8 ms·
I would certainly hope so. > "This is a very difficult issue," he says. "Obviously most of us would think that the lawyer should just do what's in the best int
by emodendroket 9y ago
I would certainly hope so.
> "This is a very difficult issue," he says. "Obviously most of us would think that the lawyer should just do what's in the best interest of the client in the view of the lawyer."
That doesn't seem very "obvious" to me, any more than it seems "obvious" that a doctor should just go ahead and carry out a medical procedure he recommends after I refuse it.
- jasonlotito 9y agoIt's not that you are refusing a procedure as much as you are choosing a procedure that the doctor thinks will cause you more harm. I'm not saying this means the lawyer is right or wrong, just that the analogy wasn't quite right.
- jerf 9y agoI don't think that was intended as an analogy, but another example of when no matter how professional someone may be, we do not force their decisions upon the people being affected.
- jasonlotito 9y agoWell, then the example fails even more so as an example, but I can see what you are saying.
- emodendroket 9y agoAs far as I can see, changing the plea midway through is more like an intervention. And further weakening the lawyer's position, it appears he flubbed the procedure in several ways while doing so.
- tokenizerrr 9y agoIf you choose to have your hand cut off because you think it would be awesome, I'd hope your doctor would refuse to do it.
- harryh 9y agoIt's interesting to think about decisions that involve an action vs decisions that involve stopping an action. Doctor: undergo my recommended treatment or you will die Patient: no Patient: Doctor, please chop off one of my hands for no good reason Doctor: no In the former we respect the rights of the patient, in the latter we do not. Kind of weird isn't it?
- elicash 9y ago"First, do no harm." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primum_non_nocere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primum_non_nocere
- lolsal 9y agoin the first example the doctor is compelling the patient to do something and the patient exercises her right to refuse. In the second example the patient is compelling to the doctor to do something and the doctor exercises her right to refuse. You never have a 'right' to compel another person to do anything. You may have legal, ethical or moral reasons to compel someone to do something, but you never have a right to.
- harryh 9y agoI think this is mostly right but it is worth noting that in some cases doctors are obligated to act. If I run into the ER with a serious issue and a doctor says "sorry, I can't treat you right now, it's my coffee break" that can be malpractice.
- lolsal 9y agoUnderstood - but that is a legal or ethical obligation, not one of your rights.
- ABCLAW 9y ago>You never have a 'right' to compel another person to do anything. There are plenty of instances where you have the right to compel another person to do things.
- ams6110 9y agoYour lawyer should advise you but ultimately follow your instructions. If he feels (or knows) you are guilty and you want to plead otherwise, he should decline to represent you.
- brians 9y agoSurely if he knows you’re guilty, but they’ll never prove it, the question is more complicated?
- peg_leg 9y agoIf the mitigation of guilt is a not guilty plea then it's rather simple.
- buckminster 9y agoIn the UK a lawyer has duties towards both his client and the court. For a lawyer to lie to the court is a serious breach of his professional ethics. To represent a client he knows to be guilty on a not guilty plea is to lie to the court. In reality there is usually wriggle room concerning motive or the suitability of the charge, say. But I know a lawyer who has turned away clients who have flat out confessed to him.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIsn't there a famous movie scene where the murderer approaches a lawyer, who cuts him off and advises him on what a lawyer can do. (Anatomy of a Murder? Jimmy Stewart). He covers the issue of what the lawyer knows, and what he can do in each case. Pretty good writing.
- mcguire 9y agoI seem to recall another scene from Rumpole, where the character has taken on a student intern or something. While interviewing the client, the student asks, "But did you do it?" and Rumpole drags him aside and tells him, "Never ask that."
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoI do not want a lawyer that was either hired by me or assigned to me making decisions unilaterally for me. They are there to interpret the law for me and to present me options. I then choose what to do. If they still want to represent me, that's up to them.
- philipodonnell 9y ago> "This is a very difficult issue," he says. "Obviously most of us would think that the lawyer should just do what's in the best interest of the client in the view of the lawyer." Absolutely freaking not. This is not how professional services works. I hope this is not actually an endemic perspective in the legal community?
- stcredzero 9y agoThis is not how professional services works. That is highly contextual. A coworker of mine called that the "Physician <-> Prostitute Spectrum." Certain service providers will pretty much do whatever you pay them to. Other service providers will filter their request through their expert knowledge. This also depends on the nature of the request, of course. It's not like a Doctor is going to give you a sex change you didn't ask for, if things are working correctly. Whether to plead guilty should be up to the client, unless they aren't competent.
