3 ms·
It's hard for me to take this author seriously when the author makes it painfully clear that a) they don't read books and b) they don't know anything about the
by busterarm 9y ago
It's hard for me to take this author seriously when the author makes it painfully clear that a) they don't read books and b) they don't know anything about the genre or its roots.
- CodeMage 9y agoThe "Post-Cyberpunk" section was especially jarring. Right off the bat, the author classifies "Snow Crash" as post-cyberpunk.
- the_af 9y agoEverything that's jarring about the article seems to be taken directly from tvtropes. Now, I love tvtropes, but I'd worry about basing an article on "knowledge" from that site.
- kernelbandwidth 9y agoMissing Stephenson's The Diamond Age was a bit of an oversight as well, considering that Snow Crash is one of the canonical Cyberpunk novels, while The Diamond Age is (IMO) a defining Post-Cyberpunk novel. The Diamond Age opens with a Cyberpunk fake protagonist written with every Cyberpunk trope in mind, and then the fake protagonist is killed off before the end of the Prologue and the real protagonist, the slain punk's baby daughter, is revealed. Stephenson's intent is clear: "This is not a cyberpunk novel." I'd also argue that Cyberpunk does not mean "everything is terrible", nor does Post-Cyberpunk have a softer and lighter view where "not everything is terrible." Rather, the difference is whether social control is rooted in 1984 or Brave New World. From this point of view, Ghost in the Shell and Minority Report are still Cyberpunk (edit: settings); the viewer is just seeing things from a point of view other than the completely marginalized. Shadowrun is a Cyberpunk setting whether you work for a corporate power or in the streets.
- the_af 9y agoAgreed. The author also presents a highly confusing timeline for 1st wave cyberpunk, 2nd wave cyberpunk & postcyberpunk. Confusing enough that I don't understand why the author thinks his/her examples are 1st or 2nd wave. And I am well-versed in the genre!
- busterarm 9y agoAlso citing Minority Report the movie, repeatedly, and not Minority Report the PKD story...
- the_af 9y agoYes! And ignoring that PKD's story has a radically different ending, so different that its message is the opposite of the movie's.
- Pamar 9y agoBut is that really the case...? Many years ago I commenter on Slashdot gave his (or her, don't remember) take on the movie ending and since then I had to completely re-evaluate the whole thing. The film is now old, but... << SPOILER >> . . . . . . . . . . When Tom Cruise's is captured they put the "halo" containment device on him. If you remember, when they did the same to the guy who attempted to murder his wife at the start of the movie, he asked, understendably worried, what would happen to him, and the policeman answered something like "you will just dream what you want to dream". Ok, now consider that everything that happens from the moment that Cruise was arrested until the end is... a device-induced dream. He was framed for murder, and... he just spends his life (or an untold number of years) in confinment - but he dreams the whole ending. Over and over... This blew me away. Especially because it could hardly be more Dickian than this, while at my first watching the ending was too damn sugary/optimist/Hollywood for my tastes.
- the_af 9y agoThat alternative interpretation of the ending is well-known. I'd definitely prefer for it to be true. However, it's non-canon and there's no indication the scriptwriters actually intended for this interpretation to be true (it'd be awesome if it was). Even with this interpretation, the ending would be completely at odds with PKD's story. In the story, Anderton (Cruise's character in the movie) wants the system to work; the conspiracy wants to undermine Precrime. Because Anderton wants Precrime to go on, he actually commits the crime he was accused of(he indeed shoots his victim), thus showing the world Precrime works. Notice how the message of the movie is "Precrime is wrong" while the message of the story is "Precrime must go on" :)