3 ms·
But the answer is already "no," at least in some cases. You generally don't have a right to make frivolous defenses (e.g., I'm not guilty because the POTUS is a
by jcranmer 9y ago
But the answer is already "no," at least in some cases. You generally don't have a right to make frivolous defenses (e.g., I'm not guilty because the POTUS is a lizard person in a secret alien conspiracy and they're framing me to stop me from telling the truth), and courts have no obligation to aid you in such a defense. As an extension, you don't have a right to demand that your lawyer participate in a frivolous defense. If you concede to your lawyer that you committed a crime, then you can't insist that your lawyer profess your innocence in that crime to the court.
What's at stake here is two issues:
1. Is the choice of whether or not to concede to elements of the crime (this isn't the same as entering a plea) one of the rights that defendants retain even with a lawyer?
2. Does the fact that this is a capital case color the decision? English's argument was that conceding to the murder could help reduce the sentence from execution, and that his duty to minimize his client's sentence trumps other concerns.
Personally, the answer to the first question does seem to be "yes" to me, but the second question does give me some pause.