5 ms·
Predicting Death for Better End-Of-Life Care
- aaavl2821 9y agothis would be a really good application of AI in healthcare, but it needs to be considered in light of other predictive tools. a sr exec at a large health system said earlier this year that they evaluated a ton of AI tools for predicting death to inform end of life care, but none did materially better than simply asking physicians which of their patients they thought would die in 12-18 months. this AI may be better than the ones this exec studied of course even if AI performs better, it would need to offer improvements significant enough to justify the cost of implementing it, which depending on what data it uses could be non-trivial another unfortunate issue is that patient preference is only one consideration in determining how end of life care is managed. profitability is another concern. the same exec said that the health system only agreed to implement their improved end of life plan once they realized that it would be profitable to the system
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 9y agoEveryone from doctors to philosophers has been saying this for ages (literally). No healthcare provider, public or private, is likely to pick this up because people who are afraid of death will freak about about 'computer decides when you should die' and will get up a big enough moral panic to prevent any further discussion of the idea. Given that I think it's literally a waste of time and resources to program a computer to tell us what we already know. Edit: by 'program a computer' I don't mean to put down the work of the Stanford team, which I'm sure is great, but rather to highlight the reductionist way it will play in public debate.
- chx 9y ago> people who are afraid of death I am afraid to live after a certain point of time. When you have no direct descendants or significant other, when your bucket list is done, what's the point of keeping a slowly failing mind alive in a more rapidly failing body? I don't want to grow old, I fail to see why I should and there's no law, not even Canada that would allow me to choose a peaceful ending date for my own. And they call this suicidal which I am not. I have my life planned and I know when I want to end it, more than a decade from now. Some people plan to travel the world when they retire, I just want not to live but I can't.
- rdiddly 9y agoThere is no law anywhere that can stop you from killing yourself, much less punish you afterward!
- anigbrowl 9y agoTrue, but it used to be a crime in many jurisdictions and i you're open about it you can be forcibly placed in psychiatric care in many places right now.
- chx 9y agoQuite right. Here's an example: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskLEO/comments/2klr4p/have_you_ever_done_a_wellness_check_what_for_how/clmitcx/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskLEO/comments/2klr4p/have_you_eve... > In fact, in my jurisdiction a 3rd party saying you said you were going to kill yourself is enough to detain you in a psychiatric hospital for a few hours at least.
- chx 9y agoNeither there is one allowing assistance :/ I want to end in peace and dignity. Is that too much to ask? Apparently. There is a lot of assistance available that leads you to extend your life beyond the point where you can keep your dignity but none where you can just ... bow out. Whenever a trainer has asked what's my goal, my only answer was, I don't want to end up in a wheelchair in twenty years. My back already hurts a little pretty much constantly, I don't want to live long enough where it becomes unbearable and/or I can't even walk any more. Truly what's the point. And voicing these -- in my opinion entirely rational -- thoughts are almost taboo.
- rdiddly 9y agohttps://www.deathwithdignity.org/learn/death-with-dignity-acts/ https://www.deathwithdignity.org/learn/death-with-dignity-ac...
- 9y ago
- evanlivingston 9y agoBetter end-of-life care isn't a technological problem. When people have terminal cancer they are still usually advised or persuaded to take chemo and/or radiation, which royally destroy their bodies, as anyone who had a loved one go through treatment knows. In the case of many late stage cancer cases it's generally known that the person is at the end of their life, yet the medical establishment still tends to focus on treatment rather than actual care. How does machine learning help the cultural problem?
- deckar01 9y ago> it's generally known that the person is at the end of their life, yet the medical establishment still tends to focus on treatment rather than actual care That is exactly what they are trying to address. These doctors are basing their treatment on statistics that don't account for the intricacies of an individual patient's condition. A machine learning model can account for correlations between obscure attributes to predict the success of treatment with much higher confidence than they have now.
- AstralStorm 9y agoThe machine learning model can also be as wrong as the doctors at predictions. What happens then? Surely not a headline of "Stanford death model is worthless" right? Even worse if treatments are forgone or triaged based on output on some incomplete model. Older people already have trouble getting access to life saving surgeries due to mortality statistics. (And no doctor wants to have a dead patient on table, liabilities notwithstanding.)
- sharmi 9y agoOften in cancer, cure and palliative care are often one. Controlling the growth of cancer cells is needed to control pain. Often the pain caused by cancerous tumours cannot be suppressed by usual pain killers. The kind of medication given for cancer treatment has vastly improved in the last 10 years, atleast for the less aggressive forms of cancer (and yes, there is such a thing). As a corollary, there are also highly aggressive forms, the kind that sends chills into your heart.
