4 ms·
Oh man, Android does that too? This awful, terrible, no good fake "AI" behavior on iOS was one of the many quality issues with modern iOS that was making Andro
by epistasis 9y ago
Oh man, Android does that too? This awful, terrible, no good fake "AI" behavior on iOS was one of the many quality issues with modern iOS that was making Android look more attractive.
iOS keyboards have been getting worse with every update, probably as more and more engineers feel the need to make a mark, or are required to fix bugs, and they spoil it. The simple and predictable statistical model of the original iOS was better than what we have now. So much of iOS was better back then, IMHO.
- ShabbosGoy 9y ago4 years ago was a very different time. Software quality in general continues to drop. I’m not sure if that’s due to increasing incompetence in the software engineering workforce (unlikely, but possible), malice (more unlikely), or apathy (most likely). When wages don’t grow over 10 years, what incentive is there to write the best software you can?
- gboudrias 9y agoI find it more reasonable to assume that you can only improve a very specific function so much before your "improvements" turn to "pointless sidegrades".
- Trav5 9y agoWell said. I have seen a lot of sidegrades over the past 10 years!
- Radim 9y agoI suspect the cause is a little more subtle (and terrifying). The majority of people don't give a shit. Correct spelling and obscure searches are not even on their radar, it's not a part of their reality. Don't let the comments here fool you -- it is a very specific, picky, technical crowd that frequents HN. The voice of "those who care" has always been a minority, although it used to matter more, simply because people who care and worry and try to do a good job tend to have more power and money (conscientiousness is a great predictor of success), and so businesses cater to them more. Now that everything seems to be turning more uniform, more global, more binary, more equal, that voice is marginalized (good thing? bad thing?) -- you're seeing the effect of a hoi polloi stampede. So it's not the fault of "incompetent programmers" -- it may be a trickle down effect of our social incentives and economic trade-offs.
- emmelaich 9y agoYes, this the real reason. It's a variation on the Tyranny of the Majority. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
- fishmeat 9y ago> The voice of "those who care" has always been a minority To add to this, people who cares most powerfully had probably switched to alternative, open source, software solutions. This leaves the remaining group with less "care" on average so fewer would complain. Kinda like evaporative cooling.
- josteink 9y ago> 4 years ago was a very different time. Software quality in general continues to drop. I’m not sure if that’s due to increasing incompetence in the software engineering workforce (unlikely, but possible), malice (more unlikely), or apathy (most likely). I think another dimension is how deployability has changed. Before... When you wrote and shipped software, getting your software out was a big problem, a big deal. This also meant that if you shipped a bug, shipping an update would be equally expensive (for you and your customers), and the amount of goodwill you lost would be quite tremendous. Now everyone has a appstore, always up to date apps, and whatever else is usually "in the cloud" somewhere. The time of people installing applications in a normal desktop-context, with installers and having IT-administrators handle updates once every second year is surely long gone. With that kind of change, and an increased focus on delivering early, doing proper QA is no longer something which is rewarded in the market. Who cares if you made a bug-free, awesome service, when you did it 6 months after someone else shipped a similar, but buggy service which everyone is already using? They have established a user-base and as such already has social momentum and lock-in. What do you have to offer which is not only fantastic enough to make some bother migrating, but also so amazing that these people will also go convert their friends and families? "Less bugs" alone is not going to cut it. Basically, taking the time to deliver quality software these days is increasingly something you get punished for in the market-place. The result? We get shit like this and we can only blame ourselves.
- pjmlp 9y agoThis will only get fixed when software starts to get liability and refunds. If enough people start suing or asking back for their money, companies will surely improve their QA.
- gaius 9y agoOn BlackBerry if it autocorrected to something you didn’t want, one press of delete would revert to your original word. iOS makes you a) rekey the whole thing and b) will probably try to change it again. I can only assume that no one (or moons, it literally just tried) who works on this uses it themselves!
- klodolph 9y agoOn iOS, one press of delete and what you originally typed will show as a suggestion.
- gaius 9y agoFor a replacement? Or for the next word?
- eltoozero 9y agoThat’s only when you actually catch it mid stream. Once you hit space and start a new word it’s game over. Frequently happens at the worst moment when you’re trying to mash out a complex explanation in a rushed fury.
- epistasis 9y agoThat's not true for this situation. For the "deep" replacements more than a word back that we're talking about, and also other changes that happen without any user notification via blue text popups, there is no easy way to fix without the long process of moving the cursor.
- kakarot 9y agoI always thought Blackberry had the best autocorrect experience. My old Blackberry would occasionally surprise me by catching something I wouldn't think it would know about, and after some initial tuning never ever frustrated me. It only enhanced my experience.
- gaius 9y agoI’m on an iPhone now but in many ways it’s a step backwards from my old BlackBerry Pearl, let alone the Bold I got next
- nyolfen 9y agoyou can turn off autocorrect
- colordrops 9y agoIt would be better if you could turn off some autocorrect features and leave others. It has a lot of facets, and autocorrect is great when it works.
- Normal_gaussian 9y agoI don't know how easy it is to switch keyboards on iOS, but its a great idea on Android. I use Minuum - looks whacko at first but let's me use way more of the screen when replying and it is really accurate!
- dillweed 9y agoEasy bit wonky swift key is probably the best