5 ms·
>John Stuart Mill’s notion that a “marketplace of ideas” will elevate the truth is flatly belied by the virality of fake news. Wow. I think this sentence is a
by whatshisface 9y ago
>John Stuart Mill’s notion that a “marketplace of ideas” will elevate the truth is flatly belied by the virality of fake news.
Wow. I think this sentence is a great example. The author makes no attempt to convince us that fake news is actually winning out over real news - they just assert it along with their primary claim in the hope that we will be carried along into both by the momentum of their article.
Yellow journalism goes back to the beginning of press freedom and lying goes back to the beginning of speech. We've had ways of combating these things for generations - ways that can't be used to make false statements - but people have always wanted to reach over and silence their opponent through (sometimes abstract) force. The problem with that? Your opponents can sometimes do it to you, too.
- ataturk 9y agoSix corporations own all the major news outlets. Six. They are agenda setting beyond belief and somehow this is what the conclusion is? WTF? There has never been a time in history when more speech, more independent and informed speech has been necessary! What we also need are people willing to put down the ideological bong and start thinking for yourselves.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y agoThere is a communication mode that can't be used to make false statements, really?
- whatshisface 9y agoIt's a bit off-topic, but there are indeed many! The simplest that I can think of is the grammar that produces all statements of the form (N not gates) <-> (N+2 not gates). Although, the search for a real answer to your question is an active subject in philosophy. What I was really talking about was how there are a huge number of "methods of convincing" that work better for the truth than for lies - sometimes so much better that they essentially don't work for lies at all. An example of that kind would be pointing at an object everyone can see and saying, "that thing, there."
- optimuspaul 9y agothis response confused me more than the initial statement. I don't understand how anybody can be prevented from making false statements.
- infogulch 9y agoGP's point is more narrow than you are taking it. You think he's saying: > There is a mode of communication in which true statements can be expressed easily and false statements cannot be expressed. Which would be nice, sure, but cannot exist, hence your confusion. But what GP is actually saying is closer to: > There exist some forms of communication for which some statements are so trivially proven that lies are pointless because they'll be disproven almost instantly. This makes no claim about which statements can be expressed like this, let alone all of them, just that it's possible to have some statements expressed like this; which is a necessary precondition to inventing something more generally applicable.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThe handwringing in this article over how a few publishers now control almost all distribution is also odd to me. Certainly I'm not thrilled by that situation, but why the pretense that it's a novel situation? People like Hearst and Murdoch have had massively outsize control over news distribution in the past. And before that, when the supposedly-outdated First Amendment was being written, control of publication largely accrued to whoever could get distribution into a given spot. These are not unprecedented challenges, and seeing an article like this casually discard their historical context makes me worry that it is in fact criticizing free speech for all the usual reasons.
- woahdudebro 9y agoYou'd think someone so opposed to "fake news" as it's called would also be a fan of centralization. The mainstream news coverage of the 2016 election was objectively in favor of Clinton with perhaps the exception of Fox News and a few other small outlets, if you were to presuppose that her election was the "correct" outcome for democracy wouldn't that be exactly the direction you would follow?
- Bartweiss 9y agoCynically? I think they are fans of centralization, and they're trying to own the narrative by confusing what the word means. The emphasis on centralized publishers hides a meaningful difference between distribution and control. The article complains, not wrongly, that optimizing for engagement rewards clickbait and bad facts. But they're not actually centralized news sources, and it looks like the op-ed writer is ultimately lamenting the loss of centralized content control. As OP here points out, most of the article relies on naked assertion with no real argumentation, much less evidence. The standout to me is: > This is not a call for nostalgia... But back then, every political actor could at least see more or less what everyone else was seeing. Today, even the most powerful elites often cannot effectively convene the right swath of the public to counter viral messages. If it's not a call for nostalgia (or a legally-enforced return to the past), it's hard to see what it is a call for. The article repeatedly asserts that more true speech is useless against bad speech, so it can't be that. That lament for the 'most powerful elites' who can no longer convene "the right swath of the public" to propagandize to? Really doesn't seem like the writer is eager for everyone to have a voice.
- mcguire 9y agoWhat "can't be used to make false statements?"
- optimuspaul 9y agoI think the article spells out the problem very well. Entities can craft fake news that appeal to very specific audiences and target them so directly that the majority doesn't even know about the fake news. The message can be tweaked slightly for different audiences to push or pull them from one view to another. This is a huge problem. There is no mechanism that can verify the messages are true. It was widely reported that this is exactly what the Kushner organization did during the Trump campaign. I'm not saying Kushner created fake news, but his organization did in fact push highly targeted messages that influenced people in ways that one might consider dishonest. It is a problem, the article lays it out. It could do better (as could I) to convince, but I find it hard to believe that someone like yourself can't convince yourself with the data available. Fake news is real, but it's not what Trump says it is. (Fake news is real, lol)
- Goladus 9y ago> Fake news is real, but it's not what Trump says it is. It's also not what this Wired author says it is. === Originally, the term "Fake News" was created by mainstream news organizations (aka old media) to denigrate all competition (legitimate or not) from social media. It was a branding campaign meant to poison the well against outside sources. Trump just turned the language against them, since he benefited from new media. The reality is that the only thing that will work is for individuals to apply critical reading skills and evaluate the content for what it is. Big news brands don't want that, though. They want people to think "real news is us, fake news is them"
- whatshisface 9y agoThe best I can do is convince you that the difference is one of quantity, not kind. All liars tweak their lies for the weaknesses of their perceived audiences. Governments all across the political spectrum have sat in back rooms, carefully considering what the people should be made to think. That's been going on for a very long time. You can't create a pannel of lie-destroyers because the liars would just see them as another audience to capture. The only solution, as uncomfortable as it might be, is to mix people so well that there's no way to lie to a target without a nearby non-targeted friend finding out. What does that look like in practice? A marketplace of ideas. If people are captured in filter bubbles, you have a thousand local monopolies of ideas.