2 ms·
Yeah - I 100% agree that a judge will interpret this appropriately, but the dumb idea of "corporate personhood" still means there's questions to ask about who g
by bigiain 9y ago
Yeah - I 100% agree that a judge will interpret this appropriately, but the dumb idea of "corporate personhood" still means there's questions to ask about who genuinely risks going to jail in a cross jurisdictional problem like this.
It's pretty clear "Uber the legal person" is pretty happy breaking laws and has a long history of not suffering any real personal consequences. I'm reasonably sure a Canadian judge doesn't even have an existentially dangerous penalty they could apply to Uber-the-legal-person. Worst case seems to be they could shut Uber down in Canada and jail some local senior management. Uber-the-global-corporation probably has contingency plans and has determined and budgeted for that risk. That's their "business as usual".
"The law", while generally robust locally against clever constructs, is probably not as effective a tool against globally distributed corporations - at least not in a very satisfying "Yeah, someone's gonna pay for that" kind of way...
- bigiain 9y agoAnd in case my self-admitted Uber hate impacts anyone's view of that last sentence - see also Apple stashing huge cash reserves off shore to reduce their tax burden or Starbucks running a a loss in high tax countries by paying high prices for coffee and royalties to parts of themselves in more favourably-taxed countries - "Oh look, we made no profit in this country, no tax for _you_!"
- bigiain 9y agoAnd a day later... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-tax/apple-plans-new-u-s-campus-to-pay-38-billion-in-foreign-cash-taxes-idUSKBN1F62FJ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-tax/apple-plans-new... At least they're choosing to pay - at least in the US - and only after the Trump administration cut the tax rates, but still...