8 ms·
So, Navier-Stokes assumes infinite divisibility in the fluid it models, right? Which we know is not the case: atoms exist. It seems obvious to me that Navier-St
by andrewflnr 9y ago
So, Navier-Stokes assumes infinite divisibility in the fluid it models, right? Which we know is not the case: atoms exist. It seems obvious to me that Navier-Stokes can't be a perfectly accurate description of reality, so it should come as no surprise if they turn out to blow up or otherwise behave non-physically. Am I missing something? Why isn't it assumed that they're just a very nice approximation, like Newton's laws pre-relativity? Actually the whole thing reminds me of the ultraviolet catastrophe that preceded quantum physics.
- jerf 9y agoTone: Straight. I think you asked a reasonable question. What you are missing is that mathematicians are concerned about Navier-Stokes itself, as an independent entity in pure mathematics, not related to its physics correspondence. I think it would be safe to say that everybody believes that even if Navier-Stokes does have a singularity in it, that there won't be any way to manifest that singularity in the real universe with our discrete atoms. But that still leaves the math question, and the possibility that even approximating the singularity may produce interesting physics.
- whatshisface 9y agoOne reason to think the physics would be interesting: it isn't every day that we can arrange macroscopic systems in ways where their small-scale behavior gets amplified enough for us to measure. Arranging a blowup in the Navier-Stokes equations would be a way to study atomic-scale physics on human scales - and, likewise, arranging a blowup (if one exists) in the QCD quark-gluon plasma equations would allow us to get unexpectedly sensitive measurements of particle-scale physics.
- pixelpoet 9y agoA nice example of such a practical tool for microscopic analysis is X-ray crystallography, once you have the theory of Fourier transforms and lattices.
- Someone 9y agoYour repeated use of the word ‘blowup’ makes me think of the way we get small-scale behavior amplified enough for us to see, hear, and feel: in atomic weapons. There is a chance that understanding how quarks interact will give us even more powerful weapons (which might at one time be useful to blow up large incoming space rocks) or give us clean energy. How large that chance is is anybody’s guess.
- andrewflnr 9y agoI guess if you're looking for pure mathematical abstraction, Navier-Stokes doesn't seem like the most interesting without the physics connection. But that's just me.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoI suppose what is interesting is the very difficulties we have deciding if there are smooth solutions. It would be interesting if there are whole class of PDEs which are difficult in this way. And if there isn't, then what is special about the NS? That too, is interesting.
- andrewflnr 9y agoFair point, there.
- tw1010 9y agoThis is such a fun observation. Physicists originally used differential equations to describe large scale, yet fundamentally atomistic, behaviour because, I assume, that was easier to work with using pen and paper than by using some more discrete, computational, atom-by-atom model. And then computers were invented, but we're still stuck with these continuous, legacy, models. Almost no-one questions the fact that the original motivation for using the differential equation technique is no longer appropriate given that the underlying technology has shifted underneath the feet of the modellers.
- openasocket 9y agoWell, we still don't have the computational power to do things atom-by-atom, even in small things like modeling cells, let alone something like simulating wind shear on a plane or predicting weather patterns. It's not just computational power but memory. There's something like 1E14 atoms in a cell. Storing the x,y,z position with 4 bytes for each dimension (though you'll probably want 8 bytes) comes out to 1.2E15 bytes = 1.2 petabytes of information. Add in more fields for velocity and other pieces of state and you're talking about something that would only fit in working memory in some of our largest machines.
- tw1010 9y agoSure, but you'd think we would shift our focus to using models explicitly tailored with that aim in mind. Using something that explicitly approximates a desired, precise, foundation. Perhaps parameterized by model accuracy. I would think taking inspiration from approximation algorithms would be a much more appropriate lens with which to model physics.
- auntienomen 9y agoIn the case of Navier-Stokes, this was done in 1934 by Jean Leray, who showed that the so-called 'weak' solutions always exist. (A weak solution is not a function, but a more general object called a distribution which can be fuzzed out on very short distance scales.) It's a very reasonable idea, and useful enough for computations, but it lacks the essential tension that makes Navier-Stokes a mathematical Everest.
- auntienomen 9y agojerf correctly points out that the mathematicians are investigating the behavior of the mathematical model, not the physical phenomenon which inspired it. I want to add a second point, which is that while it wouldn't be that shocking if Navier-Stokes had blow-up or other non-physical solutions, it's not at all obvious that it has such solutions. People have tried and failed for more than a century to construct them. We know, in fact, that Navier-Stokes is very close, in a technical sense, to not admitting such solutions, as there are very mild deformations of the Navier-Stokes model which do not admit such blowups. Likewise, there are mild deformations which do. The beauty of Navier-Stokes is that it's so perfectly balanced between the two cases.
