6 ms·
If the threat of regulation drops it 25%, that's not a very good store of value or medium of exchange.
by jedberg 9y ago
If the threat of regulation drops it 25%, that's not a very good store of value or medium of exchange.
- paulpauper 9y agoCompared to some currencies, it is. Brazil Real has lost 80% of its value relative to the dollar since 2013. I think this is overdone considered the last time Korea threatened regulation it only fell 10%.
- Matheus28 9y ago80%? Where did you pull that number from?
- hikarudo 9y agoUSD quoted in BRL achieved a minimum of around 1.96 BRL in 2013. Currently it is 3.23 BRL. So the Brazilian Real has lost 40% of its value relative to the dollar, not 80%.
- MagnumOpus 9y agoFirst, BRLUSD went from 0.488 at the start of 2013 to 0.309 now, which is only a 37% depreciation. Second, and more important, unlike crypto, BRLUSD paid 10%ish interest rates every year since then, so the total return of a US investor who invested into BRL currency forwards at the start of 2013 is +2.67%, a far cry from an 80% loss.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoNon sequitur. That only means that it is not a good store of value from before being regulated to after being regulated. If however, governments figured out some standard harmonized regulations and consistently enforced them, then afterwards there would no longer be a threat of regulation. In fact, getting regulation applied might actually reduce volatility, because the uncertainty about the threat of regulation would be taken out of people's pricing estimates.
- paulpauper 9y agoBy that logic if it goes to zero there technically is no uncertainty about the price nor any volatility
- nukeop 9y agoNo, it means its value is lower if governments try to mess with something they don't understand and want to ruin in fear of their power being diminished.