4 ms·
> This is a particularly egregious example of the pop-sci genre This is the model of Nautilus, Quartz, and a bunch of other online publications. It's fun to re
by paulcole 9y ago
> This is a particularly egregious example of the pop-sci genre
This is the model of Nautilus, Quartz, and a bunch of other online publications. It's fun to read so what's wrong with it?
- jules 9y agoOn the one hand, I like that they're doing old physics. There is a tendency to do only cutting edge physics such as modern quantum mechanics research, particle physics, even string theory. There is little chance to convey an accurate understanding of this to a layperson. Every part of physics was at the cutting edge at one point in time. The physics that is now hip will be old in 100 years, and it will be no longer interesting for science journalists. Celestial mechanics, classical optics, classical electrodynamics were at the cutting edge some time ago, and they're still super interesting. They also have the advantage of being thoroughly understood, so there's a chance to convey genuine understanding. In that sense, this article is great: it truly explains Fermat's principle as a physics college student would learn it. It would be even greater if it had more physics and less metaphysics. On the other hand, would that have reached the front page of HN? Probably not.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoBecause it is dull, long winded and misleading. Perhaps it is fun for people who like being misled?
- epicide 9y agoThis was my thought. I think the article reads almost like a children's Did You Know? kind of book: it presents the problem and just enough background information to understand it, then leaves the mystery for the reader to go and find out more. I could see the argument that there is a fine line between leaving a bit of mystery and just plain lazy writing.
- xaedes 9y ago> then leaves the mystery for the reader to go and find out more. When the reader is interested by the mystery and really goes to find more on his own, isn't that wonderful?
- natecavanaugh 9y agoI think it's the same reaction that police or lawyers have with watching crime procedurals, or why software engineers get disgusted by how "hackers" are portrayed in most popular media. However, I think this sort of simplified shorthand, with a bit of innocent embellishment (the whole mystery aspect of how nature does it) keeps people interested. It could be something that gets someone interested in discovering more. I think any simplification could be viewed as misleading, but I think these sorts of articles really do more to educate than if they were to only be clicking celebrity gossip or worthless listicles.
- pishpash 9y agoThey don't educate anything. They generate crackpots who spread more pseudoscience. True science can be explained simply and clearly with good understanding and good communication (think Terrence Tao's blog) without dumbing it down.
- natecavanaugh 9y agoThank you for the response, and I will Google Terrence Tao for the link, but maybe adding a link will help others? I don't disagree with you, but honestly, Id rather argue science with a crackpot that only has 50% of the info than the crackpot who refuses to, and can't understand anything above 0%. It's like literacy. I'd far rather live in a world where most people have a 50% literacy rate rather than in a world where 0.5% has a genius level of literacy and the rest are illiterate. Sure it's a weird, cold calculation, but in the pragmatic part, I'm happy to accept the compromise.
- abecedarius 9y agoThat this model exists is OK; that it dominates pop science is a problem. I wish there were a lot more books like the one by Feynman that I linked to in another comment, which focus on real understanding. We can't all be Feynman, but we can try to do better. (I haven't read the OP because it sounds like things I already know.)