4 ms·
What's needed here is a "naming and shaming" effort. Make a public directory of bad PHP tutorials/references/etc., with the names of the people and companies wh
by smacktoward 9y ago
What's needed here is a "naming and shaming" effort. Make a public directory of bad PHP tutorials/references/etc., with the names of the people and companies who wrote and host them prominently attached. Maybe even give them a score, based on how frequently cited/linked to their bad advice has become, or how many pieces of it they've proffered. Then only take them off the list when the documents are cleaned up or removed.
If you're a professional PHP developer or a company that builds on PHP, it would be very embarrassing to find yourself prominently featured on such a list. Which would create an incentive for those people to clean up their work so they can get off it.
As things stand currently, publishing outdated and dangerous information costs the publisher nothing, so they see no reason to stop doing it. Create a cost by attaching reputational damage to the act, and you create a reason for them to stop.
- CiPHPerCoder 9y agoThat's certainly a novel approach to solving the problem. I'm hesitant to do this myself, because it might open us to legal action, and I don't have the emotional bandwidth or cash reserves to fight a lawsuit right now.
- thehardsphere 9y agoThis plan would fail, because someone sophisticated enough to find the naming and shaming list of awfulness would probably already be sophisticated enough to realize that old, bad advice is bad and why it is, and where to find new, good information. The problem is not merely that bad old content exists, but there is a class of PHP developer who is insufficiently sophisticated to distinguish between good and bad information independently. Whether that's a feature or a bug of PHP is an exercise I leave for the reader.
- astrodust 9y agoYouTube is littered with awful, preposterously bad tutorials. If there's one thing that'd fix PHP it'd be for the community to put out better, more prominent, higher quality material than the toxic dreck that's out there. This isn't to say that there aren't good YouTube videos, but for each one of these there's easily a hundred where people with no clue are explaining PHP as if they know everything.
- rypskar 9y agoIf that list become popular search engines will use it as a validation that the linked articles are good, so the bad tutorials will get better SEO and even more newcomers will find and use them. The list can even be an incentive to write bad articles since you get free references from this site, which give scamy authors more visitors and more income from ads
- Can_Not 9y agoActually I think there are SEO ways to link but also to tell search engines that you're not endorsing the link, probably called no refer or something.