2 ms·
I have mixed feelings about this article, agreeing with points and vehemently disagreeing with others. In particular I don't like the consumption rules for mus
by busterarm 9y ago
I have mixed feelings about this article, agreeing with points and vehemently disagreeing with others. In particular I don't like the consumption rules for music.
I have pretty anomalous/extreme music listening patterns. I've listened to every album in 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die (all editions of it...) at least once. When I was working remotely, I listened to about 16 hours of music every day, about 2/3 of that time spent listening to new music. I've done experiments where I've listened exclusively to Billboard & Oricon chart records for years at a time. I listened to Meshuggah's Catch 33 at least 4 times a day every day for a year and a half. Lately, I tend to spend my time devouring entire genres, learning all of the major talents & producers and the connections between them. My knowledge has become somewhat encyclopedic -- like a more-expansive, more-complete, mental version of Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music.
Once I learned that lyrics don't matter to me, I stopped reading them along with listening. I stopped reading liner notes. I haven't picked up a physical copy of an album in at least 9 years. If anything, the changing music consumption patterns have enabled me to appreciate more music in a manner that I prefer. Maybe it's okay for people to appreciate music the way they want and not to have to put albums on some pedestal anymore like people did with 70s Prog Rock.
Through all of this, I've retained my ability to be critical of music. Heck, I'm a cohost of a podcast where all we do is critique music. I would argue that it's not the change in consumption pattern that's to blame here, but rather a lack of tastemakers in public society and extremely negative reactions to criticism of any sort. Critical opinions are faux pas in our culture pretty much universally these days.
- davehtaylor 9y ago>a lack of tastemakers in public society I would call this a good thing. I despise the idea of someone telling me what I should or shouldn't like, as though I have no mind of my own to decide what I do or don't like, and as though they are somehow superior and have some kind of enlightened outlook on things that I could never hope to achieve.
- busterarm 9y agoYou're just exemplifying what I said later where critique is unwelcome. I don't think media is some egalitarian process where everyone is celebrated just for doing something. There's a lot out there in popular culture that is just outright technically flawed. Or just crap -- trust me, I've listened to more crap music and watched more crap movies than probably anyone (I much prefer to talk about the stuff I love though). We should be celebrating the stuff that's truly outstanding, not just because it's popular. Some really outstanding work isn't comfortable for the viewer/listener either. Do you even know what you really like anymore? A lot of stuff is just rammed down our throats. Your brain triggers that dopamine hit just for recognizing the pattern regardless. It's good for business, but is it _good_? I guess it all depends on how you about whether you feel media is artwork or entertainment.
- robryan 9y agoI generally don’t let it influence my opinion on a piece of music but if I find something I like I will almost always go and check what kind of reviews it is getting online. I like to know if something is widely liked or just appeals to my taste.
- hsod 9y ago> Critical opinions are faux pas in our culture pretty much universally these days. This is a very interesting thought. It may be relevant to the endless discussions of free speech we have here on HN. Got any recommendations for reading on this idea, or did you just come up with it?