7 ms·
“Swatter” Tyler Barriss Charged with Involuntary Manslaughter
- andrewksl 9y agoUh, not that this guy doesn't deserve to be charged, but what about the cop who shot an innocent, unarmed man?
- HenryBemis 9y agoI believe that the article mentions that this is being handled. Let's see what will happen in 3-6-12 months.
- louhike 9y agoWe just know he is on temporary leave.
- trowawee 9y agoThere'll be an investigation, he'll be cleared, and he'll be back on the street in a few months.
- HenryBemis 9y agoI hope he gets the maximum sentence. Then I hope they dig up as much as possible of his past dirt and then lock him up forever. Then I hope they round up more SWATters and give them the same treatment. I won't go into to details of what will happen to this wimp behind bars, he doesn't look so tough. But it cannot be that some stupid "kid" somewhere murders people for fun. (no use to discuss police and use of arms in the USA)
- apexalpha 9y ago"Police responding to the alert surrounded the home at the address Barriss provided and shot 28-year old Andrew Finch as he emerged from the doorway of his mother’s home. Finch, a father of two, was unarmed, and died shortly after being shot by police." I'm sorry but this whole article is ridiculous. Yes, calling the police on someone for jokes is absolutely not okay, and he deserves punishment for it. But it seems very farfetched, and honestly pretty insane, that the police murdering an unarmed man is something you should consider happening when you call the police. The police have the guns, they are responsible for using them. Whether the call is a hoax or not, the police should not kill anyone unless they absolutely have no other choice. If someone is unarmed this is obviously not the case. It is ridiculous that this article tries to frame some idiot for murder / manslaughter. The police killed the guy. No one else.
- reificator 9y agoI understand where you're coming from, but I think it's less reasonable because the caller and the victim (and the SWAT team) are American.
- apexalpha 9y agoAre you implying that if you call the police in the U.S. you just need to accept that there is a chance that you get shot? Even if you are unarmed? A 28 year old person was shot dead when he opened his door. In what universe is anyone responsible for this except for the fucking police, shooting the UNARMED guy who simply opens the door at his mothers house? Honestly we live on the same planet, but in different worlds.
- cornyNetHandle 9y agoThe universe where someone else intentionally coerced badly trained and overarmed idiots into being there and made them think they might be shot at.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoYou do not open the door when the bell rings, you go on the floor like any sane person? Im sure OP is lying there right now in a puddle of freedom.
- newfoundglory 9y agoIn this universe, if you call the police and say you are an armed man holding hostages, you should expect that you will get shot. The fact that someone was shot based on a malicious false report like this wasn’t even a surprise, for many people. It was literally expected to happen at some point. You are confusing a description of how the world “should be” with how it “is” - he is being charged based on how the world is.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> Are you implying that if you call the police in the U.S. you just need to accept that there is a chance that you get shot? Even if you are unarmed? Well, it happens - http://edition.cnn.com/2017/07/17/us/minneapolis-woman-killed-by-police/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2017/07/17/us/minneapolis-woman-kille...
- fab13n 9y agoSeen from Europe, this is ludicrous. Police killed that guy. Swating as a prank is possible in the US because of US police's hysteria. And it's police hysteria that escalated a nasty prank into homicide--if not murder. [EDIT for clarity]: it's ludicrous that prankster and police officer aren't both charged. Police incompetence is no exoneration of Tyler's responsibility, and conversely, Tyler's criminal actions are no excuse for the police officer's lethal lack of judgement/restraint. Of course Tyler is a criminal, I thought it went without saying.[/EDIT] The core problem is that it's OK for US police to kill US citizens, and it's essential not to shift the blame. By primarily blaming Tyler (who's a super-nasty piece of shit, but that's another issue), medias and justice reinforce bad police officers' sentiment of impunity. In most developed countries, if a cop shoots someone who wasn't actually about to kill someone, he's criminally liable. His career is over, and his freedom in jeopardy. If he wrongly "felt threatened", that's poor judgment and incompetence, certainly not an excuse. And whether the victim was guilty of anything or not isn't a mitigating factor either: it's exclusively up to the justice to say so and to punish. That's why Judge Dredd isn't called Copper Dredd.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoBy primarily blaming Tyler (who's a super-nasty piece of shit, but that's another issue No, that is absolutely not another issue. If we don't hold people responsible for misusing these resources, there simply is no remedy here. SWAT teams cannot be expected to be fully prepared for both a hostage situation and a so-called prank. Pranks are generally fucked up shit anyway. Pranks that can turn deadly so easily should not be called pranks. They should be labeled serious crimes and prosecuted accordingly. Furthermore, I get rather tired of blow hard Europeans imagining they know what is best for internal matters of the US and that policies that work in their country would obviously work exactly the same here. If your country works better than the US, good for you. That isn't evidence that you know what is best for the US.
- gambiting 9y ago>> SWAT teams cannot be expected to be fully prepared for both a hostage situation and a so-called prank. Seeing how often these "pranks" happen, I would say they absolutely have to be prepared that the entire situation is fabricated. I agree with OP - the officers should be charged with murder of an innocent person, the responsibility to identify the situation is 100% on them.
- JamesBaxter 9y agoMy perspective from the U.K. is that it’s primarily the swatters fault but the terrible action taken by the police is somewhat “allowed” by US society due to fear of guns being available. I was trying to figure out how prevalent swatting is in the U.K. and if it could go this wrong. At least here the police don’t have to be as afraid of an armed defence which gives them less of an excuse for overreacting
- pjc50 9y agoI've found a Brit involved in a US swatting: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/robert-mcdaid-charged-tyran-dobbs-swatting-hoax-call-swat-terrorism-maryland-shot-gun-explosives-a7677071.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/robert-mcdaid... And someone swatted Mumsnet: https://www.newstatesman.com/sci-tech/2015/08/troll-hacked-mumsnet-and-sent-armed-police-founders-house https://www.newstatesman.com/sci-tech/2015/08/troll-hacked-m... But generally the lack of trigger-happy police makes it much less likely in the UK. I suspect a lot of protocol was built up in the era of regular (most, but not all false) bomb threats from the IRA.
- bb88 9y agoI said that's what he should get two weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16057578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16057578