- jasim 9y agoI'm not quite sure that doctors need AI to see the state of a terminally ill patient for what it is, but if the authority of a mystical-sounding blackbox helps them accept and act on that tough reality, that's fine by me.
- cheez 9y agoThere is a movie called Idiocracy which has some version of this. Pretty hilarious.
- eismcc 9y agoHaving worked in this space - dialysis - sometimes it’s better to let the patient gracefully decline versus degrading their quality of life with treatments that will not lengthen life and mage what time they have miserable. There’s a few companies already using ML to predict when a patient is a candidate for hospice / palliative care. It’s often cheaper, which is why it’s kind of a taboo topic.
- AstralStorm 9y agoObviously it is cheaper. Nobody can count days of life lost due to forgone treatments without a real trial with a control group. Which means using these tools is unethical if not outright criminal.
- fixermark 9y agoWhy is it unethical / criminal? This is already a calculus doctors, patients, and loved ones have to do. How does adding historical statistics to the discussion introduce an unethical / criminal aspect?
- phkahler 9y ago>> It’s often cheaper, which is why it’s kind of a taboo topic. That's a very strange point. Sometimes people think the doctors want to do everything they can "to save you" just to run up the bill. With that thinking, patients and their families would want to "save money". OTOH one may also interpret saving money as giving up and be angry that the doctor would put a price on life. You just can't win. Ultimately people and physicians need to put aside all of that and be able to objectively assess the situation. That's really hard to do particularly for the patient and family - I have no idea what it's like from the doctors side, but we had one that had his eyes wide open but couldn't drive the point home enough for the soon-to-be widow to get it.
- hughes 9y agoI feel like this AI is an attempt at making death marketable. And I mean that seriously. I think you and eismcc are right, that it is taboo even when it is arguably the best option for the patient. It would be difficult for a doctor to say "this multivariate optimization found a global maximum by stopping treatment" in a way that sounds ethical. But by attributing it to an AI that is mysterious enough to sound divine, the message might have a chance at being received.
- emveeoh 9y agoTailor-made for insurance companies...
- Asdfbla 9y agoAdd deep learning and even boring old survival analysis can make headlines as "AI predicts Death". (Not bashing the paper here, just the reporting.) Though I suppose making use of the large amount of unstructured health data is a good thing and something which classical statistical models which require relatively clean study data could have problems with.
- Herodotus38 9y agoI feel fortunate that I happened to check into HN today because this is an area where I have a lot of experience and I have made something similar (albeit much less advanced) that is currently in use by some physicians. Quick background: I am an internal medicine physician, and my focus is hospital medicine, so I actually see a lot of cancer patients suffering from complications related to progression of their disease, treatment, and have lots of end-of-life discussions. A couple years ago I had a case where I wished I had more data to drive me to make a prediction for a family who wanted to know when their loved one was going to die, and I felt like I didn't do a good job. I ended up contacting an oncologist Dr. David Hui who has done a lot of research into predicting end of life care. There are dozens if not hundreds of "prognostic calculators" out there that different groups have made over the years to try and find which variables X, Y, Z, can be used to better predict how a patient with cancer A, B or C will do. Most of them are not great and very specific. Some of them are general to all cancers, some are only for "advanced cancer" etc... So this isn't really a new idea, it's just that this is the first time someone has applied AI to it as far as I'm aware. The problem is these calculators are all buried in journals and have different inputs. What we did was collate some of the best validated ones and make it easier to check multiple prognostic calculators at once, with the idea that you could get more of a range or gestalt on the patient and use that info to help guide further decisions. In case anyone is interested the site is www.predictsurvival.com but it isn't for lay use so may not be of much interest to most here. I built it using Python and Flask and it's what I'm most proud of in my programming. Anyways, I knew someone would eventually use AI to try and tackle this question. I'll read their paper later tonight and I wouldn't be surprised if it ends up being far better than what I've done. I hope they make it open source. I'd be happy to try and answer any questions people might have about medicine and end of life care
- pwdisswordfish2 9y agoIf I am in the position of the patient, I would be horrified to hear an analysis tell me how much time I have left to live and how likely the death is. No matter what the system tells me I will still opt for whatever possible treatment in the case that the prognosis is wrong, or I fall in the ex. 10% chance of survival category. I just can't picture the doctor saying "the AI says there is a 90% chance of dying in the next month" and me choosing to die in peace at home. I'll keep fighting and take my chances.
- inimino 9y agoGood! Let's talk again when you're 70... Regardless of what decisions you make, having more information (basically a statistical aggregate of similar cases) should be useful information, no?