4 ms·
Context notwithstanding too right? The comment I replied to used the term in the context of the 5 basic tastes, not as a culinary term.
by maxerickson 9y ago
Context notwithstanding too right?
The comment I replied to used the term in the context of the 5 basic tastes, not as a culinary term.
- ghaff 9y agoFair enough. It's almost certainly more correct to list umami as one of the basic tastes, rather than savory. (I was more commenting on Wikipedia suggesting they're the same thing when they're really not.)
- zeveb 9y ago> It's almost certainly more correct to list umami as one of the basic tastes, rather than savory. I really don't think so: 'savory' is an actual English word while 'umami' is a Japanese one. Writing 'umami' like writing 'arugula' instead of 'rocket' or 'cilantro' instead of 'coriander.' And 'umami' isn't really any more accurate than 'savory': it's a 100-year-old neologism from the Japanese word for 'delicious.' Given a choice between two words which aren't necessarily perfect fits for the concept, why not stick with the native one?
- empath75 9y agoBecause savory has other meanings in cooking and umami is a essentially a pure concept in English. Umami means one and exactly one thing.
- ghaff 9y agoExactly. Essentially English co-opted umami as a stand-in for glutamate-y which, we can probably agree is an aesthetic improvement. It's at least arguably a subset of savory but as I commented earlier there are clearly meanings of savory in cooking/baking that have no relationship to umami as the term is used in English.