- philipodonnell 9y agoI get where you're coming from, but, there's a difference between not wanting to do a particular thing that your client wants you to do, and doing something different from what a client wants you to do. A better analogy would be going to a prostitute and insisting on a condom, but then the prostitute pokes some holes in it and becomes pregnant "because you seemed lonely so I thought a child might be best for you". That would be a case of requesting one service (protected sex not resulting in pregnancy) but getting an undesirable one (unprotected sex resulting in pregnancy) solely because the service professional disagreed with "what's in the best interest of the client in the view of the [prostitute]". Which, to put it mildly, is not what you paid for. :-) If a hired professional disagrees with a course of action that a customer has explicitly requested, the appropriate action is to decline to enter into a professional services arrangement, or break an existing one. Not just go ahead with whatever you wanted to do anyway because you think its better.
- stcredzero 9y agoA better analogy would be going to a prostitute and insisting on a condom, but then the prostitute pokes some holes in it and becomes pregnant "because you seemed lonely so I thought a child might be best for you". Not a better analogy. The same analogy. It's a counterpart to the unwanted sex change from the Doctor. (From what I've read, it's certain that an unasked for sex change was performed by some doctors on some infants.)
- mcguire 9y agoPerhaps yes, maybe no. Consider another case: the next time you have a head cold, go to your doctor and demand to have your left arm amputated. Or go to an engineer or architect and ask them to design something manifestly unsafe. One of the differences between a profession and a customer service job is telling the client "no" if the client is asking for something inappropriate.
- jeffdavis 9y agoThen say "no", don't say "yes" and do whatever you want.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThe defendant dismissed his first few lawyers, which is what should happen in this case. The suit is over his final lawyer, who rejected his direct instructions, announced his guilt to the court, and then sought clemency on a basis that wasn't even legally available. This is more reminiscent of the doctor refusing to amputate your arm, and then instead cutting off your little finger while you ask him not to.
- throwwwwaway9 9y ago>>"Obviously most of us would think that the lawyer should just do what's in the best interest of the client in the view of the lawyer." I doubt the lawyer has his client's interests in mind all the time: A new trial with more money coming up, media exposure, "25 years is jail isn't that bad, could've been life," "if we wrap it up by Tuesday, I can still make for Jeff's birthday party" etc etc. Lawyers are human and representing clients is a business. The most important period in your life is just another trial to him. Bottom line: Unless the lawyer is willing to do his client's time, he should be overruled by the person that really stands to lose, the client.
- Balgair 9y agoIf you see that happening, contact your local Bar Association. Example: https://www.sfbar.org/about/contact.aspx https://www.sfbar.org/about/contact.aspx
- throwwwwaway9 9y agoIt's not like he's gonna send you a certified letter stating those things. Especially public defenders that have another 100 cases having to attend to...it's math, x total hours a week and lots clients mean accept that freaking plea. Or lawyers that just found out that they will not get paid properly.
- dragonwriter 9y agoYou don't need a certified letter to file a bar complaint. Or even to get yet another lawyer and succeed in a malpractice suit, though the latter (unlike the former) may require some money up front.
- throwwwwaway9 9y agoanyone can complain, but what will you achieve. Let's rate representation from 0-100, with 0 or a negative being a drunk lawyer, sleeping through the trial, and 100 being the dream team, 10+ lawyers with unlimited funds. What if your lawyer rates a 15 (scale 0-100) and simply says that that's what I really believed, given the evidence and resources avail ? Who is going to disbar /blame him when he recounts the challenges he faced?
- sjg007 9y agoThe medical care one depends on agency of the individual, if it is an emergency and, if an adult, has a DNR or living will. Generally, adults can refuse care but the hospital/doctor/medical group will take the parent(s) to court for the benefit of a child. You see this from time to time when parents try to claim a non-medical exemption.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIf their client is unconscious and unable to communicate their wishes or is a child, then by all means let the lawyer use their own best judgement, but when the client is an adult who has been judged mentally competent, letting the lawyer override their client's express wishes is a disgusting infringement on their rights.
- Bartweiss 9y agoInterestingly, the guy saying that is supporting McCoy and claiming that the lawyer does need to respect the client's wishes. He's just claiming that it's an unintuitive legal requirement, where the rest of us seem to think it's a blatantly obvious obligation.