5 ms·
There are naturalized citizens everywhere in our security agencies. Many from former and current adversaries. They are full citizens. If they pass the backgroun
by kevin_thibedeau 9y ago
There are naturalized citizens everywhere in our security agencies. Many from former and current adversaries. They are full citizens. If they pass the background check they are entitled to the same privileges as any other citizen.
- joering2 9y agoTrust me you won't get TOP clearance if you are natcit (naturalized US citizen), only if you are soil-based citizen (actually born on the US soil)
- xxpor 9y agoWhat? This entire story is about the exact scenario you describe.
- xrayzerone 9y agoTrust me - you are 100% completely wrong.
- sevenfive 9y agoA job is not (just) a privilege.
- xrayzerone 9y agoA job in an intelligence organization requiring a high level security clearance IS a privilege. As a leader in an organization I worked for used to say, "You earn your place here every day." And plenty of naturalized citizens have earned their place.
- sevenfive 9y agoYeah, that's inspiring and all, but if you have a domestic and a naturalized candidate for the job who are both equally qualified, and the naturalized one has a 10% higher chance of being turned, just go with domestic right? Might not be "fair" to the naturalized candidate who worked hard to get where he was but fairness is not always the priority. Reminds me of the diversity debate at Google where google jobs are talked about like some kind of award or trophy of excellence and not just selling your labor to Google
- xrayzerone 9y agoYeah, that's a super plan and all. Doesn't work that way. And all foreign contact risks are quantitatively evaluated, for naturalized and US-born individuals.
- sevenfive 9y agoWell the grandparent disagrees with those evaluations. I have no opinion. My point is, there's a difference between deserving a job the most and being the best candidate for it. Whether someone has "earned" a job on a moral level should not be the only factor in hiring them. I am also surprised you decided to take your supervisor's motivational comment so literally.
- xrayzerone 9y agoHe was the CO. And we don't "motivate."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- atlantic 9y agoIt's probably that kind of politically-correct approach that creates skewed risk assessments in situations such as this one. Reality is what it is, not what we'd like it to be.
- Kalium 9y agoYour immigration and naturalization background is considered when you go through security clearance background checks. There's no tolerance for political correctness there, but neither is someone presumed to be a spy because they're naturalized.
- Veen 9y agoIt's not necessarily because of political correctness. A person with a family background and who may have been brought up in the target country has language skills and cultural knowledge that it would be difficult to learn otherwise. Those are useful skills for an intelligence agency to have. For example, a native Pashto speaker who spent their formative years in Pakistan is likely to prove a valuable asset, and it's hard to leverage that value without giving them access to sensitive information.