4 ms·
This reminds me so much of the .COM bubble. Same kind of discussions. I think there will be a place for cryptocurrency but before that has been established ther
by maxxxxx 9y ago
This reminds me so much of the .COM bubble. Same kind of discussions. I think there will be a place for cryptocurrency but before that has been established there will be a lot of people taking a lot of pain. People who have bought them a few years ago will only take paper losses but now there is real money flowing into this.
- rcheu 9y agoOne technology related bubble eventually succeeding does not imply the eventual success of every technology related bubble. There are plenty of bubbles that never really recovered (ex. the Japanese stock market crash of 1989), and technologies that petered out (ex. tablets). Pattern matching to the first chart that comes to mind isn't a great way to predict the future. Instead, look for arguments why something will or will not be useful, since that's what actually will determine the eventual success or failure.
- tbabb 9y agoI have seen comparisons to the .com boom/bubble, and I don't buy it. There was a lot of economic movement while the entire economy moved over to the internet. Those who didn't adapt failed. Those who tried models which didn't translate also failed. Lots of experimentation, and lots of reinventing things from scratch. So lots of failure and lots of speculation-- but ultimately around a real sea change. I don't see how blockchain tech could have a technological / cultural impact on that scale. It has some value, and it will find its place in mainstream society, but I don't see how/why the market needs to test everything against it to reinvent itself as was done when the internet came to the fore. I could see that for sure with AI, but blockchain? Seems pretty specific and limited. Much more hype and much less substance than the .com revolution, IMO.
- tessierashpool 9y agothis makes a lot of sense to me for the simple reason that during the dot-com boom, the world wasn’t packed with people who remembered a dot-com boom.
- eth1 9y ago.com allowed for freedom of information crypto is allowing freedom of value. it's more disruptive
- CPLX 9y agoI keep asking people this simple question, which goes something like this: Before the internet, I would wake up in the morning and have to go to a store and buy clothes, then the travel agent to book flights, then Blockbuster to get a movie to watch. After the internet I could wake up in the morning and do all that myself. That was valuable. Before smartphones I would wake up in the morning and print out my airline tickets, then call a taxi service and have to explain to them where I was, and I couldn't tell where the driver was if I didn't see him. OK, got all that? Now, with cryptocurrency I will wake up in the morning and do what? I could send money to buy drugs, that's a pretty killer use case. There are some things like transferring money out of a war torn country that maybe it would help that have some value, but I'm not in a war torn country. So... where's my killer use case? It's important to note that all the internet/smartphone examples above are INCREDIBLE use cases, and that's just scratching the surface. Booking travel used to SUCK now it's better. I can get books instantly. I can collaborate on music or video production across the country. And so on, these are big deal things. There are TONS of examples. The business opportunities here were utterly massive. Nearly everything people and businesses did on a daily basis changed in consequential ways due to the internet in ways that opened up opportunity for profit. And even with that said most of the people who saw the promise of the internet in 1997-2000 and put money into passive investments got creamed. Now, in all seriousness, what's my morning going to be like with crypto as a mature technology, how will it be different and better and why will I care? When will this happen, why hasn't it already happened, and how are all these people going to profit from the change?
- maehwasu 9y agoAn anti-pattern that I see on HN is very smart people spending lots of energy thinking of all the ways that something can't work. Whenever you have a tough problem, there are usually only a couple ways it can be solved, and infinite reasons it's hard to solve. The fact that your imagination can't come up with killer use cases does not mean that those use cases don't exist. It means you haven't exercised your imagination very hard. Further, if I think I know what crypto's killer use cases will be, also think that I can prove concept as to those use cases within 1-2 years, and I have enough money to fund that process, why would I explain those cases to you? If you're constantly waiting for concepts to be proven, you'll always feel behind the curve and wondering why others have way more money than you, even though you're way smarter than they are. Imagination, vision, and the willingness to push beyond initial analysis are probably worth 20-40 IQ points in terms of lifetime earning potential.
- colemannugent 9y agoYup. AMZN traded at around $100 in 1999, then $12 just a few months later. Now if you believed in Amazon's business model and bought at that low you could have made about 120 times what you invested if you sold today. For me I look at crypto the same way. Crypto's value is going to fluctuate over time, but I think that over the long term (5-10 years) it will become more stable and more valuable. A huge dip is a great time to buy. It also helps to only buy crypto for fun and consider it akin to gambling :)
- Jtsummers 9y agoThese currencies, as they like to call themselves, will only become stable when there's a basket of goods you can exchange them for at a consistent price. Right now it's all speculative investing and a little bit of spending as a currency. Once you can buy $10 of goods, consistently, for 0.0001 BTC (or whatever) then the price will be stable and the currency can establish itself. The same is true for the other cryptocurrencies. Being unpegged from any other currency or any goods, and nearly useless for conducting business transactions means the value will remain wildly unstable with a significant non-zero risk of failure or effective failure (going to $0 or something not much above that with little interest in conducting business using the currency).
- tbabb 9y agoAgree 100%. Cryptocurrency can't be money until it measures stable value. And that stability is literally impossible without a central bank. http://www.bzarg.com/p/what-bitcoin-shows-us-about-how-money-works/ http://www.bzarg.com/p/what-bitcoin-shows-us-about-how-money...
- qsucvatz 9y agoThat long term stability may be impossible with a central bank.