5 ms·
IANAL, but: > Gender is a protected class Which means that businesses doing public accommodation are restricted from discriminating, but 'private clubs' (suc
by bmelton 9y ago
IANAL, but:
> Gender is a protected class
Which means that businesses doing public accommodation are restricted from discriminating, but 'private clubs' (such as the Boy Scouts), who have a narrowly tailored interest that is benefitted by discrimination against a protected class is generally allowed (subject to variances within state law).
For example, a group for men who have been sexually molested by men would likely be considered presumptively lawful, but a group for men who also happen to be car salesmen would likely not be.
There are a number of details that need to be considered as well, as (loosely) prescribed by _Rotary Club of Duarte[1]_, such as exclusivity (it can't be publicly available to be overheard), and purpose (already covered), but if neither conditions are met, and a state law prohibits such discrimination, then it meets (at least) a rational basis standard.
[1] - https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/481/537 https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/481/537
- JoeAltmaier 9y agobtw BSA now admits girls too. So maybe not the best example.
- bmelton 9y agoWhich, IIRC, they decided to do of their own accord, after having won suits around discrimination (e.g., _Dale_) Whether the point is mooted or not is up for discussion, but whether they have the right to discriminate is settled, according to the Supreme Court. They clearly do.