3 ms·
The idea that a song is meant for multiple listens is an interesting claim but does not support the argument. If you won't like a song then what is the purpose
by klodolph 9y ago
The idea that a song is meant for multiple listens is an interesting claim but does not support the argument. If you won't like a song then what is the purpose of listening to it again? This whole perspective is backwards. Is it our responsibility to listen to songs multiple times, or is it simply the goal of an artist to make songs that we would listen to multiple times?
What any object is "meant for" shouldn't dictate how you use it.
- coldtea 9y ago>Is it our responsibility to listen to songs multiple times, or is it simply the goal of an artist to make songs that we would listen to multiple times? Ours obviously. Only trivial pop can be dismissed (or ear-worm its way) on a single listen. And the best works, the ones with the most depth, take multiple listenings to even begin to fully appreciate. One might not care about all this, and drop stuff they bought/downloaded to listen summarily in one listening. It's a free country, and nobody says they should be forced to do otherwise. But then -- and that's my argument, that person is not that different than people amassing tons of music and not hearing most of it even once. They might be slightly more involved, but not much more. >What any object is "meant for" shouldn't dictate how you use it Well, that's one viewpoint, a modern consumerist, where it's all about the individual and their whims, where their taste, consumption habits, and choices shouldn't be questioned. I opt for another, older viewpoint, where the individual should raise themselves to appreciate culture (music, books, movies, etc) and their choices can always be questioned and improved, and they can (and should) always strive to be better educated on them. In other words, a master work of art, does very much dictate how people use it, and if they're ever gonna get it, they should follow that path.
- JasonFruit 9y agoI'm not convinced that it's as obvious as you say, once the listener has "raise[d] themselves to appreciate culture." Once you've gained some appreciation for and understanding of music, within styles to which you're accustomed, you develop a sense of what will reward further listening and what will not. Is it infallible? Probably not. But even if it's not good enough for a published critic, it's enough to find me good music to listen to.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoA lot of music isn't immediately catchy on the first listen, and only becomes beloved after several impressions.
- __david__ 9y agoTrent Reznor described this as "albums that make you work for it". You don't like them the first time you hear them (or they just sound monotonous and undifferentiated). You don't like them the second time. But on subsequent listenings you start to notice things, things become familiar and you start liking it. And the crazy thing is that a lot of the time those albums (or artists) are the ones that get catapulted into "best album of all time" statuses. Definitely some of my top artists/albums of all time are ones that did not appeal to me on the first few listens.