28 ms·
On Windows, developers of third-party screen readers for the blind are going through a painful transition where they can no longer inject code into application
by userbinator 9y ago
On Windows, developers of third-party screen readers for the blind are going through a painful transition where they can no longer inject code into application processes in order to make numerous accessibility API calls with low overhead.
All these isolation changes are ostensibly for "security", but I suspect DRM is at least part of the motivation; corporations want to be able to silo content more and restrict the free flow thereof. To a user, a screenreader is a benevolent helper; to them, it's a malicious "attack", a way of extracting and consuming content that they may not want.
- roca 9y agoThis is absurd. Browsers offer many ways to scrape DOM content that are far more effective than using a screenreader. No doubt there are people who wish DOM content was harder to scrape, but "make screenreaders suck" would be completely ineffective for that, and accusing browser developers of deliberately doing it is slanderous.
- taeric 9y agoMany of the screens people interested with prior to web 2.0 were much more flat in abstraction. You can simply look at early HTML to see how much simpler a document first format looks. The raw number of embedded div elements greatly complicates most screen reading.
- paulie_a 9y agoExcept pre 2.0 web was design by tables.
- taeric 9y agoNot really. It was certainly a way to do things. But it was less used than the current plethora of divs. Probably easier to understand programmatically, oddly.
- paulie_a 9y agoI built websites in the 90s and tables nested 5-10 deep was a common site
- taeric 9y agoI did too, but I don't remember it nesting to 10 that often. I grant that I likely just don't remember it. I recall most were like HN, embedding a couple of tables. My argument, though, is that 10 is basically just getting started with how nested most div based layouts are. The new "grid" world is a bit of an improvement. Probably a large one, honestly.
- dblohm7 9y agoNo, we're doing it because of all the problems associated with injected DLLs. Source: I'm the dev who built the foundation for this transition in Gecko.