even things like spanking a misbehaving child is considered primitive. Whether that's justified, that's the current direction society is going. So non-violent methods of punishment will just be easier to sell than more violent methods.
- pishpash 9y agoYou're right, it's all stimulus. If we carry this further, would it be okay to one day feed a VR of some very disturbing experience as "prison"? Or for that matter, administer some drug that frightens you enough to induce negative feedback? Drugs are already used for the death penalty. It's not that far off.