- pwnna 9y agoAs an aside, as the question of the article is more about the mathematics as opposed to the physics: Navier-Stokes assuming a continuum is one of the fundamental assumptions made in basic fluid dynamics, and to an extend applies to the governing equations for solid mechanics, in a whole field known as Continuum Mechanics. The continuum assumption, as it turns out, is actually incredibly accurate for most gasses that are comprised of discrete molecules. Specifically, the region in which N-S is valid for is when Knudsen Number[1] is less than about 0.01. Knudsen Number essentially characterizes how densely packed the particles are. This turns out to be most of the flows we observe on Earth. N-S becomes less accurate at around Kn = 0.1 and completely useless at Kn >= 1, as in this region the differential arguments no longer hold and NS predicts something non-physical. Some examples of flows in this regime: mass spectrometer, reentry, and inside shockwaves. In that view, you're not wrong that NS will eventually fail, but it is just applicable to most of what we do. For those working with fluids, it is important to recognize for when NS fails so they can switch to a different model for solutions. For higher Kn flows, such as Kn > 10, you can feasibly track individual particles and their trajectories. People do this for satellites and what not. However, between the range of 0.1 < Kn < 10, we do not have a good enough set of models that is able to compute accurate answers to reality with reasonable time frames and is an active field of research. If you're interested in learning more about this topic, look up the Kinetic Theory of Gas, where particles are accounted with the evolution probability distributions in temporal, spatial, and velocity space. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knudsen_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knudsen_number
- carstimon 9y agoLet me rebuke just one part of the post: the example with Newton's laws. Of course everyone knows that Navier-Stokes is just a very nice approximation. That doesn't mean that mathematical results about Navier-Stokes can't improve or understanding of the physics side. For instance, if we find a solution which blows up, that may lead us to a correction to the model or (less likely) it may be actually physically realizable.
- carterehsmith 9y ago>> So, Navier-Stokes assumes infinite divisibility in the fluid it models, right? Which we know is not the case: atoms exist. Atoms have structure, they consist of... whatever parts. And these parts have structure (like... quarks and whatnots). And... are we sure that quarks do not have structure themselves? Whatever the case is, it is not something that one should declare in a HN thread. Even more interesting... 1+2+3+4... = -1/12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1_%2B_2_%2B_3_%2B_4_%2B_%E2%8B%AF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1_%2B_2_%2B_3_%2B_4_%2B_%E2%8B... And that result actually pops up in physics. That kind of indicates continuity/infinite divisibility.
- twiceaday 9y agoThere is a standard definition of what '=' means and your equation does not satisfy it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuIIjLr6vUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuIIjLr6vUA
- carterehsmith 9y agoYou say "your" and yet, this has nothing to do with me. I pointed to the wikipedia article. BTW this result is not exactly new, and it has specific confirmation in physics. You cannot argue that with high-school math. There is more to it.
- twiceaday 9y agoThe bit on Wikipedia that follows the equation is part of the equation. It is the context that explains how to compute it. You need that bit because the equation uses extremely common syntax as short-hand for an operation that is different from the common one. If you write it in a way that doesn't rely on redefining common syntax like so "ζ(-1) = -1/12" it seems a lot less interesting doesn't it? Perhaps syntax confusion is the only interesting thing to it.
- carterehsmith 9y agoThere is more to it - the number -1/12 actually pops up in physics when doing something awfully similar to 1+2+3... This may be useful: https://motls.blogspot.ca/2014/01/sum-of-integers-and-oversold-common.html https://motls.blogspot.ca/2014/01/sum-of-integers-and-overso... " The real problem is that the definition of the sum involving the limit of partial sums – limits that way too often "diverge" or "refuse to exist" – isn't the only definition or the best definition or the most natural definition that may be connected to the sum. There exist better definitions of the infinite sum – numerous definitions that turn out to be more natural in physics applications – and they generally produce the result −1/12−1/12. It is no trick or sleight-of-hand. The value −1/12−1/12 is really the right one and the rightness may be experimentally verified (using the Casimir effect). "
- zakk 9y ago> So, Navier-Stokes assumes infinite divisibility in the fluid it models, right? You are right. > It seems obvious to me that Navier-Stokes can't be a perfectly accurate description of reality, so it should come as no surprise if they turn out to blow up or otherwise behave non-physically. The mapping between physical reality and Navier-Stokes equations is extremely well understood. We know when they represent an excellent description of the physical world, and we know when they could fail due to the finite number of particle in the fluid. We also know how they fail, and can estimate corrections due to finite particle number, see for instance the Cunningham correction factor. We also know that a much more complicated theory, Boltzmann transport equations, would be exact. It would be surprising if Navier-Stokes equations blew up, because we know they represent most often physical reality up to extremely small, controlled corrections. > Am I missing something? Why isn't it assumed that they're just a very nice approximation, like Newton's laws pre-relativity? Actually the whole thing reminds me of the ultraviolet catastrophe that preceded quantum physics. Not really: the ultraviolet catastrophe was a symptom of unknown physics awaiting to be discovered. We know very well the physics beyond Navier-Stokes, and still we use Navier-Stokes equations for their incredible effectiveness. Using the full theory (Boltzmann transport equations) would make even the simplest fluidodinamics calculation virtually impossible, while adding a correction on the n-th significant digit, with n much higher than the precision one could reasonably expect.