2 ms·
Every body you add to such a project today would cost well over $100K per body. Not only are you paying the worker, you need a manager for that worker, a mana
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
Every body you add to such a project today would cost well over $100K per body. Not only are you paying the worker, you need a manager for that worker, a manager for the manager. And then you'd have to pay more because unskilled labour today would slow the project down significantly.
The alternative is UBI, which should cost under $20K per body, and would give people an alternative to accepting a BS market-driven job just to put food on the table.
- crdoconnor 9y agoEven if we accept your figures (personally I find them dubious), the cost of paying UBI to everybody will outweigh the cost of paying for JG for the minority actively seeking work unless more than 1 in 5 are actively seeking.
- notahacker 9y agoDifference is that a "basic job" costs up to $100k per head for the number of people who need money enough to be willing to dig a hole all day for it. Let's be generous and assume that's all 4.3% of the working age population registered as unemployed and actively looking for work in the UK, even though some of the might be more disinclined to register as looking for work if they were required to accept work digging holes. So taking your unusually high staff cost ratio of 5x salary, that's $100k per head for 4.3% of the working age population. UBI might only cost $20k plus admin costs per recipient, but as you're paying it to well over 20x as many people it's well over 4x the cost. And you don't get the hole... I'm not convinced Basic Job programmes are a fully scalable welfare replacement, or that agriculture or construction work would be a particularly good focus for a more limited workfare programme, or that advocates of such ideas have necessarily considered the risk of crowding out paid work at proper salaries, but the idea that indiscriminately doling out money to people irrespective of whether they've indicated they might want it is cheaper than welfare state alternatives is palpably false.
- fwip 9y agoIf you're paying a worker and 2 managers, that's 3 bodies. Not one.